Charlie Frederick, a contestant on Love Island: All Stars, is facing criticism for allegedly displaying aggressive, manipulative, and controlling actions after his recent departure from the ITV show.
Natalie Clowes, a 31-year-old personal assistant from Hertfordshire, has confided in friends that her four-year relationship, which lasted from 2021 to 2025, was a very difficult period in her life.
Let me tell you, from what I’m hearing, Charlie – you might remember him from Love Island, both the original series and the recent All Stars – apparently struggled with jealousy in a past relationship. It got to the point where, back in 2021, sources say he actually confronted a random person at Raffles nightclub, fueled by those feelings. It just goes to show, even being on TV doesn’t necessarily equip you to handle relationship challenges!
According to a source close to Natalie, 31, Charlie reportedly threw a KFC meal – including a bucket of chicken – at her during a heated argument, completely covering her in food.
As a lifestyle expert, I’ve heard stories about difficult relationships, and this one is particularly concerning. Apparently, Charlie – you might recognize him from Made In Chelsea – would reportedly make fun of Natalie when she was upset. Witnesses say he’d use a condescending ‘baby voice’ and sarcastically ask, ‘Shall I get out the violin?’ while she was crying, following what others described as frightening and aggressive behavior on his part. It’s a really upsetting dynamic, and highlights how damaging belittling can be.
Charlie was the first contestant on the show to be eliminated by his partner. After the public voted him into the bottom three, former Love Island winner Millie Court had the final say and chose to send him home on Thursday night.
A source close to Natalie revealed: ‘In the beginning it was quite intense from the word go.
He showered her with affection and wanted to be with her constantly, and Natalie initially found it thrilling. However, warning signs quickly emerged, particularly when he was drinking.
I’ve seen it happen so many times – a couple who appear completely idyllic, genuinely loving and connected. But sometimes, there’s a hidden struggle. With Charlie, it was alcohol. He was one person when sober – warm, engaging, everything you’d want in a partner – but drinking brought out a completely different side. It was like night and day, a real Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde situation. It completely fractured their dynamic, and it was heartbreaking to watch.
They were living in a flat in Fulham and enjoyed going out together on weekends. However, it was during these outings that he started to become much more aggressive.
He had a strong reaction at Raffles when someone bumped into Natalie, and it was a bit excessive.
My friend explained that he was a master of controlling things. He’d always justify his actions by saying it was because he loved Natalie and was just trying to protect her, and he was skilled at presenting it that way.
Things deteriorated throughout the relationship. Eventually, he’d dismiss his behavior while intoxicated, saying it wasn’t his responsibility to manage it.
Charlie was back on Love Island, hosted by Maya Jama, as part of the first All Stars cast. Millions have been tuning in to watch him in the South African villa this week.
A source close to Natalie said Charlie’s behaviour worsened even when he wasn’t drinking.
Natalie’s relationship with Charlie began to fall apart after he reportedly threw a bucket of KFC at her – an event her parents actually saw happen.
Once, while driving to Natalie’s parents’ house, they stopped at KFC to pick up dinner for everyone.
I couldn’t believe what I was witnessing. Charlie just completely lost it in the car, yelling at Natalie for seemingly no reason at all. Then, when they stopped, he actually threw a bucket of KFC at her! It hit her right in the head, and everything – the chicken, the fries, everything – went flying, covering her and making a mess all over the floor. It was awful to see.
‘Her parents heard everything, and that’s when they couldn’t understand why she was still with him.
He changed moods incredibly fast – he’d be perfectly pleasant one moment, and then suddenly become completely different, leaving Natalie to deal with the fallout, often in a very direct way.
According to a source, Charlie will first apologize and appear sorry for what he did, but then he’ll make fun of and put Natalie down.
The unhealthy dynamic of the relationship deeply affected Natalie, leaving her feeling like a completely different person, according to a source. She later began therapy to heal and recover.
It was heartbreaking to witness how he manipulated Natalie. He was a master of making her doubt her own reality. He’d fly into rages, yelling and getting right in her face, and it was terrifying. I remember Natalie pleading with him, saying, “Charlie, you’re scaring me,” and his response was just… cruel. He’d mock her, using this ridiculous, condescending baby voice as if she was the one overreacting. It was a tactic to dismiss her feelings and make her feel crazy, and it was awful to see.
According to a source, she ended the relationship because he struggled with controlling his anger. It became too much for her to handle, and she started to lose herself.
Natalie’s anxiety prevented them from having a normal social life, and his responses to situations would only make things worse.
According to a source, Natalie seemed self-assured, but only after ending the relationship did she understand how damaging it had been. She’s spent the last year focusing on her own well-being and recovery, something she really needed after being with Charlie.
Someone close to Natalie has expressed disappointment about Charlie being chosen for Love Island: All Stars. They feel the show will simply give him more chances to become famous and grow his social media presence.
The source also mentioned they were somewhat relieved that both the Islanders and the audience quickly realized who Charlie really was, and voted him the least popular male contestant as soon as they could.
Millie sent Charlie home on Thursday’s episode of the show, explaining she’d seen warning signs in their relationship.
Honestly, it’s been so frustrating watching Charlie. He was clearly building a connection with Millie before he went and kissed Jess! And then, after all that, he still chose Millie in the last recoupling, even though it was obvious he was developing feelings for Jess. It just doesn’t add up, and it’s really confusing to watch as a fan.
My friend wasn’t shocked to see Charlie on Love Island: All Stars, because he enjoys being on television and getting attention.
She would have been hurt if he’d been shown in a good light, because she knows his true character. However, she’s relieved others are finally seeing who he really is. The women involved all realized his problematic behavior.
People watching the show have commented on how frightening his eyes appeared, and she previously shared that she felt the same way.
The source believes ITV needs to be more careful when selecting male contestants for the show. They feel Charlie, in particular, shouldn’t have been allowed on the program.
His behavior on the show was again disrespectful to women, and it’s clear he hasn’t made any progress in the last year. Natalie had hoped he’d gotten help, but his appearance on the show suggests otherwise. He really needs to consider getting therapy.
‘She thought he might try to appear like a nice guy, but he’s clearly incapable of that.’
The Daily Mail has approached ITV and Charlie’s spokesperson for comment.
Read More
- VCT Pacific 2026 talks finals venues, roadshows, and local talent
- Will Victoria Beckham get the last laugh after all? Posh Spice’s solo track shoots up the charts as social media campaign to get her to number one in ‘plot twist of the year’ gains momentum amid Brooklyn fallout
- Vanessa Williams hid her sexual abuse ordeal for decades because she knew her dad ‘could not have handled it’ and only revealed she’d been molested at 10 years old after he’d died
- Dec Donnelly admits he only lasted a week of dry January as his ‘feral’ children drove him to a glass of wine – as Ant McPartlin shares how his New Year’s resolution is inspired by young son Wilder
- SEGA Football Club Champions 2026 is now live, bringing management action to Android and iOS
- The five movies competing for an Oscar that has never been won before
- EUR ILS PREDICTION
- Binance’s Bold Gambit: SENT Soars as Crypto Meets AI Farce
- Invincible Season 4’s 1st Look Reveals Villains With Thragg & 2 More
- CS2 Premier Season 4 is here! Anubis and SMG changes, new skins
2026-01-23 20:07