Movies

Good American Family: The Heartbreaking Twist That Will Change Your Perspective

BBG News

In the TV series “Good American Family” on Hulu, the intriguing concept is presented: What if the individual meant to unite your family ends up being the one who fragments it? The narrative is loosely based on the true events of Kristine and Michael Barnett (played by Ellen Pompeo and Mark Duplass) adopting Natalia Grace (portrayed by Imogen Faith Reid), a child with dwarfism. As their vision of creating a harmonious family begins to crumble, it becomes apparent that Natalia is not as they had anticipated. The tale, though rooted in reality, is more bizarre than any work of fiction could imagine. The series reserves its most shocking twist for the fifth episode, penned by creator Katie Robbins, which flips everything we thought we knew about the characters upside down.

In the initial four episodes, The American Family effectively maintains a dramatic, almost suspenseful atmosphere that makes it seem as if the Barnett family is in peril due to Natalia. Dramatic storytelling often receives criticism for being overly exaggerated or sensationalistic, yet situations like believing you’ve taken in a swindler determined to ruin your family are undeniably extreme.

In the intense narrative of the show “Good American Family,” it’s not surprising that Kristine might doubt everything about her daughter. Her anguish is palpable as she struggles to protect her family from Natalia, who nearly caused an accident that could have killed Kristine, threw her sibling’s toys onto a bustling road, laced Kristine’s coffee with something harmful, and brandished a knife in Kristine’s room, threatening her. It’s also worth mentioning that Natalia has made it clear she favors Michael in some capacity, whether as a father figure or something more, but the exact nature of this preference remains unclear. Kristine believes that Natalia is an adult disguising herself as a child, and her desperation grows as she seeks answers from various doctors and even yells at her: “How old are you?

In the end, Kristine and Michael managed to convince medical professionals and legal advisors to alter Natalia’s legal status from an 8-year-old to a 22-year-old. Though they continued to be her legal guardians (“To prevent any harm to others,” mentioned a police officer), they decided to move her out of their home. The story in Good American Family implies that removing Natalia from the family was beneficial for all parties concerned.

Over the course of four episodes, “Good American Family” portrays a heart-wrenching tale about a woman battling for survival against an overwhelming adversity, but unfortunately, her struggles are disbelieved by everyone around her.

Until it gets completely flipped around.

The truth about Natalia Grace

In Episode 5 of “Good American Family”, we no longer find the Barnett family with Natalia as she has moved into her own apartment. For the very first time, the narrative of the series switches from that of Kristine to Natalia’s personal experiences.

From our observations, we anticipated that once Natalia found herself alone and not able to swindle the Barnetts out of money, she would swiftly move on to choosing her next victim. However, this isn’t what transpired. Instead, Kristine and Michael, who suspect Natalia is lying about her age, purposely deny her walker, thereby significantly limiting her mobility. Overwhelmed, Natalia chases the van as best she can, sobbing for her walker, because it’s unbearable without it. From Kristine’s point of view, Natalia’s previous pleas for help were manipulative, intended to make Michael distrustful towards his wife.

They take off in their vehicle, taking the walker with them, thus abandoning Natalia. All of a sudden, Natalia’s fear becomes unbearably tangible.

1. Though her fridge is jam-packed and her cabinets are filled with snacks, she’s unable to cook or retrieve them due to her height. In a creative portrayal, cinematographer Carmen Cabana transforms an ordinary kitchen into an imposing fortress, as the camera swirls above Natalia as she struggles to navigate the new world that has been presented to her. Desperate for a solution, Natalia moves a chair to boost herself onto the kitchen counter and scrambles across the stove to reach the cupboard. Finding a can of peaches, she chats cheerfully with the cartoon-wearing fruit on the label, unsure how to open it.

2. Her fridge is overflowing, yet she can’t cook. The cupboards are stocked with snacks, but she can’t reach them. Filmmaker Carmen Cabana skillfully turns a regular kitchen into an impassable obstacle, as the camera dives and weaves above Natalia, who’s trying to find her bearings in the world she’s been plopped into. Desperate for a way out, Natalia drags a chair up onto the counter and crawls over the stove to get to the cupboard. She finds a can of peaches and talks animatedly to the sunglasses-wearing fruit on the label, puzzled about how to open it.

3. Her fridge is bursting at the seams, but she doesn’t know how to cook. The cupboards are brimming with snacks, yet she can’t reach them. Filmmaker Carmen Cabana masterfully converts a simple kitchen into an insurmountable challenge, as the camera darts and twists above Natalia, who’s attempting to make sense of the unfamiliar surroundings. Desperate for a solution, Natalia moves a chair to perch herself on the counter and scrambles over the stove to reach the cupboard. She discovers a can of peaches and chatters with the sunglasses-donning fruit on the label, unsure how to open it.

In “Good American Family,” what’s most chilling isn’t a specific startling moment. Instead, it’s the creeping sense of unease that arises as you understand that all your assumptions about Natalia were incorrect. You come to realize that Natalia Grace isn’t some malicious schemer determined to destroy a family; she is a vulnerable child yearning for love after years of longing for it. The actions that Kristine and Michael perceived as threatening were actually those of a child who has endured so much pain, both physically and emotionally, making it difficult for her to accept the affection offered to her.

The heartbreaking meaning behind episode 5 

In her solitary apartment, Natalia spends the evening engrossed in television, when suddenly, she recognizes Kristine on a chat program. Her heart pounding with anticipation, Natalia leans closer to the screen as Kristine speaks directly to her: “Natalia, I will never abandon you.” Although these words are false, they resonate deeply with Natalia, who has longed to hear them. As Kristine’s face fills the screen, a weary expression giving way to radiant joy, there’s a glimmer of hope that their estrangement is momentary and they will be reunited soon. In this close-up, we catch a glimpse of Natalia’s genuine emotions – her resilience and pain – as it all comes to the forefront. It’s a moving spectacle, yet heartbreaking at the same time.

The previously mentioned hope fades when Natalia discovers Kristine’s book at the library, finding that her presence in the Barnett family has been removed. Photos with her have been edited out, and there is no reference to her within its pages. At home, she angrily crosses out the photos. Moments later, she is overwhelmed by sadness and remorse, feeling the pain of being rejected by her family. Days pass, and Michael eventually visits. This is no longer the lively, efficient, and quick-thinking Natalia we’ve grown accustomed to. Instead, the true Natalia emerges as a more sensitive, slower, and desperate individual, yearning to comprehend the situation unfolding before her. Imogen Faith Reid, another dwarf, adds an overwhelming sense of vulnerability, as Natalia finds it increasingly difficult to manage daily tasks, such as turning on the tap or living independently as an adult.

Beyond simply representing Natalia, Reid’s performance in the second half of “Good American Family” offers a fresh perspective. As the story progresses, Reid portrays a nuanced side of Natalia that seems authentic and plausible. These subtle character transformations significantly alter our comprehension of everything we’ve previously witnessed. This compelling portrayal invites us to reconsider our perceptions, questioning not just the narrative on screen, but also how these perspectives shape our understanding of what we observe on television.

Read More

2025-04-09 16:06

Previous post Brooke Shields, 59, Stuns in Tiny Bikini and Reveals Secrets to Ageless Beauty!
Next post The best CS2 player: Skill, trophies, rating, and more