Emmys 2024: The 12 shows that deserved to be nominated for an Emmy (and the 5 that got too many)

As a long-time television critic with a deep appreciation for the art of storytelling and acting, I find this year’s Emmy nominations to be quite perplexing. Having spent decades immersed in the world of television, I’ve seen my fair share of critically acclaimed shows and those that left audiences scratching their heads.

Each year, I eagerly anticipate the Emmy Award nominations, knowing full well that there will be both disappointments and delightful surprises. It’s only natural that certain shows or performances miss out on recognition while others seem to secure a spot year after year, even when they’ve passed their prime. Emmy voters often lean toward the familiar names, but every so often, they surprise us with unconventional nominations. And the 2024 Emmys are shaping up to be no exception to this pattern.

As a passionate gamer of the TV awards scene, I can’t help but notice that this year’s Emmy nominations took me by surprise in both good and bad ways. Shows like “Shogun,” “True Detective: Night Country,” and “The Bear” were rightfully expected to make an appearance, but some unexpected gems, such as Maya Rudolph’s performance in “Loot,” truly stole the show.

DESERVED: 

Young Sheldon

Kick-starting the discussion on network TV, it’s astounding that “Young Sheldon,” which wrapped up its finest season yet, didn’t receive any recognition from the Emmys for Best Comedy or for any of its cast members. The heartfelt episode depicting the family dealing with Sheldon’s father’s passing was deserving of nominations for the principal actors, and the series boasted one of the most compelling finales a comedy could deliver. It’s perplexing that this remarkable show was overlooked by the Emmy voters despite “The Big Bang Theory” consistently being a favorite, as “Young Sheldon” arguably surpassed it in quality.

Ghosts

This CBS comedy, which has received rave reviews from critics, unfortunately hasn’t gained much popularity. Rose McIver once again shined in her role, but the real standouts were the supporting actors Brandon Scott Jones, Rebecca Wisocky, and Asher Grodman. The show was exceptional during its latest season and is a rare example of classic comedy on television today. However, despite its merits, it seems to be overlooked by Emmy Award voters, much like its unassuming characters.

The Curse

Emma Stone’s surprising absence from Emmy nominations is puzzling, given her second Oscar win and the widespread acclaim for her performance in “The Showtime Comedy.” With its critical success, a talented cast, and intriguing plot twists, many expected at least a nod in the Best Comedy or Limited Series categories. Instead, it seems that this series has been overlooked by Emmy voters, leaving Stone’s recognition unearned.

Loki

In the past year, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has encountered some setbacks, but “Loki” wasn’t among them. The second and last (for now) season of this series took viewers on an exhilarating journey through various timelines. Tom Hiddleston delivered a brilliant performance as the titular character, and the supporting cast, led by Ke Huy Quan, was exceptional. His acting alone merited recognition with an Emmy nomination. The finale was engaging and enjoyable, not just for Marvel enthusiasts but also for those new to the universe. Unfortunately, the Emmy voters seemed to miss out on its delightful essence.

Masters of the Air

Previously, a collaboration between Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks was a guaranteed success at the Emmys. This was evident with “Band of Brothers” and “The Pacific.” Regrettably, their most recent World War II production for Apple TV+ didn’t resonate with voters. Despite an extensive budget, an impressive cast, heart-pounding battle sequences, and emotionally charged storyline depicting the sacrifices of war, this exceptional production unfortunately fell flat during Emmy nominations.

The Gentlemen

Perhaps Guy Ritchie’s style is too refined for Emmy voters, who missed out on the enjoyable blend of action, dark humor, and exceptional acting found in his Netflix series. Notably, Theo James delivered a standout performance as a soldier entangled in a mob conspiracy, while Ray Winstone brought hysterical scenes to life. Unfortunately, the Emmy judges seemed unable to look past the violence and acknowledge this unexpectedly entertaining show.

Franklin

In most cases, an actor who has won an Oscar and stars in a historical mini-series is a strong contender for Emmy Awards. However, Michael Douglas’ portrayal of a Founding Father in this Apple TV+ production went unrecognized despite positive critic reception. The series boasted impressive production elements worthy of nominations for costume design and cinematography, making its absence in these categories quite surprising. Unfortunately, it seems that the Emmy voters did not find this educational program appealing.

The Regime

As someone who has spent years immersed in the world of television criticism, I’ve seen my fair share of polarizing shows. This HBO dark comedy, in particular, left critics divided, with some praising its unique premise and others finding it too outlandish to be enjoyable. However, I couldn’t help but be captivated by Kate Winslet’s mesmerizing portrayal of an Eastern European dictator.

