In ‘The Penguin’ finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

In 'The Penguin' finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

As I delve deeper into Cristin Milioti‘s captivating journey, I am struck by her unwavering dedication and passion for her craft. Her life experiences have molded her into an actress who not only brings characters to life but also infuses them with a depth and complexity that resonates with audiences.


This article contains spoilers for the finale of HBO’s “The Penguin.”

Cristin Milioti acknowledges feeling self-conscious about speaking too formally about acting roles during interviews. She often winces at performers who speak about their characters in the third person, but finds herself doing the same when discussing Sofia Gigante, aka Falcone, her crime boss character in HBO’s “The Penguin.

On a Zoom call from her New York residence, Milioti expresses her affection for the character Sofia, stating, “She’s the role I’ve enjoyed portraying the most.

When Milioti learned about the ending of the limited series that was planned for Sofia, she felt “truly heartbroken.

In the final episode of “The Penguin” on Sunday, Colin Farrell’s character, Oz Cobb (also known as the penguin), successfully seizes power from Sofia following their power struggle. He then assumes command over Gotham’s criminal underworld and, in a moment that appears to be a set-up for her murder, takes Sofia to a secluded location. However, instead of carrying out the hit, he devises another form of retribution. He hands her over to the police and sends her back to Arkham Asylum, where she had endured years of suffering after being falsely accused of multiple murders.

“What’s horrible is he discovers a fate worse than death for her,” Milioti explains.

In 'The Penguin' finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

Despite the grim conclusion for Sofia, Milioti discovers a hint of optimism in the finale: In prison, she receives a message from Selina Kyle, also known as Catwoman. This connection is significant because, in Matt Reeves’ 2022 film “The Batman,” it’s revealed that Selina’s father is Carmine Falcone, which makes her Sofia’s half-sister. Milioti reflects, “There seems to be a small beam of light at the end of the tunnel. She might have family.” Furthermore, Milioti harbors her own hopes for the future: She expresses her desire to portray Sofia once more.

“It would be my wildest dream,” she says.

For Milioni, playing Sofia had long been a cherished aspiration, as she developed a deep affection for the Batman universe following her father’s introduction to “Batman Returns” at age 7. She recalls, “I was absolutely petrified yet couldn’t tear my eyes away.

Straight away, Milioti bought a Catwoman suit, but her fascination didn’t end there. She visited Blockbuster to rent Tim Burton’s 1989 “Batman,” repeatedly watching it. When “Batman Forever” premiered in 1995, she persuaded her dad to take her to the cinema six times. Her bedroom walls were adorned with photos of Jim Carrey as the Riddler. For Milioti, her affection for Batman stems from her empathy towards the characters.

She remarks that the villains in Batman’s world are deeply rooted in genuine suffering. They may not possess supernatural abilities, yet they create their own costumes, which can be both fascinating and amusingly theatrical, yet at times heartbreakingly tragic.

Raised in New Jersey, Milioti had a fascination for complex female characters with aggressive leanings from an early age. Alongside Michelle Pfeiffer’s Catwoman in “Batman Returns,” she admired Uma Thurman’s Bride from Quentin Tarantino’s “Kill Bill,” her preferred movie.

In the cinema when I watched ‘Wonder Woman’, seeing all those young girls there, it was deeply moving for me. And as I was watching, I thought to myself, “For me, ‘Kill Bill’ was like ‘Wonder Woman’.

In 'The Penguin' finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

Following her departure from NYU, Milioti discovered that despite flourishing in New York’s theater environment, she struggled to make the impact she desired in television and film roles she auditioned for. Roles such as “corpse found in a trunk” or “guest at Blair Waldorf’s party” were not uncommon, but a part on “Gossip Girl” never came her way.

As a passionate admirer of Milioti’s talent, I’ve had the pleasure of witnessing her versatility firsthand. From portraying a Czech songwriter in “Once” on Broadway, to embodying the iconic “mother” on “How I Met Your Mother,” lending her voice to the memorable character in an episode of “30 Rock,” and getting stuck in a time loop as a wedding guest in “Palm Springs,” Milioti has shown an impressive range.

