Karen Pirie Season 2 Review: Britbox Crime Thriller’s Strong, Flawed Return

by

While she’s famous for other roles, Lauren Lyle shines in the second season of Karen Pirie, now available on Britbox. The show’s creator, Emery Kenny, uses a similar storytelling approach as Season 1, heavily featuring shifting timelines. The investigation jumps between the past and present, revealing clearer motivations and showing events from every angle. This creates a complex police drama that immediately draws you in. It centers around a determined detective inspector who is fascinated by the reasons *why* people commit crimes – whether it’s a desire for power, a sense of entitlement, or something deeply personal.

Karen Pirie quickly became popular in 2022, successfully adapting Val McDermid’s popular novels with a strong personality. Now in its second season, Pirie has been promoted, and the show explores her personal life more fully. Creator Emery Kenny keeps the character fresh and realistic, showing us not just how she acts, but how others perceive her. The new season builds on the strengths of the first, tackling another fascinating unsolved case – this one from 1984.

Karen Pirie Season 2 Is Elevated by Solid Storytelling and Cultural Context

The way this story is built is crucial, skillfully connecting different parts of the plot and using time jumps to create tension. It uses DNA evidence to reveal connections between people and families with influence across several decades. The series immerses viewers in the political climate surrounding the U.K. miner’s strike, showing the fear in Scottish towns during the 1980s as people lost their jobs in the name of advancement. This is why Karen Pirie is so impactful: Over three episodes, Kenny provides a rich cultural background to this crime drama. While a detective inspector is the main focus, the story also draws clear parallels to current events, making it particularly meaningful.

Currently, the rise of artificial intelligence is impacting various industries, potentially putting some jobs at risk. With the increasing cost of living and high inflation, many people are struggling financially, and these concerns are reflected in the show Karen Pirie. Similar to how miners felt replaced in the 1980s, AI is driving a significant shift that social media leaders view as necessary. However, a key enjoyment of watching Karen Pirie is seeing how this modern issue connects to a decades-old kidnapping case, which viewers can unravel gradually.

As a big mystery fan, I’ve been really enjoying Dept Q on Netflix, and Karen Pirie feels like it hits some of the same notes – there’s definitely a familiar vibe that I think viewers will pick up on. What I especially like about Karen Pirie is how it shows her navigating a career that’s traditionally been dominated by men, really making her own path. Season 2 takes things even further, not just showing her fighting against prejudice at work, but cleverly using different timelines to tackle some really tough issues. Honestly, I think Karen Pirie is a more layered show than Dept Q. Dept Q mostly stuck to the past, avoiding a lot of modern social commentary, while this Britbox thriller actually embraces it. It weaves relevant context into the story, which I think is a brilliant way to keep audiences engaged and thinking.

Without this strong emphasis on how the story is built – which is essential to Season 2 – Karen Pirie would lose a key element. The truly innovative aspects of the show all stem from how the different parts of the story connect, and how events from various time periods influence each other. The way clues are gradually revealed and the moments of realization for both Pirie and the audience are closely linked. While it appears to be a simple crime drama, the dedicated cast truly brings it to life. This dedication begins with James Cosmo’s subtle yet powerful portrayal of oil tycoon Sir Broderick Grant.

This Crime Drama Asks Audiences How Far They Would Go for Family

As a film fan, I think James Cosmo is someone everyone recognizes from Braveheart, and he’s just kept delivering strong performances ever since. He’s really built an impressive career with some truly memorable roles. In Season 2 of Karen Pirie, Sir Broderick Grant – a character who could have easily been a bit predictable – actually gets a lot of weight and seriousness thanks to Cosmo’s presence. It’s a fascinating dynamic seeing him act opposite Jamie Michie, who plays the younger version of his character, in scenes that jump between different time periods. Cosmo manages to create a really intriguing character with very little screen time, taking a familiar type and giving him a subtle, clever edge.

