Fox’s Best Medicine Is House Meets Gilmore Girls (& It Was Just Renewed For Part 2)

by

The new Fox comedy-drama, Best Medicine, blends the sharp, no-nonsense doctor character from House with the charming small-town setting of Gilmore Girls. Josh Charles stars as Dr. Martin Best, a direct and sometimes grumpy surgeon who trades the bustle of Boston for a quieter life as the town doctor in Port Wynn, Maine.

Best Medicine is an American adaptation of the British show Doc Martin. However, the American version is more upbeat and emotionally open than the original’s quirky and reserved style. While Dr. Best is focused on helping the people of Port Wynn, he also needs their community to help him with his own personal struggles.

Josh Charles’ Best Medicine Mixes Medical Drama With Small-Town Charm

“Best Medicine” is successful because it combines the captivating nature of medical mysteries with the warm, inviting atmosphere of a quirky small town. Instead of the typical fast-paced medical dramas, this show takes its time, allowing the unique character of Port Wynn to shine through in every episode.

I was completely hooked by Josh Charles’ character, Dr. Best – he’s got this really interesting guardedness about him, and you quickly realize there’s a reason for it. It turns out he’s secretly terrified of blood, and the show brilliantly reveals it stems from a really painful experience. He was involved in a difficult surgery on a young girl that brought back all the grief from losing his sister, Rosemary, when he was a kid. It’s a surprisingly vulnerable backstory for someone who initially seems so tough.

The experience led him to seek a less stressful job: becoming the town doctor in a small Maine town where he used to spend summers with his aunt. Taking the position in Port Wynn meant he could still practice medicine while also dealing with his fear of blood.

Despite the show hinting at a difficult past for Dr. Best, it doesn’t let that define the series. His history is more of a subtle background element than the main focus. The heart of the show is watching Dr. Best gradually open up and connect with the people in town, slowly letting down his guard.

I just love this show! It’s the kind of thing you can always put on when you need a pick-me-up. It mixes genuinely touching moments with little mysteries and a sweet bit of romance. Honestly, the quirky people who live in Port Wynn are just as interesting as whatever medical problem they’re dealing with each week. It really feels like a story about people coming together and helping each other heal, and that’s what makes it so special.

Why Best Medicine Has Been An Instant Hit For Fox

The new medical comedy-drama is already a hit, giving Fox its best show launch in three years. It successfully combines the popular formats of weekly medical cases and heartwarming stories about a close-knit community, making it appealing to a wide audience.

The show focuses just as much on the connections between characters as it does on the medical mysteries. You’ll actually get to know Dr. Best’s Aunt Sarah and his cheerful assistant Elaine better than many of the patients. It really draws you into the lives and relationships within the town – like the developing romance between Dr. Best and teacher Louisa, or the unexpectedly charming Sheriff Mylow, who used to be engaged to Louisa.

Best Medicine Characters
Character Role Actor Best Known Roles
Dr. Martin Best Town doctor with a lack of bedside manner Josh Charles Sports Night, The Good Wife, Dead Poet’s Society
Louisa Gavin Town schoolteacher & Martin’s romantic interest Abigail Spencer All My Children, Angela’s Eyes, Timeless
Sheriff Mark Mylow Town sheriff & Louisa’s ex-fiancé Josh Segarra She-Hulk: Attorney at Law, Animal Control
Elaine Denton Dr. Best’s assistant & aspiring YouTuber Cree Game Shakers
Aunt Sarah Dr. Best’s aunt & local lobster woman Annie Potts Ghostbusters, Designing Women, Young Sheldon

Unlike many sitcoms that rely on general jokes, or serious medical shows with sharp wit, Best Medicine focuses on funny situations that come from its characters. A lot of the comedy happens when the straightforward Dr. Best interacts with the overly friendly people in town, creating moments that are both awkward and heartwarming.

The town of Port Wynn is a major reason the show has become so popular. It has a warm, inviting feel, reminding many of the charming community in Gilmore Girls. Port Wynn is filled with unique traditions, like the Blueberry Festival and monthly bean dinners, and even quirky spots like the Blood Factory. While it’s a bit of an idealized place, it feels incredibly welcoming.

This situation perfectly casts Dr. Best as an outsider. Similar to the character Gregory House from the show House, he notices everything and can’t overlook even the smallest medical detail. Because of this, he feels compelled to investigate any mystery, even if it just starts with a cough or a rash, even when he’d rather not get involved.

What To Expect From Best Medicine Season 2

There’s still a lot of story to tell with the show, especially since it’s based on the popular British series Doc Martin, which ran for nine seasons. Although this American version is a bit more heartwarming, it follows the same basic idea.

If Best Medicine stays true to the style of the show it’s based on, the second season will probably explore Dr. Best’s fear of blood in more detail. Like in Doc Martin, where the doctor’s condition became common knowledge and a continuing part of the story, Dr. Best’s phobia could become a long-term challenge he struggles with.

The show could also explore new relationships within Dr. Best’s family. Like in Doc Martin, where the death of an aunt brought a new relative to town and changed the doctor’s life, a similar event could happen here. This would add depth to Dr. Best’s personal life, although the unique mix of warmth and criticism provided by Aunt Sarah would be hard to replace.

Meanwhile, Best Medicine will probably keep developing the unique atmosphere of Port Wynn. Because American TV seasons are usually longer than British ones, the show has more opportunity to delve into the town’s customs and everyday life.

Season 2 of Best Medicine will likely continue storylines we’ve already seen, while also starting new ones. This will allow the town’s unique traditions to change and develop as Dr. Best becomes more involved with the people who live there.

Like Screen Rant’s TV coverage? Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get exclusive insights from actors and creators about the shows you love. Just be sure to select “Network TV” in your newsletter preferences!

Read More

2026-03-10 21:41