Presumed Innocent diverges from the book with a shocking twist ending: Who killed Carolyn?

Presumed Innocent diverges from the book with a shocking twist ending: Who killed Carolyn?

As a devoted fan of “Presumed Innocent,” I couldn’t contain my excitement as I sat down to watch the much-anticipated season finale on Apple TV+. The suspense had been building week after week, and the stakes were higher than ever. I was fully invested in the story of Rusty Sabich and his trial for Carolyn Polhemus’ murder.


As a passionate gamer and avid fan of “Presumed Innocent” on Apple TV+, I’ve been eagerly waiting for this moment. And finally, it’s here! In the season finale, which premiered on July 24, I got the answers I’ve been craving. Did Rusty manage to win his life-altering trial? Who was truly responsible for Carolyn Polhemus’ death? The suspense was killing me, but now, I know it all. Plus, a few other mind-blowing revelations were thrown into the mix. What a thrilling ride!

If you’ve read Scott Turow’s book with the same title, get ready for an unexpected twist as the series deviates from the novel’s identified killer. (Written in first person perspective of a gamer)

As someone who takes their viewing experience seriously and hates having surprises ruined for them, I can’t stress enough how important it is to heed warnings like “Major spoilers ahead.” Having had my share of disappointments from knowing too much about a show before watching the finale, I understand the value of that warning. It’s not just about avoiding disappointment or frustration, but also about preserving the emotional impact and enjoyment of the climax. So, if you value your own viewing experience, take heed of that warning and don’t proceed until you’ve seen the finale!

Presumed Innocent diverges from the book with a shocking twist ending: Who killed Carolyn?

Who killed Carolyn?

Towards the close of the episode, it is revealed that Jaden (played by Chase Infiniti), who is Rusty’s daughter, committed the murder of Carolyn. Initially, Rusty points an accusing finger at his wife, Barbara. However, unbeknownst to them, Jaden had been listening in and later confesses to the crime.

On the night when Carolyn was tragically killed, Jaden decided to visit her house to discuss the ongoing affair between them. His main objective was to ask Carolyn to keep away from his family. However, an unexpected revelation came up during their confrontation – Carolyn announced that she was pregnant with Rusty’s child. This shocking news pushed Jaden over the edge, causing him to lose control and react impulsively. In a fit of rage, he seized the nearby fire poker and inflicted lethal blows on Carolyn, ultimately taking her life.

Afterward, it came as a surprise when Rusty went back to the house; this fact had been hidden from everyone until his unexpected announcement. Suspecting Barbara of killing Carolyn, Rusty staged her body to resemble the Bunny Davis crime scene. His aim was to create a new suspect and potentially clear his own name. Furthermore, he manipulated Liam Davis into possibly implicating himself during interrogation, offering him a reduced sentence in return.

To put it simply, Rusty took actions not just to exonerate himself, but also to shield Barbara from accusations. Unbeknownst to him, his daughter was actually the one responsible for the deeds.

In Turrow’s novel, Barbara turns out to be the hidden culprit behind the crimes, despite an intriguing plot development. I strongly advise giving it a read if you haven’t already!

Presumed Innocent diverges from the book with a shocking twist ending: Who killed Carolyn?

Rusty is found not guilty of Carolyn’s murder

In the final stretch before the surprising climax of “Presumed Innocent,” we witness the trial’s concluding days unfold. Rusty takes the stand to present his closing argument, emphasizing that the prosecution lacks any forensic proof. They are missing the murder weapon and have yet to establish a definitive time of death.

Tommy’s closing statement remains persuasive, yet it fails to convince the jury. As a result, they declare Rusty “not guilty” in relation to Carolyn’s murder, bringing an end to this long-standing allegation against him.

Later on, Nico accuses Tommy of having feelings for Carolyn, but contrary to his hostile behavior towards Rusty and his self-assured demeanor, Tommy was actually blameless in this situation.

Regarding the fire poker, Jaden took it to Tommy’s place, fearing her father could lose the court case. Following Carolyn’s murder, Jaden went back home, washed the car, and hid it in their garden.

After discovering Barbara’s infidelity with Cliffton, the bartender, Rusty secretly installed a tracking system on her vehicle. When he observed the car heading to Tommy’s residence, he mistakenly believed Barbara was there for a poker game, unaware that Jaden had borrowed the car instead.

As someone who has always been intrigued by gripping legal dramas, I can’t help but express my enthusiasm for the conclusion of “Presumed Innocent” season 1. The captivating storyline and exceptional acting left me on the edge of my seat throughout each episode.

Read More

2024-07-24 22:25

Previous post Monty Python and the Holy Grail joins Magic: The Gathering
Next post The Jaguar Three?: Will Jaguar TCS Racing Sweep The Championships in 2024?