Expats

This Prime Video production, an engrossing miniseries based on a beloved book, boasted a renowned actress like Nicole Kidman and offered a captivating perspective of Hong Kong life for locals, newcomers, and visitors. Despite its lengthy episodes, some as long as movies, and challenging themes, the Emmy Awards’ voters seemed to steer clear. One might have assumed Kidman’s acclaimed performance would merit recognition rather than the series being overlooked.

Lawman: Bass Reeves

If Yellowstone was undecided, the Emmys had an opportunity to recognize Taylor Sheridan’s other remarkable show from last year. Its captivating portrayal of a lesser-known historical figure was enhanced by David Oyelowo’s compelling performance as the lead character. The ensemble cast, including the late Donald Sutherland in one of his final acts, was equally deserving of recognition. Despite debates over genre classification, this exceptional Western merited Emmy nominations.

For All Mankind

In the fourth season of Apple TV+’s acclaimed sci-fi series, the alternate history setting reached new heights. Not only did we witness a captivating portrayal of a drastically different 2000s, but we were also treated to an engaging storyline filled with power struggles between various factions, worker uprisings versus corporations, and unexpected political turns. The ensemble cast delivered stellar performances, the writing was exceptional, and unfortunately, this remarkable genre show continued to be overlooked by the Emmy Awards.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds/Lower Decks

As a passionate gamer and avid fan of science fiction shows, I can’t help but feel disappointed once again. Star Trek: Strange New Worlds delivered captivating storylines and intriguing characters, not to mention the stunning musical episode that left us all in awe. And yet, no recognition from the Emmys in the sound categories? It’s perplexing, to say the least.

TOO MANY:

Palm Royale

As a gamer, I can’t believe my eyes at this Emmy nomination twist. The Apple TV+ show I watched received some harsh criticism from both audiences and critics. They labeled it as overlong, bloated, flat, and a massive waste of an incredible cast’s talents. It’s baffling how this underperforming show ended up with nominations for Best Comedy and nods to its stars, Kristin Wiig and Carol Burnett. I’m left scratching my head in confusion, wondering if the Emmy selection process is more of a game than I thought.

The Morning Show

Regarding Apple TV+ and its launch series, it’s intriguing how the Emmy Awards voters continue to be captivated by this show, despite its shift from serious drama to a more campy tone. In Season 3, the storylines became excessive, and the acting veered towards being overdramatic, resembling a prestige production. Amazingly, it received nominations for Outstanding Drama Series, as well as an impressive ten acting nods, with four of those going to Supporting Actresses in Drama. It seems that the Emmy voters are so enamored by the celebrity factor that they overlook the show’s shortcomings and shower it with undue recognition at awards shows.

The Bear

The Bear is a great show, that can’t be denied. Yet it’s ironic a show once considered “flying under the radar” is now dominating the Emmys with a record 23 nominations. The jarring part is that practically the one cast member not recognized is Abby Elliott, who turned in some fantastic work this past season. Folks still argue about whether it’s a comedy or drama but it seems voters go a tad overboard giving The Bear so many nominations and crowding out other potential nominees. 

Mr. & Mrs. Smith

The Prime Video series we enjoy so much has surprised critics with its numerous award nominations for this humor-infused action comedy. Donald Glover and Maya Erskine are up for the leading roles, although rumors suggest they might depart in Season 2. Glover’s writing recognition is also unusual. Notable guest stars like John Turturro, Paul Dano, Parker Posey, and Sarah Paulson have also earned nominations. The latter two were merely titled “Therapist” and “Other Jane,” with no defined characters. Given the abundance of talented actors overlooked for recognition, the Emmys’ decision to honor this action show’s ensemble cast is perplexing.

FEUD: Capote Vs The Swans

Although this new installment in FX’s anthology didn’t receive a Best Limited Series recognition at the Emmys, it can be debated that it received more recognition than merited. This is evident in the nods given to Gus Van Sant for direction and the performances of Tom Hollander, Naomi Watts, and Diane Lane, which were not universally praised by critics. Sadly, it seems that Treat Williams’ nomination was more a result of his final appearance in the show, as the series faced criticism for its tone and historical inaccuracies, potentially taking nominations away from more deserving talents.

The 2024 Emmy Awards air Sunday, Sept. 15, at 8/7c on ABC. Stream on Hulu the next day.

Read More

• MANA PREDICTION. MANA cryptocurrency
• LDO PREDICTION. LDO cryptocurrency
• VET PREDICTION. VET cryptocurrency
• The end of Superhero TV on broadcast may usher in an era that leaves a generation behind
• TRUMP PREDICTION. TRUMP cryptocurrency
• BTC PREDICTION. BTC cryptocurrency
• LTC PREDICTION. LTC cryptocurrency
• XNO PREDICTION. XNO cryptocurrency
• GFAL PREDICTION. GFAL cryptocurrency
• MEOW PREDICTION. MEOW cryptocurrency

2024-07-17 23:28