This 94% RT Christmas Classic Is a Rare Box Office Flop That Still Holds Up as a Masterpiece

by

Today marks the 79th anniversary of the premiere of It’s a Wonderful Life, a truly classic film. Starring James Stewart and Donna Reed, the 1946 movie directed by Frank Capra was initially expected to be a hit. Critics at the time generally agreed, and Time Magazine even predicted it could be one of the year’s best films.

Despite being a beloved classic today, It’s a Wonderful Life wasn’t initially a financial success. RKO Radio Studios actually lost money on the film when it was first released. It easily could have been forgotten, appreciated only by serious movie fans. However, a quirk with its copyright prevented that from happening, and it eventually became the popular holiday tradition we know and love.

George Bailey’s Journey of Broken Dreams Was Too Bleak for Post-WWII Moviegoers

Just a year after World War II ended, Americans were still recovering from the immense hardship and loss, similar to what they’d experienced during the Great Depression. Returning soldiers had been profoundly changed by their experiences, and many families were still mourning loved ones. Combined with ongoing worries about the economy – stemming from both the war and the Depression – audiences in the mid-1940s weren’t prepared for a film as somber as It’s a Wonderful Life.

Don’t let the heartwarming reputation fool you – It’s a Wonderful Life is actually a pretty somber film. It centers on George Bailey, a man who always dreamed of traveling the world and becoming wealthy, ever since he was a young boy helping out at the local pharmacy. But, like life often does, things don’t quite go as planned for George.

Through the eyes of the angel Clarence, we see George Bailey repeatedly postpone his own dreams to help others. When his father unexpectedly passes away, George sacrifices his chance to go to college so his younger brother, Harry, can pursue his education. George takes over the family business, Bailey Brothers Building & Loan, believing it’s only temporary – Harry will eventually return and George can then follow his own path.

When Harry comes back, it opens doors for his brother, though George is still left to manage the Building & Loan, much to his frustration. Resigned to his situation, George marries Mary, who has always loved him, and they start a family. Together, they make the Building & Loan more successful than ever before.

When war begins, George is unable to enlist because of the hearing loss he experienced while rescuing his brother, Harry, from drowning years earlier. The excitement and potential heroism of war are therefore closed off to him. Despite this disappointment, George tries to remain positive, secretly hoping that his selflessness and endurance will eventually be recognized.

It’s a Wonderful Life’s Overall Message Takes the Long Way Around

George quietly carries his unhappiness, finding contentment in a life he didn’t initially envision. He deeply loves his family, yet still feels a lingering desire for excitement. Adding to his struggles, he’s constantly harassed by Mr. Potter, the town’s ruthless banker, who is determined to ruin the Building & Loan and take over Bedford Falls.

Okay, so things really fall apart when George’s uncle, Billy, misplaces the bank deposit – and wouldn’t you know it, it ends up with the awful Mr. Potter! This leads to accusations of wrongdoing at the Building & Loan, and it’s just the final straw for George. He desperately tries to get money from his life insurance, but it hits him hard that his family would actually be better off financially if he wasn’t around. He even swallows his pride and asks Potter for help, but that old grinch just cackles and turns him down. It’s heartbreaking!

George Bailey feels completely hopeless, leading him to consider ending his life. He plans to jump from a bridge, believing his life insurance will at least provide for his family. Luckily, Clarence, a guardian angel, appears and shows George what life would have been like if he’d never existed.

The story concludes with George understanding that even though he didn’t achieve his original ambitions, staying in Bedford Falls was the right thing to do. He made a positive difference in the lives of so many people. When George faces a crisis, those he’s helped over the years rally to support him, providing the money he needs and demonstrating just how much he means to the community.

It’s a Wonderful Life Struggled at the Box Office for Several Reasons

Hollywood has always struggled with how to depict suicide, and the America of the 1940s was still healing emotionally after World War II. Given that the film featured George Bailey, a character who both avoided military service and ultimately chose suicide when facing hardship, it’s easy to understand why the movie initially received a negative reaction.

I always find it fascinating to learn about the behind-the-scenes struggles of classic films, and It’s a Wonderful Life had a particularly rough time. It seems unbelievable now, but back in the late 40s, with everyone so worried about Communism, even the FBI questioned the movie! They actually thought portraying a wealthy banker like Mr. Potter in a negative light was a tactic Communists used to criticize the rich. It was the start of a really difficult period in America, where suspicion and fear seemed to follow everyone for years, and this movie got caught right in the middle of it.

Despite its heartwarming message, It’s a Wonderful Life wasn’t a hit when it was first released. Audiences, facing a difficult post-war world, weren’t receptive to the film’s strong dose of nostalgia and feel-good emotions. The movie’s high production costs also contributed to its struggles. Ultimately, It’s a Wonderful Life lost $525,000 in theaters and was considered a major box office failure.

Copyright Renewal is Everything In the Film Industry

The sale gave the buyer the rights to the movie itself, as well as the ability to show it on TV, use its music, and adapt the original story it was based on. This meant TV stations could broadcast the film.

The film gradually became a beloved Christmas tradition, shown on hundreds of TV stations each year. By the 1980s, watching it had become a family custom. Throughout the 1990s, the broadcasting rights were sold several times before NBC secured them exclusively in 1994.

It’s striking how differently people view the film today, considering it was initially considered a failure in 1946. Perhaps the world simply wasn’t prepared for George Bailey’s powerful message: that even through difficult times, a person’s life is ultimately what they make of it. The true value lies in the relationships we build, the family we cherish, and appreciating the wonderful life we’ve been given.

Read More

2025-12-20 17:09