‘Big Mistakes’: A New Eight-Episode Netflix Crime Thriller Is Perfect Binge

by

It’s always impressive when someone creates and stars in their own show – think Tina Fey with 30 Rock, Donald Glover with Atlanta, and Phoebe Waller-Bridge with Fleabag. Now, another talented actor is joining that group. Dan Levy, known for Schitt’s Creek, is both the creator and lead actor in Big Mistakes, a new comedy crime thriller available on Netflix.

Dan Levy is a proven talent in front of and behind the camera, with a rare Emmy win in writing, directing, and acting. He’s also experienced in show management, having co-created the hit series Schitt’s Creek with his brother, Eugene Levy, and the cooking show The Big Brunch. Now, everyone’s wondering what his latest project is and what sets it apart.

Two Siblings Struggle Get Trapped in the Jaws of Blackmail in ‘Big Mistakes’

In the series Big Mistakes, Nicky Levy plays a pastor who is secretly gay. He’s determined to keep this hidden from his church community, fearing it would destroy his career. His sister, Morgan Ortega, is an elementary school teacher with a habit of making impulsive, self-sabotaging decisions. The story takes a turn when their mother, Linda Metcalf – a controlling shop owner and mayoral candidate – insists they fulfill their grandmother’s final wish: to buy her a necklace.

Morgan impulsively steals a diamond necklace, unknowingly connecting himself and his sibling, Nicky, to a dangerous criminal organization. Soon, the syndicate blackmails them into performing a string of risky jobs. Neither of them are criminals by nature, and their clumsiness consistently turns these tasks into chaotic and comical disasters.

Alongside the main characters in ‘Big Mistake’ are Natalie (Abby Quinn) and Nicky’s younger sibling, who are assisting their mother with her campaign for mayor. The cast also includes Elizabeth Perkins as Annette, a practical and successful real estate businesswoman, Max (Jack Innanen), Morgan’s somewhat childish boyfriend, and Tareq (Jacob Gutierrez), Nicky’s secret boyfriend. Tareq, a local handyman, becomes increasingly upset about having to keep their relationship a secret.

The show, which first launched on April 9, 2026, has become a worldwide success, reaching number 7 on FlixPatrol. TelevisionStats reports that the eight-part series is currently Netflix’s most popular show, and is also number one in both the crime and comedy genres. It’s closely followed on Netflix by Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen, Peaky Blinders, and One Piece.

Will ‘Big Mistakes’ Hit the Heights of ‘Schitt’s Creek’?

Big Mistakes has quickly become a hit in 2026, earning high praise from both audiences and critics. With an 80% rating from critics and a 73% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, it’s clear most viewers agree it’s a quality show. Many critics highlight the show’s sharp, clever dialogue and consider it one of the best LGBTQ+ series ever made. They also commend the creator, Levy, for understanding what his audience wants and for his strong on-screen chemistry with his co-star. While a few critics found parts of the show to be slow-paced, this is a common minority opinion.

Because of its strong initial success, Big Mistakes is expected to get a second season. It will probably be compared often to Dan Levy’s popular show, Schitt’s Creek. It’s uncertain whether it will be as successful, considering Schitt’s Creek received 19 Emmy nominations and continues to have a dedicated fanbase. That show also won many awards, including two Screen Actors Guild Awards and 18 Canadian Screen Awards.

Netflix has found a winning formula with shows that combine crime and religious themes. Narco Saints, a compelling gangster drama about a drug lord who also pretends to be a preacher, is a standout. Messiah, which centers on a mysterious figure believed by his followers to be the second coming of Jesus, is also excellent. Now, all attention is on Big Mistakes. While it remains to be seen if it will reach the same heights as the creator’s previous work, fans will likely continue to enjoy his signature style – similar to Taylor Sheridan. The creator is openly gay and consistently uses his platform to highlight issues facing the LGBTQ+ community.

Read More

2026-04-17 22:18