Forget Clint Eastwood — Sergio Leone’s Greatest Western Hero Isn’t Who You Think

by

Sergio Leone revolutionized Westerns in film, giving us classics like A Fistful of Dollars and Once Upon a Time in the West. He populated these movies with memorable characters – from ruthless villains to strong, silent heroes. While audiences adore The Man With No Name, many consider it to be only one of Leone’s many achievements, and not necessarily his best.

Sergio Leone created some of the most memorable and complex characters in Western films. Even today, his storytelling style is clearly visible in countless Wild West movies and has deeply influenced directors like Quentin Tarantino and Steven Spielberg. His compelling villains and mysterious heroes helped him reimagine the Old West, and to say he was simply a transformative director doesn’t fully capture his enormous impact on cinema. While others may deserve the title of ‘most impactful director,’ Leone’s influence is truly unparalleled.

Once Upon a Time in the West Is Leone’s Magnum Opus

Sergio Leone revisited the Wild West with his film, Once Upon a Time in the West. The story starts with a cold-blooded killer named Frank murdering the McBain family, who owned land desired for a new railroad. Frank was hired by a greedy landowner and assumes the property is now available. However, Mr. McBain secretly married Jill, a former saloon girl, and she arrives in town just as the locals begin funeral preparations. Though she has no prior connection to the town of Sweetwater, Jill is determined to fulfill her late husband’s dream of building it. She quickly finds herself allied with two gunslingers: Harmonica, who is seeking revenge on Frank and his crew, and Cheyenne, an outlaw who develops feelings for Jill.

The group works together to fulfill McBain’s vision – securing the land for a railroad and the new town it would create. But the agreement depends on finishing the road before the train arrives. As Frank tries to take the land from Jill, her friends step up to protect her, putting themselves in danger. They face off against a group of killers and a dishonest businessman, all while dealing with complicated relationships. Cheyenne is in love with Jill, but finds herself drawn to Harmonica, while her past marriage was more about opportunity than affection – a reflection of the harsh realities of life in the Wild West.

Once Upon a Time in the West is a cinematic masterpiece that truly highlights Sergio Leone’s skill as a director. Building on the success of his Dollars Trilogy, the film expands on everything that made those movies great – from the drawn-out, suspenseful opening to Ennio Morricone’s iconic music and the film’s deeper meaning. The hero, Harmonica, is a compelling figure with a more personal motivation than Leone’s previous protagonists, while the villain, Frank, is even more menacing than any from the earlier films. The character of Jill adds a strong and courageous heart to the story. Together, these elements combine to create what many consider the ultimate Western.

Jill McBain Is Leone’s Greatest Character

Jill McBain immediately becomes the heart of Once Upon a Time in the West, a fact emphasized by both the storytelling and Ennio Morricone’s beautiful music. Claudia Cardinale delivers the film’s most compelling performance, even outshining established stars like Charles Bronson and Henry Fonda. From the moment she steps off the train, she captivates the audience. When she discovers the bodies of her family, Cardinale powerfully conveys her character’s grief and pain, ultimately lifting the film to masterpiece status.

Jill is portrayed as a remarkably resourceful woman who deeply understands the challenges of the West. Her ability to survive is both a strength and a source of sadness, suggesting a difficult past that has taught her how to navigate a harsh world. Despite this past, she bravely dedicates herself to honoring her late husband and protecting his reputation, even though it wasn’t originally her goal. The film implies that McBain was the first person to treat her with genuine kindness, and she feels compelled to support his vision because of that. For someone so practical, her actions at Sweetwater are inspiring, marking the start of a significant personal transformation, both for her as a character and as a symbol of change.

While many Western fans consider the Man With No Name to be Sergio Leone’s most iconic character, he was actually designed to be quite simple. Blondie isn’t meant to be a complex character study, but rather a basic representation of Western ideals – an archetype, not a fully developed person. This simplicity allows viewers to easily imagine themselves as him, making the film a form of escapism. In contrast, the character of Jill is far more intricate and the story truly revolves around her experiences and perspective.

Once Upon a Time in the West’s Symbolism is Perfect

While The Dollars Trilogy aimed to reimagine the classic gunslinger, Once Upon a Time in the West goes much deeper. Though Harmonica and Cheyenne share similarities with the hero from that earlier series, this film is more about the changing West itself. Essentially, it’s the story of two gunslingers, relics of a fading era, who risk everything to help bring the Old West to a close and make way for progress. As Jill builds a town, she brings civilization to a lawless land, and the railroad symbolizes the arrival of industry and connection to the wider country.

By the end of the film, Frank’s death represents the end of the violent, lawless days of the Old West. Harmonica and Cheyenne both realize they don’t belong in the new, more settled world that’s emerging. Jill, now independent, steps forward to help the workers, demonstrating her readiness to embrace a more civilized life. She transforms from a mistreated outsider into a key figure in building a better future, finally finding meaning in her life. Though saying goodbye to Harmonica is heartbreaking, it’s a necessary part of her journey.

Most of Sergio Leone’s characters don’t really change throughout his films. Figures like Tuco, the Man With No Name, Angel Eyes, and Harmonica might achieve their immediate goals – getting rich or taking revenge – but they remain essentially the same people. This makes Jill unique; she’s the only character who truly evolves, and her journey represents the changing face of America itself.

Jill isn’t strong because of fighting skills or physical power. Her true strength comes from her bravery, ability to bounce back, and inner toughness. Even when her life is at risk or Frank tries to stop her, she remains dedicated to continuing McBain’s work and making his goals a reality.

Once Upon a Time in the West Eclipses the Dollars Trilogy

While The Dollars Trilogy delivers classic Western action, Once Upon a Time in the West offers a more sophisticated take on the genre. It’s a revisionist Western, but it balances a gritty, realistic portrayal of the Old West with moments of hope and inspiration. The film centers on Jill McBain, brilliantly played by Claudia Cardinale – a strong, determined woman who embodies the resilience of Western heroes, but with a richer, more complex character.

Sergio Leone’s work is hugely influential and changed the landscape of film. Through movies like A Fistful of Dollars and Once Upon a Time in America, he reshaped how we see American legends, from cowboys to criminals. And in Once Upon a Time in the West, he surpassed even his famous ‘Man With No Name’ character, creating the iconic Jill McBain and delivering his most compelling Western hero.

Read More

2025-10-30 16:07