Agatha All Along Is Loads of Clever, Campy, Witchy Fun

Agatha All Along Is Loads of Clever, Campy, Witchy Fun

As a longtime fan of enigmatic rock stars who vanished mysteriously, leaving behind a trail of captivating music, I was immediately drawn to the tale of this Formvie-Nicks-like figure. Being a woman and a lover of all things witchy, gothy, and ’90s cult classics, Agatha’s debut on Disney+ felt like a magical homecoming. The production design is nothing short of dazzling, and the camp quotient is delightfully high, making it a perfect blend of autumn coziness and Halloween-season spookiness.


10 minutes into the debut episode of the captivating new Marvel series “Agatha All Along“, you might find yourself questioning if you’d started the wrong Kathryn Hahn show. Contrary to the powerful witch Agatha Harkness, whom Wanda “Scarlet Witch” Maximoff defeated in the finale of “WandaVision”, her character is introduced as Agnes, a sassy, flannel-wearing, rule-breaking police detective investigating a murder in a typical small town. Her main adversary? An FBI agent tasked with keeping her in check, played by Aubrey Plaza. It has a strong resemblance to “Mare of Easttown”. However, what’s quite disconcerting is the over-the-top acting from Hahn and Plaza, two exceptional TV actors known for their superb performances.

The initial hint that the show Agatha, a spin-off from the series’ creator Jac Schaefer (who has released the first two episodes on Disney+), is playing around with us a bit, comes from its peculiar, overly rigid performances. Kathryn Hahn is putting on an exaggerated act reminiscent of her character in Mare, as Wanda (Elizabeth Olsen) has taken control of Agatha’s powers and imprisoned her within the same suburban nightmare that had previously been Wanda’s own journey through family-sitcom tropes in the series named after her. We don’t get to learn about all the Strong Female Lead roles Agatha might have endured during the three years she spent trapped in the TV trope-inspired Westview, New Jersey. Fortunately, Agatha is not a repeat of WandaVision, and its foray into detective drama gimmicks is merely the beginning of many enjoyable, culturally aware surprises it has in store.

Agatha All Along Is Loads of Clever, Campy, Witchy Fun

As a passionate movie-goer, I’ve come to find that the series unfolds like the classic hero’s journey, but with an intriguing twist – our antagonist, Agatha, is the one embarking on this quest. Drawn out of my TV trance by an enigmatic teenage admirer, portrayed masterfully by Joe Locke from Heartstopper, who sports black fingernails and disregards his “boyf’s” phone calls, Agatha decides to regain her powers. She embarks on a legendary path known as the Witches’ Road, a supernatural freeway shrouded in mystery, some claim it’s merely a myth, while others see it as a perilous route to death. However, folklore whispers that a witch who successfully navigates its trials will receive what she’s missing – and Agatha isn’t ready to settle for being just the nosy neighbor of Westview.

For the disgraced witch to stand a slim chance at finding the legendary path and ultimately claiming her reward, she must first overcome her tarnished standing within her own community and assemble a group of skilled occultists to aid her in passing its trials. The intriguing blend of forlorn outcasts, brought to life by talented actors, is what makes the series so captivating. When Agatha confronts Lilia, a renowned musical theater performer turned street psychic with a grudge against Agatha’s perpetuation of negative witch stereotypes, she finds herself working alongside Jennifer Kale, a wellness entrepreneur whose questionable practices have landed her in legal trouble. Lastly, Alice, who was discovered providing security at a mall Hot Topic and is revealed to be a descendant of a popular rock star known for recording a hit song meant to summon the path, then disappearing, joins their ranks.

Agatha All Along Is Loads of Clever, Campy, Witchy Fun

In this series titled “Agatha,” characters like Locke and Plaza, who exhibit a dynamic reminiscent of “Killing Eve,” add an edge that appeals to female and LGBTQ+ viewers who may not always find a comfortable fit in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The visual aesthetic is striking, with a high camp factor. It satirizes female-oriented media, from “Mare” to the luxurious kitchens and cashmere attire of Nancy Meyers’ films. While it touches on the perils of dark feminine archetypes, it does so in a way that’s more humorous than preachy, avoiding tropes like trauma-driven narratives or empowerment porn. The overall atmosphere harks back to the comforting, supernatural vibe of ’90s female-centric cult classics such as “The Craft,” “Practical Magic,” “Hocus Pocus,” “Charmed,” and “Buffy.” Even the queer classic “The Wizard of Oz” lends a touch of its yellow-brick magic. Whether this is pandering or not, it’s executed so entertainingly and strategically timed between autumn comfort and Halloween spookiness that, as a member of the potentially targeted audience, I found myself more entertained than offended.

The show isn’t necessarily out of trouble yet, but it still has some hurdles to overcome. Marvel’s struggle to attract viewers outside the usual superhero demographic is partly due to their mishandling of characters they create, as seen in some recent productions like Chloé Zhao’s Eternals and The Marvels, directed by Nia DaCosta (known for reviving Candyman). These projects, despite having talented female directors, have been marred by questionable ideas. Shows starting with promising concepts, such as Captain Marvel film and the Ms. Marvel series, soon fell into the repetitive pattern of action-heavy Marvel productions. Streaming platform Disney+ seems to be grappling with letting go of traditional franchise norms to create genre-blending Marvel shows akin to Netflix’s psychological thriller Jessica Jones or the first season of FX’s trippy Legion. Out of everything they’ve attempted, WandaVision came closest to bucking the trend. However, its ending was underwhelming, not just featuring Agatha and Wanda exchanging fireballs against a digitally created crimson sky, but also revealing that the destruction witnessed was caused by a woman’s uncontrolled emotions. This was certainly disappointing.

Agatha All Along Is Loads of Clever, Campy, Witchy Fun

Perhaps you understand my concern when Marvel Studios’ streaming head Brad Winderbaum states that “Agatha” entices with the amusement of Halloween, only to find oneself shedding tears unexpectedly. I don’t require a tearjerker from a clever witch series, and it would be disheartening to discover that this is what the Marvel team believes women and LGBTQ+ individuals should expect in entertainment. Nevertheless, after four episodes, “Agatha” has yet to show any flaws. Here’s hoping the Maiden, the Mother, the Crone, and undoubtedly Our Lady of Easttown keep it consistent.

Read More

2024-09-19 05:06

Previous post Salem’s Seven explained: Who are Agatha All Along’s Marvel villains?