James Gunn Defends His Controversial DCU Batman Hire

When I heard Christina Hodson was writing the new Batman: The Brave and the Bold movie, it immediately caused a lot of debate among DC fans online. Some people weren’t happy, especially after her work on The Flash and Birds of Prey. But honestly, I was glad to see James Gunn, one of the heads of DC Studios, quickly step in and publicly support her. He made it clear he believes she’s the right person for the job, and I think that’s great!

The Hollywood Reporter announced on January 21st that Christina Hodson will write the script for The Brave and the Bold, the film that will introduce Batman and his son, Damian Wayne, as Robin to the DC Universe. Sources say Hodson started working on the project as early as fall 2025.

The announcement quickly sparked debate among fans, who reminded everyone of her past work with DC. Her recent film, The Flash (2023), was a major box office disappointment, costing Warner Bros. over $200 million and becoming one of the biggest superhero failures ever. Another film she worked on, Birds of Prey, earned $205.5 million worldwide, but with a production cost of $82 million, it didn’t make enough to cover its expenses – it needed between $250 and $300 million to break even.

James Gunn responded to the criticism in a Threads post, where he often connects with fans. He defended both the skills of the filmmaker in question and the way movies are made as a team effort.

If someone is criticizing Christina Hodson’s writing, they probably haven’t actually read one of her scripts. She was a key part of our initial DCU planning. Also, it’s unfair to evaluate my work based on movies directed by others, because directors often make significant changes to the original screenplay.

How Important Is Brave and the Bold for the Dcu?

As a huge DC fan, I’m telling you, The Brave and the Bold is a massive deal for where DC Studios is heading. It’s going to give us the definitive Batman for the new DC Universe – a completely separate Batman from the one Robert Pattinson plays in The Batman movies. The story’s inspired by a really famous comic book run by Grant Morrison, and it’s all about Bruce Wayne finding out he has a son, Damian, who’s been secretly trained by the League of Assassins. It’s a game changer!

During the 2023 DCU presentation, James Gunn introduced the new Batman, Bruce Wayne, and his son, Robin (Damian Wayne). He jokingly described Damian as a highly skilled, ruthless assassin, and revealed that Batman was unaware of Damian’s existence for the first 8 to 10 years of his life.

This movie kicks off the story of the Bat-family within the DC Universe, centering on the complex relationship between Batman and a young boy who’s been trained as a killer. This Batman is a fresh take on the character – he’ll have three unique traits and hasn’t been seen in a live-action film before, making things particularly exciting.

Batman is as famous and important as Superman when it comes to DC Comics. How he’s introduced into the new DC Universe could really shape the future of the whole franchise. Because fans know how crucial he is, they have high hopes and want the best writers and artists working on the character.

Andy Muschietti, the director of The Flash, is still set to direct The Brave and the Bold, a choice that initially upset some fans. However, Muschietti recently impressed audiences with his work on the HBO series It: Welcome to Derry. The show was a success both with critics and viewers, demonstrating that a previous disappointment doesn’t necessarily reflect a director’s overall talent.

The reasoning behind choosing Hodson is similar. Her work on the Bumblebee screenplay showed she’s skilled at creating believable and touching connections between characters, even within large-scale action movies. Bumblebee worked so well because it centered on the relationship between a young person and their guardian – the same core dynamic that will drive The Brave and the Bold. Hodson’s experience with these types of complex relationships, plus her early involvement in planning the DC Universe, indicates she understands the overall direction James Gunn and Peter Safran envision.

Read More

2026-01-29 19:05