George RR Martin warns of “toxic” House of the Dragon changes

As a long-time fan and avid gamer who has spent countless hours immersed in the intricate worlds of George R.R. Martin’s books, I can’t help but feel a pang of nostalgia tinged with disappointment when it comes to House of the Dragon season 2. The changes made to the ‘Blood and Cheese’ sequence, while perhaps practical from a production standpoint, have left me yearning for the darker, more visceral impact of the original scene from Fire & Blood.


House of the Dragon season 2 spoilers follow.

George R.R. Martin, the mastermind behind the series Game of Thrones, has expressed concerns over potential ‘harmful’ alterations in the show House of the Dragon, as he discussed it in his latest blog post

Ioutingoutout outout’ssttpspassoutoutptout Soutoutoutoutpasspoutoutoutoutoutoutpassoutoutoutpassateteonoutoutoutoutppoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutttesetoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutppoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutingoutoutoutoutoutsspoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutpassoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutoutout’ssspassoutoutoutoutoutpassoutsatoutoutoutoutoutateon outoutoutoutssss’techppoutatsesspt inssttsatoutout.outoutoutoutout’sspassoutoutoutoutpassoutoutoutpoutoutout passoutpassoutpassoutoutoutsstssptsetout andssppssteppoutoutssperptsspsspassoutpassoutpassoutp.outoutptssstoutpassoutpoutsspte.tessptsat’sattesspatsetepp inset,sattessteechtsstee

According to Martin’s comments (as reported by TheWrap), it wasn’t the contentious ending of House of the Dragon’s second season that he found most problematic, instead

Instead, the author found disagreement with showrunner Ryan Condal for eliminating the character Maelor from the series, as it was expected that Maelor would play a significant role during the ‘Blood and Cheese’ scene in the season premiere

George RR Martin warns of "toxic" House of the Dragon changesRyan Condal and George R.R. Martin

Ioutout. It

In the television adaptation, characters Blood and Cheese compel Helaena to decide which of her twin offspring should perish. Contrastingly, in the book “Fire & Blood,” it’s the younger son Maelor who is present alongside the twins and their mother during the heart-wrenching moment when she must choose among her three children

In his blog post, Martin expressed that the “Sophie’s Choice” segment was the most impactful, intense, and raw part of the sequence. He found it difficult to let go of this aspect, and based on the reactions he saw online, it seemed like many other fans shared his sentiment as well

The writer explained that he “argued against” the show’s twist on ‘Blood and Cheese’ when he first found out about it from Condal.

As a gamer, I didn’t engage in a heated debate for long, but the suggested change felt like a slight hiccup to me. Ryan had solid reasons behind it: avoiding the hassle of casting another child, especially a two-year-old toddler. Toddlers are unpredictable and can slow down the production process significantly, which would also impact the budget

The budget for “House of the Dragon” was tight, so we needed to cut costs wherever possible. Ryan explained to me that Prince Maelor wasn’t being written off, but rather delayed until Season 3. If Queen Helaena conceives him in the late part of Season 2 and gives birth in Season 3, it would make sense for her character. With this understanding, I agreed to the change in the storyline

George RR Martin warns of "toxic" House of the Dragon changes

Martin asserted: “I’m convinced the scene from the book remains more impactful. The readers should have that privilege. The characters portraying the killers on screen were exceptionally well-played… however, the characters themselves are more ruthless, harsh, and terrifying in Fire & Blood.”

Martin’s worry is that removing Maelor from the series so far might trigger a ripple effect, potentially resulting in additional content from his books not being included in “House of the Dragon

If “House of the Dragon” proceeds with certain planned alterations for Seasons 3 and 4, there could be even bigger and more harmful butterflies on the horizon, as indicated in his writing

The author explicitly stated that they were still fond of the particular episode, including the Blood and Cheese segment, and expressed their approval for the work Condal is performing in his role as showrunner

George RR Martin warns of "toxic" House of the Dragon changes

Ryan Condal

HBO defended showrunner Ryan Condal’s creative choices in its statement to Deadline.

As an ardent admirer, I can confidently say that there are scarcely more passionate followers of George R.R. Martin and his masterpiece, “Fire & Blood,” than the creative force behind “House of the Dragon.” This extends to both our on-set team and our colleagues at HBO

Typically, when a book is turned into a TV show, the showrunner must make challenging decisions about which characters and stories to focus on, given the unique format and constraints of television. In our opinion, Ryan Condal and his team have done an exceptional job, and the millions of fans who have followed the series since its first two seasons will undoubtedly continue to find it engaging

As a dedicated gamer, I can tell you firsthand that adapting Martin’s epic literary universe for the screen was no walk in the park – it was more like a marathon!

George RR Martin warns of "toxic" House of the Dragon changes

As a storyteller immersed in the gaming world, I believe we need to tackle this fabricated past just as any gamer would handle an intriguing level from their favorite historical game – with a keen eye for detail and a respect for authenticity

To create a rich and immersive world for readers, we need to build a comprehensive three-dimensional narrative, complete with characters who have complex internal lives, flaws, desires, and emotions. These aspects may not be explicitly mentioned in historical accounts, but they help bring the story to life. Reading “Fire & Blood” offers many instances where one can speculating about what was left out of the actual flaws, motivations, feelings, or motivations, is often an incomplete depiction of the characters’ true nature. While it’s a fragmented picture at bestows the historical record

Essentially, our role as dramatists and adaptors often involves filling in details based on what we’re provided. However, much of the unique flavor or essence comes from our individual contributions to this process

Martin’s critique of the second season of “House of the Dragon” surfaced several weeks following the announcement that the series is set to conclude with its fourth season

In the United Kingdom, you can watch seasons 1-2 of “House of the Dragon” on Sky Atlantic and stream it on NOW. In the United States, it is broadcasted on HBO and can be streamed on Max

Read more House of the Dragon news on our dedicated homepage

Read More

2024-09-05 03:20

Previous post Guess who! Australian icon looks completely unrecognisable in jaw-dropping picture worlds away from his heyday
Next post Paramount celebrates Star Trek day by making almost all Trek premieres free to watch