Still, she knew she was waiting for something like “The Penguin.”

She mentions that a few months prior, the project came her way, and it seems to her a consequence of aging that she’s become more conscious of time and how she wants to utilize it. She had been on the lookout for an opportunity such as this one, but they are quite elusive.

Typically speaking, these types of roles often lead to a figurative massacre among numerous performers. However, the showrunner of “The Penguin”, Lauren LeFranc, along with executives Craig Zobel and Reeves decided they’d like to have a virtual meeting with her instead.

From the outset, Milioti instinctively felt there were rich layers to Sofia, even though she wasn’t aware of all her past details.

She remarks that there are parts which resemble the surface of an iceberg; they appear tranquil, yet beneath the surface, there’s a great deal of activity taking place.

Throughout the series, Sofia undergoes several transformations. In a flashback episode, we discover her as an innocent girl who uncovers her father Carmine’s (Mark Strong) murders of women. She is subsequently framed for these crimes. Later on, seeking retribution against her entire family, whom she believes were involved in keeping her confined at Arkham, she uses poison gas and parades around her family’s mansion in a yellow gown and gas mask. This scene is mirrored in the finale where she sets fire to the estate while wearing a striking red coat designed by costume designer Helen Huang.

In 'The Penguin' finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

Milioti frequently employs the term “collaborative” when discussing her work with LeFranc. She wonders if her level of involvement was more than typical, considering the prominence of the show.

She mentions that there’s no similar franchise she can compare it to, as her experiences haven’t been the same. However, she suspects it’s not unique in that regard. She goes on to say that she recognizes how fortunate she was for the opportunity.

As a passionate cinephile, I had the privilege of working alongside LeFranc and our exceptional department heads, such as hairstylist Brian Badie, to develop Sofia’s transformation throughout the series. Gradually asserting herself and assuming a more dominant role within the storyline, Sofia found her confidence growing. Eager to reflect this evolution, I advocated for Sofia’s hair to transition from a neatly pulled-back style to the sultry shag she sports by the finale. In my own words, it was akin to watching Sofia undergo a beautiful and powerful blooming into a fierce character – a further blossoming into an animal, if you will.

I openly admitted to Milioti that I had secretly hoped Sofia would outsmart Oz at his own game, and it seemed like she might when she blew up his warehouse. Unfortunately, he managed to regain control. As an actress, it’s her duty to support her characters, even those who commit questionable acts, but she confessed that she was rooting for Sofia too. Many others on set shared the same sentiment. “I can recall members of the crew feeling the same way,” she explains. “‘We all wanted her to win.’

In 'The Penguin' finale, Cristin Milioti finds a glimmer of hope for Sofia

In one of her last scenes filmed alongside Farrell, she found herself in an emotionally charged moment. She expressed, “There simply couldn’t be a more fitting companion for me to traverse the realms of despair with.” She added, “I believe he too comprehended the profound impact of that scene.

It’s been speculated that Sofia could appear in the sequel of “The Batman”, but according to Milioti, she hasn’t engaged in any talks with Reeves or LeFranc about it. As Milioti puts it, “Everyone seems to be keeping things very secret.

Milioti found the character to be incredibly important to her, and she felt significantly anxious when she first arrived on set. In her own words, “I thought, ‘Oh my goodness, this is finding a needle in a haystack!'” This sentiment undeniably amplified her overwhelming nervousness during the initial months of filming. She acknowledged that chances like this don’t come often.

When did the nerves dissipate for her?

It wasn’t until I understood how deeply involved I was in that project, that if they chose to let me go, it would cause them significant inconvenience.

Read More

2024-11-11 06:32

Previous post The Penguin finale explained: Did Oz Cobb get everything he dreamed of?
Next post The Penguin finale was great, but I wish they hadn’t done that to [SPOILER]