Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Review: A Stronger Sequel Still Dragged Down by Old Problems

by

The games started as basic survival horror adventures where you just clicked to play, but they soon became incredibly popular worldwide because of their detailed backstory and memorable frightening moments. When the first movie was a big success with audiences, excitement for the next one grew even more.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 successfully expands on the first movie, which is rare for video game adaptations—only franchises like Sonic the Hedgehog and Super Mario have really broken through. While the sequel offers plenty of fun references and memorable scenes for dedicated fans, it focuses so much on them that it might not appeal to those unfamiliar with the games or general horror movie fans. What excites longtime FNAF followers might not be enough to grab everyone else’s attention.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is Better Than the First, But Lacks Direction

The movie Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 brings back Josh Hutcherson, Piper Rubio, and Elizabeth Lail as Mike and Abby Schmidt, and Vanessa Afton. While it seemed like the supernatural events had ended after the first film, the movie reveals that the terrifying spirits from the original location have begun to awaken.

Abby is determined to free Freddy Fazbear and the other spirits stuck inside the animatronics. Meanwhile, Mike and Vanessa find themselves back at the original location where the haunting began. The movie does a good job of establishing the story and, similar to the first film, includes little scares to keep the audience engaged. However, when the movie isn’t actively trying to frighten you, it becomes clear that the plot lacks a strong focus.

Most viewers, unlike the characters Mike and Vanessa, find the story to be mostly funny and lighthearted. This is in line with the franchise’s appeal to children who grew up with the games and books. However, this focus on humor also prevents the movie from fully resolving its core identity issues, much like the first film.

While Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 delivers bigger scares, impressive animatronics, and a surprisingly good handling of its story, it feels unsure of its own identity. It attempts to blend horror, comedy, and supernatural thrills, but doesn’t fully commit to any single genre, ultimately falling short of its potential.

As a film fan, I found this movie sets up a really tense situation with what should be huge consequences, but then it feels like everything gets resolved a little too easily. The characters always seem to have enough time to think their way out of trouble, which sometimes doesn’t even make sense within the movie’s own rules. Like, one minute a robotic creature is super fast and creepy, and the next it’s conveniently slow, just so our heroes can outsmart it. It’s a bit jarring, honestly.

The film’s unevenness – in both the villains’ actions and its overall mood – makes it primarily appealing to existing fans. It has trouble consistently blending scary moments with lighter, more thoughtful ones. Just when the movie seems to settle into a groove, the tone abruptly changes again.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2’s Puppets are Scary, But Need More Presence

Fans keep coming back to Five Nights at Freddy’s because of its characters and story, but especially because the first movie was a hit, and the second one is even better. However, the story feels incomplete – like getting only small tastes of something truly amazing, leaving you wanting more.

The Marionette is definitely the most impressive part of Five Nights at Freddy’s 2. The filmmakers did the right thing by building anticipation for this character, as it’s genuinely creepy and lives up to the game’s version. The puppetry work is fantastic, especially for a horror movie, and it’s a real achievement. However, while it shines in certain scenes, the Marionette is often missing, which is the film’s biggest problem – we simply need to see more of the puppets.

When the toy versions of the characters actually do something, like Mangle in the movie, it can be genuinely frightening. The same goes for the older, damaged versions of the characters, but they mostly just stand around looking threatening, waiting for something to happen. They don’t have a lot of active moments beyond the occasional movement or attempt to stop the player.

The puppets aren’t necessarily meant to be quick, but the way they’re presented makes them seem restricted, and not due to the limitations of the costumes themselves. Furthermore, the animatronics’ behavior is inconsistent – some who haven’t previously been violent are suddenly responsible for deaths.

While Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 looks great and features excellent practical effects, the movie mostly uses these impressive creations for quick scares. Though the film does a good job building tension in certain moments, like with the Marionette, the puppets often feel like they could have been used more effectively. What we see is visually striking, but it feels like a glimpse of what the effects could do, rather than a full showcase of their capabilities.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is a Great Movie For Fans, But Casual Viewers Will Struggle

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 stands out as a special sequel in a horror series that’s already known for being different—it’s grown from games into books and a complex storyline. These films could have just been made to make money, but they actually delve deeply—and sometimes intensely—into the series’ established history. The story tweaks some characters and details, but the core lore stays true and even includes unexpected twists.

The movie starts with little details and scenes that aren’t essential to the plot, but they actually make it more engaging. However, this focus on detail also creates a problem: the movie is geared so much towards existing fans that it might not appeal to newcomers. While the film is fun to watch, it’s hard to fully enjoy if you aren’t already familiar with the story and characters.

The plot is famously intricate and detailed, making it somewhat challenging for a general audience to follow, despite being logically structured. However, the movie doesn’t pause to provide extensive explanations; it gives brief background information when necessary and keeps moving at a fast pace, even if viewers haven’t fully grasped everything.

The movie’s shifting tone, combined with a complicated plot, might make it enjoyable in moments for horror fans, but ultimately leave them feeling lost. While revisiting the puppets from the original film is a nice touch, the explanation that they were just early versions feels forced. The story even goes beyond the complexity of the Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 game.

This sequel has a lot going on, attempting to balance many different elements. Despite this, it confidently sets up future installments with promises of exciting developments. While Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 might not appeal to all players, it stays true to its own ideas, which will satisfy many fans.

The game continues the series in a positive direction, and could be even better with a more focused atmosphere and more development for its scary characters. While Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is a step forward, it doesn’t quite reach the level of a truly essential installment.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is in theaters on December 5.

Read More

2025-12-04 09:08