Sir Broderick Grant could easily have been portrayed as a stereotypical villainous oil tycoon – think raised eyebrows and over-the-top arrogance. However, the show presents him as a husband and father who is struggling with a personal loss and has lost faith in people in charge, like DI Karen Pirie. This is a brilliant example of subtle acting, and every scene he’s in is captivating. He comes across as a well-respected businessman with strong connections and plenty of money, a man who shows his power through careful planning, not empty threats. He knows that information is his most valuable tool when dealing with the detectives investigating him. But what truly makes Sir Broderick compelling isn’t his relationship with DI Karen Pirie; it’s his willingness to bend the rules and his own questionable ethics.

I found Sir Broderick’s character fascinating – he’s become so detached from reality thanks to his wealth, and his money and power have made him incredibly impatient. What drives him to solve this crime isn’t simple; it’s a tangle of feelings he’s been suppressing for over forty years, and they’ve really started to fester. The performance really taps into a question we’ve seen explored in films like Denis Villeneuve’s Prisoners: just how far *should* someone go to uncover the truth? That’s really the central theme of Season 2, and it’s a question that resonates with multiple characters, not just him.

Could Karen Pirie be the Most Underrated Anti-Hero in Crime Drama?

Karen Pirie frequently challenges what’s considered right and wrong, questioning traditional ideas to create compelling storylines. The actor playing her, Lyle, portrays a character who questions those in power, defies typical gender roles, and finds it difficult to connect with others emotionally. These conflicting traits are just one way Karen Pirie Season 2 continues to be innovative and different. Whether you agree with Pirie’s actions or not, she definitely moves away from what viewers usually expect, showing both strength and femininity. She earns respect without compromising her values, and she’s vulnerable enough to feel real, but not so much that she appears weak.

This performance could be tricky for some actors, but Lyle handles the complexities with ease, consistently captivating audiences. Whether Pirie is navigating the confusing ups and downs of a casual relationship with DS Phil Parhatka, or carefully avoiding trouble with her bosses, she’s compelling to watch. Much like the story itself, which presents multiple threads and challenges viewers to connect the dots, Karen Pirie finds herself torn between personal and professional life. She’s held back by the strict rules of her job, yet also struggles to control her tendency to speak her mind.

This works really well within a narrative that moves between different time periods, uses flashbacks, and handles several characters’ reasons for acting without feeling rushed. Lyle delivers a character that’s hard for others to match, as Pirie is simply a compelling and powerful presence. If the second season had been able to reach her level in terms of depth and complexity, it would have been considered outstanding. Sadly, Karen Pirie doesn’t quite succeed in the end.

Season 2 of Karen Pirie Fumbles Its Ending

It’s often difficult for TV shows to end strongly, and many great series either stumble or succeed in their final episodes. Lost is a good example – reactions from viewers were very divided. Karen Pirie invests a lot of effort into other aspects of the show, so it’s harsh to say this Britbox series doesn’t deliver a satisfying conclusion. The show’s careful attention to detail throughout the different time periods brings it close in quality to the highly praised Red Riding Trilogy, which starred Andrew Garfield, Rebecca Hall, and Sean Bean. The authentic period setting will keep viewers engaged, even if Season 2 doesn’t offer much that’s new. Sadly, the plot falls apart quickly once the mystery starts to disappear.

A sense of mystery is crucial for any truly successful murder mystery or police show. Viewers can easily tell when a story feels familiar, and Karen Pirie unfortunately struggles to feel fresh. Even with strong performances from the entire cast – including Lyle and Cosmo at their best – it isn’t enough to elevate the show. Consequently, what could have been a fantastic comeback after a three-year break ends up being just okay, instead of exceptional. This second season features several captivating performances, but it’s ultimately held back by predictable genre clichés and a need to neatly wrap up the plot.

This isn’t to discourage viewers from watching Karen Pirie Season 2, as there’s still much to enjoy in this intricate crime series. It’s still a well-made adaptation, featuring a captivating lead performance and strong support from experienced actors. The show feels authentic and realistic, and Emery Kenny expertly weaves between different time periods, connecting the various plot elements. Sadly, the ending doesn’t quite deliver, diminishing the impact of the earlier episodes and relying too much on predictable tropes.

Karen Pirie premieres October 2 on Britbox, releasing each of its three episodes weekly.

Read More

2025-10-03 06:53