The Chilling True Story Behind HBO’s The Yogurt Shop Murders

by

Thirty-three years ago, I thought I was just heading out for a delightful fro-yo run in Austin, Texas. Little did I know that day would turn into a heart-wrenching tragedy as four young ladies lost their lives due to a senseless shooting on December 6, 1991.

A group of four teenagers – Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison, and Eliza Thomas – aged between 13 and 17, tragically lost their lives. They were found dead, with their belongings taken, in a secluded area at the back of a store. The shop was later burned down. This chilling case, which has baffled investigators for over three decades, is now the focus of a HBO documentary titled The Yogurt Shop Murders, helmed by director Margaret Brown.

Over the course of four episodes, starting August 3rd on Sundays, the series delves into various theories surrounding the identities of those responsible for the murders of four young women. It includes conversations with investigators as well as their interactions with suspects, insights from family members of the victims, and unique footage of the suspects captured by a local Austin documentary filmmaker, Claire Huie. However, the precise motives behind these girls’ deaths remain a mystery.

Brown, a native of Austin, recounts that at social gatherings, conversations often turned to the Yogurt Shop Murders. This tragic event is deeply ingrained in the folklore and collective consciousness of Austin, shaping the city’s history. Every resident seems to have their own theory about it.

Here’s what to know about the first episode of The Yogurt Shop Murders.

A key arrest

In the premiere of “The Yogurt Shop Murders,” we find ourselves starting with footage from Huie, showing a man named Robert Springsteen strolling through Macy’s to buy a sharp suit. He shares that he has been released from death row and is preparing for an interview on CBS’s investigative show, 48 Hours, as well as court appearances. The scene hints at the upcoming episodes, promising to reveal how Springsteen regained his freedom.

A week following the tragic incident, I was identified as the suspect, with my friend Maurice Pierce, aged 16, getting apprehended by the police. He was spotted carrying a fully-loaded firearm concealed within the waistband of his jeans, in the Northcross Mall Plaza, not far from the I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt! store. The gun matched the type that authorities had been searching for since they discovered a bullet in one of their sinks at the yogurt shop.

During interrogation, Pierce chose not to acknowledge his own wrongdoing, yet he disclosed the identities of others who were with him on the night of the shooting: Michael Scott, Springsteen, and Forrest Welborn.

According to Pierce, Forest requested to borrow his firearm and later returned looking sweaty with a scent of hairspray. The following day, the quartet of boys snatched a vehicle and drove it to San Antonio to meet a girl. Upon their return, Maurice mentioned that Forest asked for the gun once more. When Maurice inquired about the reason, he disclosed that Forest intended to murder more girls, similar to what he had done the previous night.

Audience will listen to a police recording where Maurice directly queries Forrest about his involvement in the girls’ deaths, to which Forrest responds that he was merely jesting and guarantees truthfulness: “I wouldn’t lie to you.” The authorities also failed to discover proof that could implicate him in the murders.

One significant factor contributing to the ongoing mystery of this crime is the chaotic condition of the crime scene. The authorities lacked tangible proof connecting these four suspects to the incident, even though they collected DNA samples from the girls for potential future use. Unfortunately, there was no CCTV footage available at the store, and the crime scene was submerged in water due to fire extinguishing efforts, making it challenging to find uncontaminated evidence or fingerprints. Additionally, while police could trace credit card transactions within the store, they were unable to monitor cash transactions, thereby limiting their ability to identify all involved parties.

As a cinephile immersed in the intrigue of unsolved mysteries, I’ve come to learn that the prevailing hypothesis surrounding the Yogurt Shop Murders within the law enforcement community points towards an unfortunate turn of events during a botched robbery attempt.

Families still traumatized

In the initial episode, family members of the deceased vividly recall December 6, 1991, as if it were just yesterday. Sonora, Eliza Thomas’s sister, recounts her uncontrollable teeth chattering upon hearing the news and needing to place her hand in her mouth to stop them. She clearly remembers the discomfort of informing her divorced parents about their daughter’s passing. Sonora recalls her mother shutting herself away in her bedroom and refusing to speak with the police, while she nervously cleaned the house. On the first night without her sister by her side, Sonora Thomas recollects thinking, “I have never woken up on a day when my sister was not among the living.

Shawn Ayers often reflects on his sister Amy each day, expressing that there’s never a moment without her on his mind. Meanwhile, Pam Ayers frequently recalls her daughter Amy whenever she comes across children and pets, as Amy and the other three girls were actively involved in Future Farmers of America.

Barbara Ayres-Wilson, the mother of Jennifer and Sarah Harbison, has been openly discussing the murders ever since she lost her daughters. Her hope is that this public discourse might aid law enforcement in resolving the case more swiftly. She remembers that on the day they passed away, Jennifer and Sarah were in high spirits, eager to visit the yogurt shop where Jennifer was employed. After seeing them off, she received a warm hug from each girl and urged them to be cautious. Despite this, she continues to ponder if there was anything else she could have done differently. She expresses her feelings as, “You’re left with all these regrets of not being able to protect [them]…How can someone be and then not be?

Read More

2025-08-04 04:06