Sauron’s Biggest Difference To Morgoth Reveals Lord Of The Rings’ TRUE Villain

by

Both Morgoth and Sauron caused immense destruction in Middle-earth, but Morgoth is arguably the true villain of the story. Although Sauron is the main enemy in The Lord of the Rings and much of the Second Age, Morgoth, his former master, was the dominant force in the earlier years.

Once Morgoth was defeated, Sauron became the primary source of evil in Middle-earth. While Morgoth was much stronger – being a powerful Vala compared to Sauron’s lesser status as a Maia – sheer power isn’t what makes someone the true villain in The Lord of the Rings. Something else is far more crucial.

The Biggest Difference Between Morgoth And Sauron

Morgoth and Sauron share many traits. Both are often shown wearing dark armor, led armies of orcs and other evil beings, and were enemies of the Elves of Middle-earth. Because Sauron served as Morgoth’s most trusted lieutenant, the two were very much alike in their goals and methods.

Despite any surface similarities, Morgoth and Eru Ilúvatar held fundamentally different beliefs. Morgoth’s main ambition was simply to rule everything. He originally tried to create life himself, hoping to equal the power of the creator god, Eru. When he realized he couldn’t do that, he shifted his focus to controlling the world Eru had already made – Middle-earth and the larger realm of Arda.

Morgoth desired to remake the world, control everyone in it, and bring all of existence under his power. If something couldn’t be bent to his will, he simply destroyed it, corrupted it, or filled it with darkness. Ultimately, Morgoth was driven by nothing more than his own pride – he wanted a kingdom that would prove he was better than all others.

I’ve always understood that Sauron didn’t just want power for its own sake. Deep down, a part of his original purpose as a Maia – to care for Middle-earth – still existed within him. But it was his intense desire for everything to be perfectly ordered that led him down a dark path. He became convinced that the only way to bring true peace was to control everyone, to take away their freedom. He didn’t want to rule a vibrant, diverse world; he wanted to be the one in charge of a flawlessly controlled continent, dictating every single thing that happened.

Sauron’s goal, revealed in the creation of the One Ring, wasn’t simply to destroy, but to control minds. If his plan had worked, Elves, Men, and Dwarves would have lived in peaceful, but absolute, obedience to him for all time.

Sauron Changed – And That’s Why He’s Middle-earth’s Real Villain

For much of the First and Second Ages in Middle-earth, Sauron still aimed to impose order. However, without Morgoth present, the ongoing resistance from the Elves, and the disapproval of the Valar, Sauron grew increasingly bitter. By the end of the Second Age, he had become a mirror of Morgoth – just as boastful, covetous, and proud. His goal shifted from achieving peace through domination to simply dominating for its own sake.

By the time of The Lord of the Rings, Sauron had completely embraced the same ruthless approach as Morgoth – either control everything or obliterate anything that resisted. As J.R.R. Tolkien explained, Sauron became driven by an insatiable hunger for ultimate power and an ever-growing hatred.

As a huge fan of Tolkien, I’ve always thought about Sauron’s potential. If he’d just stayed a well-intentioned, but ultimately flawed, character, he wouldn’t have been a truly terrifying villain – not on the scale of Morgoth, anyway. But he did change, and that’s what made him so compellingly evil.

Sauron’s evil was deeply influenced by the world of Middle-earth. His master, Morgoth, was a troublemaker from the very beginning, disrupting the creation of the world – a cosmic conflict mirroring the biblical tale of Lucifer’s rebellion against God, as Morgoth sought to rival his creator.

Sauron’s descent into evil happened primarily because of his focus on Middle-earth. This land wasn’t just a backdrop for his wickedness; it actually changed him, becoming his all-consuming obsession. He was driven not by some deep-seated personal issues, but by the constant resistance he faced from the creatures living there. Though he might not be the strongest or the origin of all evil, Sauron’s slow corruption and strong connection to Middle-earth firmly establish him as the central villain of The Lord of the Rings.

Read More

2025-12-13 17:10