Critics Have Seen The Pitt Season 2, And They’re Having The Same Reaction To Another ‘Chaotic’ Day In The ER

Great medical dramas are known for their gripping intensity, high stakes, and often, realistic scenes. The Pitt delivers on all fronts, earning awards for its cast, including Noah Wyle, throughout its first season (available on HBO Max). As Season 2 of The Pitt approaches its 2026 release, early reviews of the first nine episodes out of fifteen suggest the show continues to be a compelling watch.

Season 2 of The Pitt jumps forward ten months, continuing to follow the emergency room staff through a single shift in real time. This season takes place on the Fourth of July in Pittsburgh, promising some dramatic firework-related injuries! Reviews are coming in, and Alison Herman of Variety calls the show’s return “triumphant,” noting that it doesn’t need major changes after a successful first season. The actors have subtly developed their characters, and the show continues to tackle important social issues. Herman adds:

Season 2’s storylines tackle difficult social issues that emerge when people are at their most vulnerable. The show consistently champions progressive values, offering a strong contrast to current conservative viewpoints. This season’s episodes specifically address topics like ICE deportations, bias against larger bodies in healthcare, end-of-life cancer care, homelessness, the risks of AI technology, and the importance of providing sign language interpreters for deaf patients.

In a review for The Daily Beast, Nick Schager praises the show’s creator, R. Scott Gemmill, for not trying to overdo things after a strong first season made The Pitt a standout on HBO Max. Schager highlights Noah Wyle’s excellent performance and notes that the show feels more assured this season. He believes it successfully avoids the typical ‘second season slump’ and instead expands on its strengths, making it both the most intense and most compassionate medical drama currently on television.

Robby is the kind of doctor everyone hopes to have – compassionate and skilled. What makes Wyle’s portrayal, and Gemmill’s writing, so effective is that Robby isn’t presented as perfect. He has a demanding side and isn’t afraid to show it, making him a realistic and complex character. This, in turn, makes his courage and kindness when facing personal and professional challenges even more impactful.

HBO Max offers a wide range of movies, shows, documentaries, and critically acclaimed series like The Pitt, with plans starting at just $10.99 per month (Basic With Ads). See the deal and start streaming today!

According to Angie Han of The Hollywood Reporter, Season 2 of The Pitt is just as exciting and intense as the first, but surprisingly, it also feels familiar and reassuring. She compares returning to the show to reconnecting with an old friend – a feeling you don’t typically associate with hospital dramas. As Han puts it:

The hospital emergency room is predictably busy, but the show’s editing continues to be smooth and artfully done. The characters feel realistically flawed, navigating both work challenges – including their own hidden prejudices – and complicated personal lives. The actors deliver consistently strong performances, and the show maintains a perfect balance of drama, emotion, and surprising moments of levity.

According to Chris Evangelista of SlashFilm, The Pitt consistently delivers high-quality television by focusing on relatable characters and skilled acting. He awarded the first nine episodes a 9 out of 10, praising the HBO Max medical drama as one of the best shows currently available.

Season 2 of The Pitt continues the story of the dedicated emergency room staff at Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center, building on the success of the first season. While it doesn’t simply repeat old storylines, the creators wisely maintain the elements that made Season 1 so popular. If you enjoyed the first season, you’ll likely enjoy this one too.

IndieWire’s Ben Travers gave the season a B grade, highlighting the compelling new relationship between Dr. Robby and Dr. Baran Al-Hashim (Sepideh Moafi). Dr. Al-Hashim will be taking over for Noah Wyle’s character while he’s on leave, and she embodies the changes coming to the ER as he works his final shift.

The ticking clocks emphasizing the limited time frame really heighten the tension in The Pitt. Like the first season, this medical drama from R. Scott Gemmill avoids overly dramatic personal stories, puzzling illnesses, or romantic side plots. Instead, the show’s sense of urgency comes from the constant pressure of the job itself, shown through the never-ending stream of patients arriving at The Pitt.

The second season of The Pitt appears to be delivering more of what fans loved about the show last year. You can watch the new trailer below.

Read More

2026-01-07 17:09