Action RPG

Fans React To Elden Ring Movie News: ‘We’re In The Best Hands Possible with Garland’

BBG News

Just a few short hours have passed since the announcement of an upcoming live-action Elden Ring film, and the fanbase is already expressing their thoughts – a mix of excitement and apprehension. I, for one, can’t help but share my own feelings!

As a passionate gamer, I’ve found myself immersed in various discussions surrounding this upcoming game we’re all eagerly anticipating. Questions about its origins, from opting for a cinematic experience instead of a TV series, to the selection of Alex Garland as director – he’s known for Ex Machina and Civil War – and whether the complex narrative should revolve around the Tarnished or other elements of the game world. George R. R. Martin, who penned A Song of Ice and Fire and played a role in crafting Elden Ring’s universe, is on board as a producer for this project, along with Vince Gerardis.

One gamer lamented, “Why, oh why? Please, keep FromSoftware out of Hollywood!” Another expressed disappointment, “I had hoped it was merely a joke. The film, I fear, will be a visually appealing chaos.

Concerns have arisen among some fans due to the fact that much of Elden Ring’s narrative seems to be implied rather than explicitly stated, with the majority of its interpretation being left to the community.

The challenge in turning Fromsoft Souls games into movies lies primarily in the fact that most of the game’s lore is open to interpretation by players. The games themselves don’t provide straightforward explanations about their storylines, which works well for these games as it encourages exploration and discovery. However, a movie must cater to a wider audience and be more explicit in its storytelling. This could potentially take away from the appeal of the game’s mystery. One player suggested that if the story were centered around the Tarnished, a character who can be easily understood by newcomers, it might work better. Another thought that a movie focusing on the game’s lore or NPCs could be possible.

It’s worth noting that many gamers are pleased with the choice of Garland as the director, considering his obvious passion for gaming. Beyond his impressive resume in game writing (having penned Enslaved: Odyssey to the West and DmC: Devil May Cry), he recently disclosed on a Reddit AMA that he’s currently deep into an NG+6 playthrough of Shadow of the Erdtree, demonstrating his unwavering dedication to gaming.

The player inquired, “Have you watched Garland’s movies?” To which I replied, “They are outstanding films, but somewhat peculiar and they tend to elicit divided opinions. They carry a strong artistic flavor that some find off-putting due to their peculiarity. In my view, this very quality makes him the ideal choice for an Elden Ring movie since he can effectively handle the ‘weird’ aspect.

This player commented, “Garland’s work is truly exceptional, and while it might seem unusual for him to direct this, he did create Ex Machina, a film that was quite unconventional. However, given his talent, it could turn out to be extraordinary.

This enthusiastic player remarked, “Regardless of personal opinions on an Elden Ring film, there’s no denying we’re in capable hands with Garland. If you’re still unsure, I suggest checking out his video with Neil Druckmann. Trust me, they will stay faithful to the original source material.

Currently, there’s no official word on the storyline, character choices, and launch date for the Elden Ring movie. Fans are also tossing around ideas, such as a humorous suggestion for Jack Black to portray Godrick or Torrent, while some have proposed Chris Pratt for the role of a Tarnished character.

Beyond the cinematic realm, Elden Ring has maintained its allure among gamers by offering additional content since its debut. In 2024, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree was released as downloadable content, and next week, players will gain access to a standalone multiplayer expansion titled Elden Ring Nightreign.

Read More

2025-05-23 15:58

Previous post Knives Out
Next post An Elden Ring Movie Is in the Works for Some Reason