Movies

Disney’s Secret Reason for Dumping Narnia: The Feud That Killed a Franchise

BBG News

C.S. Lewis’ book series, initially published in the 1950s, has remained a significant part of literary lore. Although various TV productions have been made based on the series, Hollywood hasn’t quite managed to convey its core ideas and narrative effectively. However, everything shifted in 2005 when Disney took on the challenge of adapting “The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.

Following remarkable theater earnings, Disney went on to transform additional two books into films. Yet, a fourth adaption met its demise due to a creative disagreement between the producers and Disney. Nonetheless, it appears that Disney harbored grand ambitions for materializing this magical realm on screen.

Disney Had Plans to Adapt The Silver Chair

Despite C.S. Lewis’s initial reluctance to allow adaptations of his book series for television and film, his stepson eventually granted the rights following the impressive CGI animation of Aslan. Immediately afterward, they began production, debuting The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe in 2005 and Prince Caspian in 2008. However, concerns arose when the franchise was taken over by 20th Century Fox. Nevertheless, the production company managed to adapt well, resulting in the release of a third film, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, in 2010. Consequently, it appeared that the company was on track to produce the fourth film, The Silver Chair.

Back in October 2011, Douglas Gresham, Lewis’ literary executor, announced that the contract between C.S. Lewis and Waldon Media had ended, and they were looking for a new partner to collaborate with. Three years later, in 2013, it was revealed that The Mark Gordon Company would be working with the estate to produce “The Silver Chair.” Mark Gordon, being an ardent fan of the tales, expressed his desire to bring the entire fictional realm to fruition. In an interview, the producer shared his thoughts on this endeavor.

20th Century Fox was still involved in the project, suggesting that the movie had a major distribution company backing it up. In the past, this was a positive sign since the distributor had been instrumental in producing several successful children’s films like “Horton Hears a Who” and “Marley & Me”. Additionally, Walden Media proposed an equal partnership, allowing 20th Century Fox to significantly profit from the expanding franchise. Initially, fans were unconcerned about these alterations as they anticipated the series would undergo significant changes with this new narrative. The storyline of “The Silver Chair” deviates from the Pevensie children and instead follows a revamped Eustace Scrubb alongside a girl named Jill. Together, they join Aslan in search of Prince Caspian’s missing son.

By 2013, screenwriter David Magee was recruited to write the script for the film, and a fan engagement initiative was launched inviting fans to suggest names for the Lady of Green Kirtle. However, following this, there was an extended period of silence regarding the project, causing some apprehension among fans. In 2018, it became known that Netflix would be taking charge of a fresh Narnia endeavor, indicating that Disney and 20th Century Fox had completely relinquished control over the franchise. Despite neither company ever explaining their reasons for cancelling The Silver Chair, it’s evident that other production companies perceived greater value in the series.

Harsh Feuds and Budget Cuts Made the Fourth Film Impossible to Produce

Initially, it might appear that Disney stopped producing The Chronicles of Narnia series due to financial losses. However, this wasn’t entirely accurate. Although the second and third films didn’t match the success of the first, they still generated significant revenue at the box office. Remarkably, the film franchise accumulated an impressive $1.6 billion despite a total production budget of $560 million. Furthermore, the notion that Narnia alienated viewers with its strong Christian symbolism doesn’t hold much weight. Sadly, the real reason behind the cancellation of The Silver Chair was due to Philip Anschutz, a significant investor in Walden Media, seeking a substantial portion of the distribution rights.

Due to Anschutz’s strong faith and commitment to creating Christian-themed content for wide audiences, he was resolute in ensuring the success of the Narnia films, regardless of the financial implications. He also held a significant share in Regal Entertainment Group, giving him control over one of the world’s second-largest movie theater chains, which led to friction with Disney and Walden Media. The situation worsened when Prince Caspian underperformed compared to the first film, causing Walden Media to continually pressure Disney. As anticipated, Disney eventually relinquished control over the franchise to 20th Century Fox, which explains why the third film was distributed by a different corporation rather than Disney. With Disney out of the equation, it appears that the C.S. Lewis estate faced difficulties in bringing the fourth film to life, primarily due to lack of sufficient funding support.

Essentially, this dispute offers fans a plausible explanation for why the fourth movie never came out. During that period, numerous rumors were spreading, many suggesting that Lewis’ religious beliefs had damaged the series’ reputation. Some also claimed that the franchise had strayed too far from its biblical origins, leading to further controversy. The second film was more secular and included several intense fight sequences. In response, the C.S. Lewis Society promptly criticized Disney’s adaptation of the tale, pointing out deviations from the original story.

However, it’s clear that Disney wasn’t perpetually at odds with Anschutz as suggested earlier. Instead, Disney became weary of Walden Media’s control over their projects. With a film underperforming, it’s logical for them to desire a separation. This dispute between the two parties isn’t lost on fans, especially considering the religious themes in the Narnia series that played a significant role in its ongoing success and popularity.

Netflix Is Keen to Extend the Franchise Further

Although it’s a bit disappointing that Disney and 20th Century Studios didn’t manage to bring this beloved book series to the screen, enthusiasts have shifted their expectations towards the future. There’s a strong possibility that Netflix might take on one of Narnia’s less popular novels, “The Magician’s Nephew,” which is actually the first book in the series, with “The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe” following as the second. Fans are well aware that Greta Gerwig, famous for her work on movies like Barbie and Little Women, is set to direct this project. Speculations about the cast have been running rampant, with one popular rumor floating around. No matter what happens next, fans are eagerly awaiting more updates on this series and are intrigued by the potential influence of streaming on these upcoming films.

Indeed, this news is quite intriguing, yet it sheds light on Disney’s missteps with the Narnia franchise. Initially, they excelled with the first movie, making subsequent adaptations appear less impressive. Remarkably, even after 20 years, the CGI in the film remains impressive, and the story stays true to its roots. However, it seems that Prince Caspian was the turning point. Disney increased the budget from $180 million to $220 million, hoping for better special effects, but the darker tone left fans disappointed as they expected a lighter, fairytale-like series. Moreover, in their enthusiasm, Disney overspent on promotional items like toys and merchandise, totaling approximately $175 million. They even created an attraction at Hollywood Studios at Walt Disney World, but these efforts could not prevent the inevitable struggles.

Essentially, enthusiasts are eager for Netflix to learn from past errors and develop a more extensive Narnia series. While the Narnia tales are renowned for their rich history and Biblical undertones, they still present a literal story about a talking lion, a wicked witch, and a magical wardrobe. However, this doesn’t prevent Netflix from exploring its source material creatively. The upcoming adaptation by Greta Gerwig has sparked curiosity due to her success with the Barbie movie. Moreover, many spectators are backing the gender-neutral casting of Aslan and the recent news about Emma Mackey playing the White Witch, as it opens the door for well-known actors to join the project. Regardless of the future direction of the movies, Narnia fans simply hope that the new generation of creators will do the franchise justice.

Read More

2025-05-01 06:06

Previous post The Substance’s Dennis Quaid Gets Real About Eating So Much Shrimp While Filming That Uncomfortable Scene, And I Feel Queasy
Next post You Won’t Believe What Just Happened to XRP! Bears, Bulls, and $13.9 Million in Liquidations