Movies

You Won’t Believe the Marvel Movie That’s WORSE Than Morbius & Madame Web

BBG News

I can’t help but be taken aback by the scathing reviews for Marvel Studios’ lowest-rated live-action film, a movie that even fell short of the disapproval given to titles like “Morbius,” “Madame Web,” and “Kraven the Hunter.” Yet, it’s important to remember that while today’s greatest Marvel films rule Hollywood, this wasn’t always the norm. Prior to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) timeline revolutionizing superhero storytelling with box-office giants, Marvel properties often struggled in adaptation. The most striking example of these early missteps stands out so starkly that even Marvel’s other infamous flops appear almost flawless by comparison.

Prior to the 2000s and the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), DC had a stronghold on superhero films, as Batman and Superman both had long-running film and TV series that spanned over more than fifty years. Meanwhile, Marvel found it challenging to keep up, producing only a small number of TV movies and direct-to-video releases. One particularly noteworthy flop from this era was a movie released in the 1990s, which holds the worst rating on Rotten Tomatoes among all live-action Marvel films.

1990’s Captain America Movie Has A 6% Critic Review Score On Rotten Tomatoes

In the 1990s, the version of Captain America portrayed in that film has an unusually low rating of 6% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes. This is incredibly rare for any superhero movie, especially one featuring such a renowned character like Steve Rogers. Directed by Albert Pyun and starring Matt Salinger (son of the esteemed author J.D. Salinger), the 1990 film version of Captain America was an unusual direct-to-video release in the U.S., despite initially being intended for theatrical release. It circulated through various international markets, often appearing in the wake of other unsuccessful superhero attempts from that time period.

It’s not just about age or genre prejudices; even low-budget, cheesy horror and action movies from the ’80s and ’90s can gain some retrospective admiration. However, this was never the case with Captain America. While the audience score is a bit higher at 19%, this still signifies a remarkable lack of approval for a character who would later become a central figure in some of the highest-rated Marvel Cinematic Universe films. For instance, Sony’s Madame Web, which was heavily criticized upon release, currently has an audience rating of 54%.

The reviews for the movie “Captain America” on Rotten Tomatoes are especially harsh yet amusing. Tim Brayton from Alternate Ending describes it as “unbelievably dull, painfully slow, stretching its 97 minutes to a point where time seems to lose significance.” On the other hand, Zac Hecstand from Film Inquiry advises that watching the 1990 Captain America movie serves as a lesson for any aspiring filmmaker on how not to produce a superhero flick.

The 1990’s Captain America Tomatometer Score Falls Below Many Of Marvel’s Least Successful Movies

In terms of how poorly this film is regarded, even among the most panned Marvel-linked movies, the 1990 version of Captain America ranks as one of the least favored. The Sony Spider-Man Universe has three notorious flops – Morbius, Kraven the Hunter, and Madame Web. Even Marvel’s infamous 2015 film, Fant4astic, which only managed a 9% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, is considered worse. I can comfortably say that the 1990 Captain America movie sits below all of these.

Movie Critics Score Audience Score
Captain America (1990) 6% 19%
Fantastic Four (2015) 9% 18%
Madame Web 11% 54%
Kraven the Hunter 15% 73%
Morbius 15% 71%

In more straightforward terms, these three recent catastrophes were criticized for poor storytelling, lackluster acting, and subpar special effects, but still managed to outperform the 1990 Captain America film. It’s not that contemporary films are given a free pass – if anything, viewers and critics have become more demanding over time. The fact that Captain America performs worse in reviews despite being viewed through the lens of nostalgia suggests significant flaws. It’s not about having unrealistic expectations; rather, the movie truly is as rough as many found it to be.

Why The 1990’s Captain America Movie Has Such A Low Review Score

Almost everything took a turn for the worse with the 1990 version of Captain America. To begin with, the budget was shockingly minimal for a superhero movie. With production costs roughly estimated at $3 million, it barely stood a chance against blockbusters like Batman (1989), which boasted a budget of $35 million and an acclaimed director in Tim Burton. Instead of investing in impressive sets, sophisticated costumes, and convincing special effects, the Captain America film relied heavily on cheaply made sets, ill-fitting costumes, and frequently humorous special effects.

In a puzzling plot twist, Red Skull, Captain America’s longtime adversary, was transformed from a German Nazi into an Italian fascist, a move that didn’t enhance the narrative and instead blurred the historical accuracy of the story. The character’s appearance was erratic, with him shifting from grotesquely disfigured supervillain to ordinary mob boss in the middle of the film. The editing was rough, the acting lacked depth, and the dialogue ranged from uninspired to preposterous. Even the action sequences were perplexing.

Each of these elements played a role in the disappointing critical reception of Captain America’s movie, as indicated by the small number of reviews – only 17 – compared to more recent films that can gather hundreds. Despite this being spread over several decades and including opinions from professionals who revisited the film both before and after the rise of the MCU, it’s notable that not a single one out of five reviews gave it a positive rating. This is quite critical indeed.

In addition, the film seems to struggle due to its outdated feel. While some ’90s movies maintain a charming retro appeal, Captain America (1990) fails to evoke that sense of nostalgic fun. Instead, it appears dated in a way that feels more disheartening than appealing. In contrast to cult classics such as Flash Gordon and The Rocketeer, it seems lacking in style, unity, and emotional depth.

1990’s Captain America Review Score Shows How Major The MCU Captain America Movies Really Are

In the year 2011, the movie “Captain America: The First Avenger” hit the screens. It was not just any ordinary film; it carried the might of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) with it. Despite this, the anticipation surrounding it was immense. Captain America embodies ideals and moral purity, a characterization that can easily veer towards being overly sentimental or flat. However, Chris Evans skillfully portrayed the character in a way that resonated deeply, paving the path for his further development. The Russo brothers later enriched the character in “Captain America: The Winter Soldier” and “Captain America: Civil War,” demonstrating that he could serve as the emotional and philosophical heart of the entire MCU.

These movies didn’t merely thrive; they outshone expectations. “The Winter Soldier” boasts a remarkable 90% critic rating on Rotten Tomatoes, while “Civil War” takes it up a notch with 91%. Even the supposed “weakest” of the trilogy, “The First Avenger,” still manages an impressive 80%. This stands in stark contrast to the 1990 adaptation that missed the mark in portraying Steve Rogers and even posed a significant threat to the character’s cinematic future.

The fact that such a dismal phase could be succeeded by such remarkable peaks makes for one of the most compelling comeback tales in superhero lore. The 1990 version of ‘Captain America’ isn’t merely a poor film; it serves as an intriguing testament to the evolution of superhero cinema. It demonstrates that characters as revered as ‘Captain America’ necessitate the perfect setting, the appropriate tone, and indeed, the adequate funding. In the absence of these crucial components, even a symbol of American valor can fail to make an impact with its star-spangled image.

Read More

2025-04-25 14:22

Previous post FBC: Firebreak Gets June Xbox Game Pass Release Date
Next post If your Oblivion Remastered save files are mysteriously disappearing or not syncing between devices, don’t worry: It’s not your fault, they’re just getting sent to the wrong place