Netflix, Ava DuVernay settle defamation lawsuit brought by ‘When They See Us’ prosecutor

by

I, as a follower of social justice and equal rights, strongly believe that Ava DuVernay and Netflix made the right decision in settling the defamation lawsuit filed by Linda Fairstein over her portrayal in “When They See Us.” While it’s important to respect the legal process and allow everyone involved their day in court, I also recognize the significant impact this case had on the public discourse around systemic racism and the criminal justice system.

Ava DuVernay and Netflix have reached an agreement to resolve a defamation claim brought against them by a former NYC prosecutor who was unhappy with how they depicted him in the critically-acclaimed miniseries “When They See Us.”

On Tuesday, Netflix, DuVernay, and plaintiff Fairstein announced the terms of their settlement in a joint statement. According to the agreement, Netflix will move the disclaimer from the ending credits to the start of the show.

“The film draws inspiration from real-life occurrences and people, but some characters, situations, places, dialogues, and names have been altered for storytelling reasons.”

In a compassionate gesture, Netflix, headquartered in Los Gatos, California, has pledged to contribute $1 million to the Innocence Project – an organization dedicated to helping those falsely imprisoned. Notably, Michael J. Fox’s former co-star, Linda Fairstein, will not receive any financial compensation as part of this arrangement.

DuVernay spoke out herself, revealing that Fairstein arranged for her husband to terminate their legal proceedings just before they were set to face a New York City jury. According to the filmmaker, Fairstein’s initial conditions for dropping the lawsuit involved a monetary settlement and a disclaimer asserting that all portrayals of her in the series were fictitious.

In her statement, DuVernay expressed her viewpoint that Linda Fairstein played a significant role in the Central Park Jogger investigation and subsequent wrongful convictions of five innocent young men, who were primarily Black and Brown.

“Linda Fairstein chose not to undergo a trial by her equals. This behavior is typical of bullies; when confronted with courage, they may retreat.”

Fairstein expressed in a release that reaching a conclusion in the defamation lawsuit wasn’t simple and that it transcended the notion of “winning” or securing monetary compensation; instead, it was a matter of safeguarding her reputation.

“Fairstein insisted that the defamatory portrayal of her as a villain in the movies wasn’t accurate; it was important to correct historical records.”

Each time I revisit the series on Netflix, the important disclaimer reminding viewers of the truth will be displayed once more, as per the terms of their settlement agreement.

As a movie enthusiast, I’d describe it this way: In “When They See Us,” directed by DuVernay, the story unfolds about a group of five Black and Brown teenagers erroneously accused and convicted of assaulting a female jogger in New York City’s Central Park in 1989. The quintet spent years behind bars before being exonerated and freed in 2002.

In the Central Park Five case, Fairstein, who previously worked for the prosecution, is portrayed by Felicity Huffman in the Emmy-winning series. However, Fairstean took legal action against Netflix and DuVernay in March 2020, claiming they falsely and defamatorily depicted her character in almost every scene where she appears.

I was disappointed with how “When They See Us” depicted fairstein in the series. The show painted her as an unwilling and ruthless antagonist, bent on jailing innocent kids of color no matter what. This portrayal, in my opinion, was an unfair characterization that oversimplified a complex figure.

When I first heard about the frivolous complaint filed against “13 Reasons Why” by Netflix, I was taken aback but not overly concerned. After all, they confidently dismissed it as such and vowed to fiercely defend both Ava DuVernay and Attica Locke in response.

Following the release of “When They See Us” on Netflix, Fairstein was dismissed by her literary and film representation, American and British publishers as well. The lawsuit further stated that she had also lost consulting and public speaking engagements due to the show.

“When They See Us” was nominated for 16 Emmy Awards and nine NAACP Image Awards.

Read More

2024-07-18 22:44