Movies

Leave Chappell Roan Alone

BBG News

Leave Chappell Roan Alone

As a movie critic who has spent my fair share of time navigating the complex world of celebrity culture, I can wholeheartedly say that Chappell Roan is not just a musical prodigy, but also a beacon of courage and resilience in an industry that often demands more than it should. Her journey is reminiscent of a modern-day Odyssey, filled with the Sirens’ calls of fame and fortune, the Scylla and Charybdis of fan expectations and societal pressures.

“Please refrain from troubling Chappell Roan, her father, or her sibling. It’s crucial not to create a scene with her during public events such as the red carpet.

Although Roan has achieved great success in the upper echelons of pop music at just 26 years old, she’s had a difficult period. Not only has she experienced unwanted encounters with fans in places like airports, parties, and even during heated arguments with her partner, but she’s also struggled to adapt to the demands of being a contemporary artist in today’s world.

In a current article featured on Rolling Stone’s cover, Roan expressed, “A part of me secretly wishes I never achieve another hit song, as no one would ever anticipate anything from me…” It is not unprecedented for the artist to harbor such feelings. During an interview with Drew Afualo for The Comment Section podcast in July, she openly discussed her concerns that her growing fame poses a threat to her family’s security. Consequently, she has deliberately slowed down any initiatives intended to increase her visibility.

Since the popular singer publicly expressed her boundaries with fans and the entertainment industry on social media, she’s faced negative feedback and criticism. She’s been labeled as “weak” and “passive-aggressive” for canceling a string of European concerts, which were later disclosed to be due to rehearsals for the MTV Video Music Awards. Some have called her “insincere” and “distasteful” for choosing an awards show performance over performances for them. The term “ungrateful” has been hurled at her as well – a label that pop stars throughout generations are all too familiar with.

Modern society often turns pop stars into contemporary divine figures, living deities who walk among us. These celebrities act as avatars, fulfilling our desires and needs. Although idolizing individuals is not a novel idea, the unprecedented closeness demanded by our culture for celebrities warrants careful scrutiny.

Musicians and their supporters have often had a complex, interdependent connection. It’s impossible for one to flourish without the other. Fans provide essential backing for musicians’ careers, and in response, they feel nurtured by their beloved artists—whether it’s through heartfelt lyrics, uplifting messages, or captivating performances. This bond can be seen as a two-way relationship, or even an unspoken agreement, if you prefer to think of it that way.

Beyond just individual fans, there’s a larger system at play. This includes paparazzi, gossip websites, and the non-stop 24/7 social media cycle; fan clubs, some of which have both economic power and political influence; and these elements collectively blur the line between feeling connected to an artist and feeling entitled to their work, as if they work for us.

The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, combined with celebrities’ frequent live appearances on streaming platforms like Instagram Live, Twitch, and others, sparked a change in people’s habits.

During the pandemic, when people worldwide were in quarantine and grieving the loss of loved ones, celebrities became a source of comfort and companionship. As the bond between fans and these stars grew stronger during those difficult times, it has persisted even as life returned to normal. Now, fans are eagerly following the day-to-day activities of their favorite pop stars. Gossip sites anonymously track their movements, and enthusiasts flock to their preferred restaurants in hopes of catching a glimpse of them in person. This obsession has led to the emergence of members-only clubs as the latest celebrity sanctuary. Fans have even started replicating their beloved celebrities’ shower routines!

But herein lies the difference between love and hate, fandom and obsession. One is rooted in agency and autonomy, the other in domination and control. When fandom transforms into obsession, the manifestation of that can show up in insidious ways. 

History has often shown us instances where individuals in the limelight have faced challenges similar to what Selena Quintanilla Pérez, Britney Spears, Amy Winehouse, or Maren Morris experienced. For example, Selena was murdered by her fan club president, while Britney shaved her head as a response to relentless media harassment. Amy Winehouse faced intense criticism from the media and fans before her death. More recently, Maren Morris stepped away from country music in 2021 following hateful comments she received for supporting transgender rights causes.

TopMob contributed significantly to the decline of these women’s lives. One might ponder: If we adore our pop stars so much, where is the affection shown towards them? Where lies the human compassion in this situation?

Roan’s question, in essence, revolves around reinforcing one’s identity. She highlights the significant role that groupthink plays in perpetuating a harmful system that ultimately affects everyone negatively.

Alternate Version: It’s not just her who’s experiencing it; Hayley Williams, the lead singer of Paramore, has also gone through this. Women in the entertainment industry I know have faced similar issues. Social media has intensified the problem. I’m grateful that Chappell is addressing it honestly and immediately. It takes courage, and unfortunately, it’s necessary.

It’s perfectly fine for celebrities to set limits with their fans. In some cases, setting these boundaries, when both parties agree, can challenge and potentially mend the harmful aspects of fan worship culture.

America should be prepared to respect the boundaries of pop stars, as it’s crucial for their safety and well-being. Failure to do so might discourage upcoming female artists like Chappell Roan from entering or continuing in the music industry due to fears of harassment, doxxing, stalking, and other harmful behaviors from fans, often referred to as “stans.

It’s also something that Chappell Roan and her female counterparts in pop cannot do alone. It is the responsibility of the fan to check for any harmful behaviors that can result in the greater erosion and silencing of women in pop. Call it a “Femininomenon” if you must. But it’s really giving artists the respect they deserve.

Read More

2024-09-13 22:06

Previous post The Critic review: It’s Agatha Christie on steroids (and McKellen’s magnificent)