Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

As a seasoned fantasy enthusiast, I must say that my heart has been captivated by the enthralling narrative unfolding in “The Rings of Power.” Each episode seems to outdo the last, weaving a complex web of intrigue and drama that leaves me on the edge of my seat.


let’s delve into scrutiny and ranking! Let’s systematically evaluate each of the eight episodes from Season 2 of The Rings of Power, arranging them from least favored to most appreciated, with “least favored” and “most appreciated” being subjective terms.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

8. Episode 204, “Eldest”

The Rings of Power” takes place during Middle-earth’s Second Age, which precedes the story we commonly associate with “The Lord of the Rings.” Some characters are recurring and some are entirely new, but the tales of certain characters, such as elf Arondir, Númenórean Isildur, and human Estrid, are more on the tedious side. The show primarily focuses on their quest to locate Arondir’s stepson Theo, who was abducted by an Ent. Unfortunately, every character in this story seems uninteresting, making it rather dull as well.

Additionally, we monitor Galadriel and Elrond as they escort elves to the city of Eregion. However, their journey is interrupted by wraiths and orcs. The elves, much like humans in their lack of alertness, almost get caught unawares. Meanwhile, in the remote sands of Rhûn, a character from J.R.R. Tolkien’s original trilogy named Stranger, who possesses magical abilities, encounters Tom Bombadil, a figure reimagined here as a mysterious mentor. This character was originally part of Tolkien’s books but has been given a new role in this context.

Everything about this feels unusual or off-putting. However, I must admit that my preferred part is when Nori, the harfoot character, encounters a new group of harfoots in Rhûn, which she discovers alongside her friend Poppy. Apart from that, this episode seems more designed for tolerance than pleasure.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

7. Episode 203, “The Eagle and the Sceptre”

In this episode of “The Rings of Power,” it appears the human characters are struggling to make an impact. Isildur, Arondir, and Estrid converge, but their journey lacks intensity compared to their adventure in “Endless.” On the other hand, Queen Regent Míriel fails to secure her coronation on the island nation of Númenor this season, leaving viewers with a sense that key scenes are missing or connections with characters feel tenuous. Although not poorly done, these segments can be somewhat tedious.

As a dedicated gamer, I’ve been thoroughly enjoying “The Eagle and the Sceptre” so far, though it may not be setting the world on fire. Consistency seems to be the name of the game with this season of The Rings of Power, as each episode offers a slightly varying degree of quality. But here’s the kicker: things are only getting better from here!

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

6. Episode 202, “Where the Stars Are Strange”

To start off, the opening episodes of The Rings of Power season 2 lay a lot of groundwork for what follows. In Episode 202, The Stranger and the Harfoots delve further into the land of Rhûn, offering delightful banter along the way. Sauron, hidden as the celestial figure Annatar, unmasks himself to the elven blacksmith Celebrimbor, sparking one of the season’s most captivating storylines. Meanwhile, beneath the mountains in the dwarven stronghold of Khazad-dûm, we reconnect with Disa and Durin IV. They may not do much in this episode, but the dwarves, known for their relatable, warm, and humorous nature, make every encounter enjoyable.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

5. Episode 201, “Elven Kings Under the Sky”

The first episode of The Rings of Power season 2 presents a conundrum for the elves: having recently crafted their elf-rings, which can protect against decay but could potentially be tainted since they were fashioned under Sauron’s (disguised as Halbrand) influence, what will they do with them? This dilemma causes discord among the elves — Elrond even leaps from a waterfall in an attempt to prevent their use. However, in the end, the elves don these rings and Middle-earth flourishes once more.

The elves come off as somewhat rigid, but it provides them with stakes and motivations. However, the most captivating moments of this episode are dedicated to Sauron. At the onset, we witness a flashback depicting the world shortly after the end of the First Age, where Sauron is deceived by his subordinate and must regain strength, transforming from a mound of slime into something resembling a human form over an unspecified period.

It’s enjoyable spending time with Sauron right now. He seems like the leading figure of the current storyline, and this series of events appears to be setting him up for future victories.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

4. Episode 207, “Doomed to Die”

The season climaxes with a massive siege of Eregion, with the corrupted elf Adar harrying the elven city walls from without and Sauron masquerading as a benevolent protector to the citizens within. Things really get going in “Doomed to Die,” but there are some weird moments that hold me back from kicking it up the list. For instance, at one point Elrond gives an inspirational speech to a random archer, who then saves the day and dies in slow motion. It’s shot like an epic moment, expect that we’d never met this person before and it has no emotional impact, no matter how the show tries to sell it. Sometimes The Rings of Power assumes that mounting an expensive action scene is effort enough, but without connections to the characters, it doesn’t count for much.

Although I may have expressed some reservations, the fight remains captivating. The most intriguing moments, however, revolve around Celebrimbor and Sauron, with the latter deceitfully persuading the elven blacksmith to craft the Rings of Power. Indeed, Sauron never fails to be engaging as a cunning manipulator.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

3. Episode 206, “Where Is He?”

Exploring the Effective Elements of ‘The Rings of Power’ focuses on the scenes that capture our interest: we delve deeply into the dwarven community, following Durin IV’s internal struggle over betraying his father, and observing Celebrimbor as Sauron, the future dark lord, manipulates him to appear insane. The plot thickens further on Númenor, as Míriel leaves the determination of her rulership to a colossal sea creature.

The episode gets docked a couple points for another weird scene with Tom Bombadil in Rhûn, but the season is really cooking at this point.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

2. Episode 205, “Halls of Stone”

From a devoted fan’s perspective, “Halls of Stone” resonates similarly to “Who Is He?” due to their shared strengths, but it elevates those aspects with finesse. In the depths of Khazad-dûm, Durin IV finds himself torn between witnessing his father’s corruption by greed and preserving their newly reconciled bond – a profoundly human struggle in an extraordinary setting inhabited by non-humans. This tale beautifully explores the complexities of relationships and the struggle between loyalty and morality.

In addition, this point in the Númenor storyline may very well be its peak. The newly crowned king of the island, Ar-Pharazôn, gazes longingly across the ocean towards the everlasting land of elves, creating a suspenseful character-focused moment that I feel the series could have featured more often. Subsequently, a confrontation between Pharazôn and Míriel’s followers occurs in an intense scene.

Every episode of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, ranked worst to best

1. Episode 208, “Shadow and Flame”

The finale of season 2 is also its best episode, which is a plus; it’s good to end on a high note. The Siege of Eregion ends with several entertaining scenes, including a shape-shifting fight between Sauron and Galadriel, a kind of redemption for Adar, and a barn-burner of a scene where Sauron pelts his friend and colleague Celebrimbor with arrows to torture him for information. If Sauron is the main character of the show, this is one of the scenes that makes him.

I also really enjoyed Durin III leaping into the battle against the monstrous balrog hidden deep beneath even the depths of Khazad-dûm, taking responsibility for how his greed had roused the creature and passing kingship of the dwarven realm onto his son. I wasn’t as enthusiastic with how the show wrapped up things in Númenór (rushed) or in Rhûn (ditto), but overall this was a solid way to end the season.

As an ardent fan, I can’t hide my excitement about the possibility that The Rings of Power might grace our screens once more in 2026, though it hasn’t received an official confirmation for a third season yet.

Read More

2024-10-12 01:46

Previous post Review: Surrounded by beauty, the world mysteriously unravels in ‘The Universal Theory’