American Idol Just Made Some Major Cuts, And I’m Not Surprised To Hear Carrie Underwood Had A Tougher Time With It

by

In the year 2025, catch the live broadcast of American Idol on Sundays as we initiate the final round of its 23rd season. This spectacular event will feature the Top 14 performers, who’ll be saluting the inductees of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. The journey to select these talented few from the initial 144 contestants wasn’t an effortless one, and it seems that Carrie Underwood, taking over for Katy Perry, may have faced more challenges than her fellow judges when it came to eliminating contestants.

In the episode aired on April 21st, a notable error by Ryan Seacrest could have potentially upset Carrie Underwood. The number of contestants was reduced from 20 to 14, with fan votes deciding the first 10. The remaining four were chosen by Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan, which unfortunately meant ending the competition for six artists simultaneously. This proved to be a difficult decision for the Season 4 champion, Underwood, as she shared with USA TODAY.

Initially, my thoughts echoed: ‘Six? I find that beyond reach!’ However, there were slight adjustments needed, but overall, I believe we’re content with the outcome, aside from the fact that six individuals had to leave, which was quite substantial.

20 years later, returning as a judge on American Idol stirred up a wave of nostalgia for Carrie Underwood. It’s likely she was reminiscing about the emotions she felt knowing her destiny rested with those seated across the table. Given this is her first major elimination, it’s not surprising that she found it challenging, especially on live television.

Although she seemed to minimize the turmoil by describing them as “largely in agreement” and content with the singers selected for advancement, Lionel Richie depicted a somewhat chaotic scene regarding the choice that needed to be made during a single commercial break. In his own words, he stated:

Underwood urged Carrie, saying, “Hurry up, Carrie! Give us your answer.” He expressed his desire for none to depart, as there was still a minute left. As it was her first time facing the judges, Carrie was seated on their side of the table, and they needed her response.

Luke Bryan admitted that swift choices needed to be (and were) made. He stated that there were two contestants everyone concurred should progress, however, selecting the other two from the eight remaining talented individuals turned out to be quite challenging.

In summary, after reviewing their collective performances up until that point in the show, Josh King, Ché Chesterman, Desmond Roberts, and Amanda Barise received approval from the judges. Among those not so fortunate were Baylee Littrell (son of Backstreet Boy Brian Littrell) and Zaylie Windsor, who Carrie Underwood had likened to Taylor Swift during her audition.

It’s clear that the challenges ahead won’t become any less difficult, but we’ll have to watch how Carrie Underwood manages it all. The finals commence at 8 p.m. Eastern Time on April 27, and they’ll pick up again on Monday, April 28. You can catch them live on ABC, or stream them the following day on Hulu.

Read More

2025-04-28 00:07