Movies

Hannibal Lecter’s First Prequel Movie Came Out 5 Years Before Silence of the Lambs

BBG News

In the novel “Red Dragon,” written by Thomas Harris, the character of Hannibal Lecter, a notorious cannibalistic serial killer, was first introduced to many. Seven years later, Harris penned the sequel, titled “The Silence of the Lambs,” which eventually became a horror movie sensation when it hit the screens. The film immortalized Hannibal Lecter, portrayed by Anthony Hopkins, as a terrifying icon. This film was also an unprecedented success, winning in all five major Oscar categories: Best Actor (Anthony Hopkins), Best Actress (Jodie Foster), Best Director (Jonathan Demme), Best Screenplay (Ted Tally), and the prestigious Best Picture award.

The remarkable triumph of “The Silence of the Lambs” as the only horror film to secure the Best Picture award at the Oscars paved the way for a franchise, one that encompassed the prequel adaptation of “Red Dragon,” directed by Brett Ratner and featuring Edward Norton as FBI agent Will Graham, with Anthony Hopkins reprising his iconic role as Hannibal Lecter. This storyline was also adapted later into the TV series “Hannibal,” starring Mads Mikkelsen as Lecter. Interestingly, “Red Dragon” had been previously adapted in 1986 under the title “Manhunter,” two years before Thomas Harris’ novel was published and five years prior to Anthony Hopkins’ portrayal of Hannibal Lecter.

The First Hannibal Lecter Movie Came Out Five Years Before Silence Of The Lambs

Brian Cox Was The Original Hannibal Lecktor

Prior to Thomas Harris penning “The Silence of the Lambs”, his initial Hannibal Lecter novel, “Red Dragon”, had already been adapted into a film titled “Manhunter”. This movie was directed by Michael Mann in 1986, marking it as his third cinematic project after “Thief” and “The Keep”. Notably, Mann, who later earned Academy Award nominations for “The Last of the Mohicans”, “The Insider”, “Ali”, and “Collateral”, was the one who introduced Hannibal to the big screen. He altered the spelling to Hannibal Lecktor and cast Brian Cox (famous from “Succession”) as the notorious cannibalistic serial killer. Those who have watched “Red Dragon” and the “Hannibal” TV series are familiar with the narrative.

In the film ‘Manhunter’, William Petersen, best known from ‘CSI’, portrays Will Graham, a former FBI profiler who stepped down after encountering Hannibal Lecter, an ordeal that led to his mental collapse. Later, when his old superior, Jack Crawford, played by Dennis Farina, requested his help with a fresh serial killer case, he consented under the proviso that he would only focus on gathering evidence. Nevertheless, Graham eventually sought assistance from Lecter in prison, asking him to delve into the mind of the serial killer.

Manhunter vs. Red Dragon
Title Rotten Tomatoes Critics’ Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score Est. Budget Worldwide Box Office
Manhunter 94% 77% $15M $8.6M
Red Dragon 69% 74% $78M $206M

In contrast to the 2002 film “Red Dragon,” directed by Brett Ratner, which features Anthony Hopkins reprising his role as Hannibal Lecter, the Michael Mann movie, titled “Manhunter,” doesn’t make Hannibal Lecter the central focus. Instead, he serves as a tool for Will Graham to uncover details about the Tooth Fairy killer. As a result, “Manhunter” can be described more as a mystery thriller rather than a Hannibal Lecter horror movie, even though Hannibal plays a crucial role in both films without being the main character.

Michael Mann’s Manhunter Surpasses Red Dragon In Every Way

In contrast to the later films in the series, Manhunter may not be as heavily centered on Hannibal Lecter, but it surpasses Red Dragon. The film’s excellence lies primarily in the hands of director Michael Mann and his masterful pacing and storytelling. His work would earn him significant Oscar recognition in the near future, as he crafted a chilling thriller that kept viewers gripped and produced an unsettling portrayal of Francis Dolarhyde, played by Tom Noonan. Unlike Brett Ratner, who is recognized for his blockbuster movie-making style, Mann aimed for something more ominous and eerie in this production.

Brian Cox’s interpretation of Hannibal Lecktor doesn’t fall short in comparison to Anthony Hopkins’ iconic portrayal on the big screen, as both actors delivered compelling performances in their respective roles. Despite Hopkins being widely recognized for his exceptional take on the cannibalistic serial killer, Cox effectively brought his own version of Hannibal to life. Furthermore, Cox acknowledged the distinctions between his depiction and Hopkins’.

Indeed, this role is distinct from others. It’s akin to interpreting Hamlet; each actor brings their unique take on the character. In my case, Michael Mann and I collaborated to shape my performance. Tony delivered an exceptional portrayal in his own way…

However, we followed our own path with the game. Instead, Tony opted for a different direction. Undeniably, Tony’s new approach led to great success, earning him an Oscar and substantial wealth. In turn, I managed to earn around $10,000 from it.

Instead of Hannibal, the film Manhunter stands out against Red Dragon in nearly every aspect. Initially, it received a mixed reception, but over time, opinions have shifted and it has gained cult status. Compared to the later Red Dragon adaptation, Manhunter is often favorably reviewed. The early criticism of Mann’s visually stylized approach eventually became his signature style, becoming more accepted as the years passed. Critics also appreciated the subtle narrative in Mann’s film, contrasting it with Ratner’s more sensationalist design.

Tom Noonan, who brought the character Francis Dollarhyde to life in “Manhunter”, deserves credit too. Although Ralph Fiennes is more famously known for his portrayal in “Red Dragon”, Noonan’s performance was spot-on. He skillfully conveyed the unsettling nature of the Tooth Fairy killer, adding a chilling element to Michael Mann’s film that was seemingly missing from “Red Dragon”.

It’s worth noting that although critics harshly criticized Mann’s direction when the movie first came out, Ratner’s film employed the same cinematographer, Dante Spinotti, who worked on both Manhunter and Red Dragon. Later, Spinotti received an Oscar nomination for his work on Mann’s The Insider. Interestingly, while Red Dragon was a financial success, it’s largely considered an insignificant addition to Hannibal Lecter’s legend. On the contrary, Manhunter, due to its themes, color use, and character portrayal, is still widely studied by film scholars and is regarded as the most compelling prequel of Hannibal Lecter ever made for the big screen.

Read More

2025-05-18 14:11

Previous post Stars Ditching Younger Lovers For Older Partners
Next post Doctor Who boss teases finale reveal after two classic characters return: “This is the big one”