Movies

Clueless Proved Amy Heckerling Was Brilliant. But It’s Not Her Only Stroke of Genius

BBG News

How would one assess the value of a filmmaker’s work? Is it by focusing on the financial success at the box office, or the trophies amassed on a shelf from various awards? Which method is more indicative of success: A series of commercially successful films or a movie that continues to resonate in popular culture for decades and beyond?

Or how about this: Can you measure a career in terms of generosity of spirit?

30 years ago on August 19th, Amy Heckerling‘s film Clueless was released, and even if she hadn’t made any other movies, this clever update of Jane Austen’s Emma would have been a significant achievement. Alicia Silverstone portrays Cher, a high school student in Beverly Hills who flaunts an extravagant and mismatched wardrobe, skillfully maneuvering her way to higher grades without actually doing the work. At first glance, she appears superficial and spoiled, but beneath that facade lies compassion and honesty. Her initial attempts at matchmaking are self-serving, but eventually, she discovers joy in connecting people. She’s too practical to seek love for herself, until she finds herself drawn to Paul Rudd’s Josh, the son of her father’s ex-wife, who she had previously viewed as an annoying sibling figure.

Clueless is not only uniquely inventive (Heckerling cleverly introduced the term As if!) but also flawlessly executed (its witty jokes flow smoothly, like a pearl necklace). It reveals a deep fondness for its characters, poking fun at them affectionately. When Cher calls one of the epic sword-and-sandal films “Sporadicus,” it only endears her to us more; she’s not belittling unfamiliar movies and experiences – she’s just so enthusiastic that she occasionally stumbles over the details.

This style, known as Amy Heckerling’s, is a hallmark of a director who consistently exhibits self-assurance instead of arrogance, which often left the industry perplexed, even after she created one of the most iconic teen movies of the ’80s, if not the best ever made in 1982 with “Fast Times at Ridgemont High.” Perhaps it takes an unconventional filmmaker to create comedies that stand the test of time, like “Clueless” and “Fast Times.” And perhaps the takeaway from Heckerling’s diverse career isn’t that we need more people who understand the rules—it’s that we need more trailblazers who set their own path.

Today, we often publicly advocate for women filmmakers extensively, yet it sometimes seems like a theatrical display. However, in the past, women directors such as Amy Heckerling and her peers, including friend Joan Micklin Silver who self-financed her initial movie, Hester Street (1975), were attempting to create films when female directors were still viewed with suspicion, considered unworthy of handling large studio budgets. At 28 years old, the Bronx-born Heckerling, a graduate of New York University with a master’s in film from the American Film Institute, made her directorial debut with Fast Times, an adaptation of Cameron Crowe’s book about teenage life in a Southern California high school. Unlike other teen movies at the time, Fast Times stood out, especially for its frank portrayal of teen pregnancy and abortion. Universal, the studio behind the film, initially hesitated when early test audiences reacted negatively to the abortion subplot. Nevertheless, the executives eventually allowed it, and Fast Times was successful enough at the box office that Heckerling went on to direct two more films: 1984’s comedic parody Johnny Dangerously, which failed financially, and 1985’s National Lampoon’s European Vacation, which was profitable.

However, Nancy Meyers’ most successful work was the 1989 comedy “Look Who’s Talking“, where Kirstie Alley plays a single mother whose child, initially an infant and later a toddler, speaks like a sailor on a break, but only the audience hears his wisecracks. (Bruce Willis lends his voice for the child.) Despite appearing overly exaggerated at first glance, this film is both entertaining and subtly insightful. It’s a cleverly empathetic movie that humorously explores a modern mom juggling everything on her own. Occasionally, tackling weighty topics can be best done with a light-hearted approach.

After that, Heckerling moved on to one of the movie’s sequels, namely 1990’s “Look Who’s Talking Too.” Five years later, “Clueless” was released, although it is beloved today, it was merely a moderate success initially. Considering her knack for mainstream comedy, which seems to have earned her recognition from industry leaders, it might be the reason she didn’t achieve the career she truly deserved after “Clueless.” Her last significant work was the pleasant horror comedy “Vamps” in 2012, featuring Alicia Silverstone and Krysten Ritter as vampire characters who aim to preserve their youthful vampiric existence by feeding on rat blood. Since then, she has been working in television, directing episodes for “Gossip Girl” and Amazon Prime’s “Red Oaks,” and transforming “Clueless” into a musical that is currently running in London’s West End.

Let’s revisit the concept of achieving “the career you deserve” – this often translates to generating profits for executives. However, what if you’ve created excellent or even outstanding films that didn’t find success? Amy Heckerling’s supposed failures are actually more heartfelt and superior in quality compared to many successful comedy directors’ works. In the 2000 film “Loser“, Jason Biggs portrays Paul, a kind but out-of-place Midwestern boy who secures a scholarship at NYU, only to encounter the harsh, snobbish behavior of his wealthy peers. His love interest, Mena Suvari’s sharp and insightful Dora, is in a relationship with one of her professors (Greg Kinnear portrays him as weaselly). “Loser” is relentlessly critical of human cruelty and boorishness; as is typical for Heckerling, she shows her compassion towards the characters who truly deserve it.

In 2007’s “I Could Never Be Your Woman,” a movie that unfortunately never made it to U.S. cinemas due to distribution rights issues, Michelle Pfeiffer portrays Rosie, a TV show writer and producer focusing on privileged teenagers. Amy Heckerling, the director, modeled this film on her own experience adapting “Clueless” into a television series in the late 1990s. At mid-40s, divorced, and with an 11-year-old daughter (Saoirse Ronan’s initial film role), Rosie has been single for quite some time. The arrival of actor Paul Rudd, who plays Adam, a late-20-something, on her show stirs up reluctant feelings in her. She questions whether she’s too old and if he’s too young. While many men might quickly dismiss such concerns, they significantly affect Rosie. Pfeiffer skillfully conveys Rosie’s self-doubt with infectious enthusiasm. Despite not eliciting sympathy, you can’t help but wish the best for her character.

Despite Paramount initially acquiring the script for I Could Never Be Your Woman, the studio ultimately decided against producing the film. As Amy Heckerling explained to Entertainment Weekly in 2008, there were reservations about making a movie with an older female lead—a demographic not always favored by all audiences. Instead, she partnered with an independent producer, which initiated the movie’s distribution challenges. Nowadays, it can be streamed if one looks for it, but unfortunately, many people remain unaware of its existence.

In an unexpected twist, a movie filled with wit and charm went unnoticed amidst the lack of intelligent romantic comedies for adults back in the early 2000s. This film, which should have been celebrated, was overlooked by many. Now, as big-studio releases have become rare, it seems like a precious artifact from a bygone era. If this is the legacy that a talented filmmaker like Heckerling has left behind, perhaps it’s just a sign that she made the right decisions along the way. Those who view these choices as mistakes are actually the ones missing out.

Read More

2025-07-18 21:06

Previous post ‘Basic Instinct’ Is Getting a Modern Reboot
Next post Pokémon Unite announces new Ranked Season 29 and Battle Pass Season 33