A Single Star Trek Data Mistake Created the Smartest Villain in TNG History

by

The show featured many unforgettable villains, with the Borg and Romulans being the most well-known. However, those were large-scale threats. Professor James Moriarty, who first appeared in Season 2’s “Elementary, Dear Data,” quickly proved to be a formidable opponent, and his introduction to the series was a complete surprise.

The holodeck character of Sherlock Holmes unexpectedly became one of the most compelling villains in The Next Generation. Known as Moriarty, he proved so popular with fans that he returned in the Season 6 episode, “Ship in a Bottle,” and even reappeared years later in Picard. Moriarty’s development made him a truly unforgettable antagonist in the series.

Star Trek Gave Fans the Perfect Sherlock Holmes Crossover

Season 2 of Star Trek treated fans to a delightful surprise: Data and Geordi La Forge used the holodeck to bring the stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to life. This was a particularly fitting concept for Data, as the Sherlock Holmes tales emphasize skills he excels at, like logical thinking and deduction.

But when Geordi and Data try to make the game more challenging, it backfires. The issue is Data’s incredible memory – he remembers every Sherlock Holmes story ever written, letting him solve the mystery almost instantly. This ruins the game for Geordi, who points out that the fun is in the process of solving the mystery, not just knowing the answer.

Okay, so Geordi really thought he was clever trying to give Data a challenge in this holodeck scenario. He asked the computer for a new Sherlock Holmes mystery, but here’s where he messed up. Instead of telling it to create a powerful villain for Data to fight, he asked for someone who could simply outthink him. It’s a subtle difference, but it’s a crucial one, and it immediately sets Data up for a much more complex problem than Geordi anticipated. It wasn’t about brute force, it was about mental agility, and that’s where things get interesting – and difficult – for our android friend.

What started as a simple request unexpectedly resulted in a remarkably intelligent version of James Moriarty, played by Daniel Davis. This Moriarty became aware of himself and his surroundings, and cleverly used that knowledge to his benefit. Unlike other characters in the holodeck, he didn’t just follow a pre-written storyline.

He learned how to interact and manipulate the ship’s interface and kidnapped

Read More

2026-05-14 14:38