10 Dark Fantasy Series That Prove Game of Thrones Was Always Overrated

by

Despite all the dragons, backstabbing, and shocking deaths, Game of Thrones is often considered the peak of dark fantasy. However, much of its positive reputation comes from the earlier seasons, and a closer look reveals the series as a whole isn’t as profound or thematically rich as many believe. Without the high production value, the story’s moral complexity and overall ambition seem less impressive.

I’ve always loved fantasy, and even before everyone was talking about Westeros, there were authors writing incredibly powerful, gritty stories. They weren’t afraid to really delve into the darker sides of things – war, the abuse of power, the lasting effects of trauma, and how easily people can become corrupted. If you’re like me and you’re looking for something beyond the usual castles and frozen creatures, these ten epic dark fantasy series prove that Game of Thrones definitely wasn’t the end of the line for amazing fantasy. They’re just so much more imaginative and impactful!

The Chronicles of the Black Company by Glen Cook

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Glen Cook’s The Black Company was a groundbreaking fantasy series, establishing a gritty and realistic style long before it became popular. The story is told from the perspective of a world-weary group of mercenaries, and it deliberately avoids traditional heroic tropes and simple notions of good and evil. Characters are flawed, the focus is on simply staying alive, and war is portrayed as a brutal, draining, and ultimately damaging experience.

Unlike shows like Game of Thrones that often make power struggles seem exciting, R. Scott Bakker’s work portrays evil as tedious and draining. His villains – sorcerer-kings and dark lords – aren’t impressive or glamorous; they’re frightening bosses. The realistic, military-style setting makes the magic feel even more unsettling and dangerous, demonstrating that a creepy atmosphere and careful storytelling can be much more effective than relying on shocking twists.

Powder Mage Trilogy by Brian McClellan

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Brian McClellan’s Powder Mage trilogy is a fast-paced fantasy series that combines the excitement of flintlock firearms with intense political drama. The story kicks off with the fall of gods and quickly descends into chaotic revolutions, all powered by a unique magic system linked to gunpowder. This creates a world where advancement and conflict are constantly intertwined, and even the best intentions can be corrupted.

While Game of Thrones centers on the struggles for power between families, Powder Mage explores the aftermath of a revolution. Author Brian McClellan delves into the unforeseen results of upheaval, the hardships faced by ordinary people, and the difficult choices characters make. The series feels more relevant and fast-paced than many traditional fantasy stories, trading a static, medieval world for one of rapid change and forcing its characters to grapple with the repercussions of altering the past.

The Dark Tower Series by Stephen King

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

As a huge movie and book fan, I’ve always found Stephen King’s The Dark Tower series to be something special – it’s really hard to pin down to just one genre. It throws together dark fantasy, horror, westerns, and even science fiction into this massive, interconnected story. What really grabs me is Roland Deschain’s journey; it’s a really bleak and personal obsession, fueled by what he’s lost and a sense of fate, rather than any grand political scheme. And the world itself? It feels genuinely fractured, like pieces of different realities are bleeding into each other. It’s a really unique and compelling world to get lost in.

While Game of Thrones feels realistic despite its fantasy elements, The Dark Tower fully leans into the bizarre and philosophical. Stephen King focuses on themes like obsession, destiny, and repeating patterns of ruin, emphasizing emotional impact over political strategy. This creates a much more unusual and ambitious story, prioritizing a sense of deep unease over conflicts between families.

The Blacktongue Thief by Christopher Buehlman

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Christopher Buehlman’s The Blacktongue Thief is a darkly funny adventure about a wisecracking thief trying to survive in a world torn apart by war. While the story is full of jokes, it’s set in a deeply damaged land still recovering from invasion, cultural upheaval, and magical disasters. Every country is marked by these events, and even victories feel hollow.

The novel’s unique voice is what truly makes it stand out. Unlike the often serious tone of Game of Thrones, Buehlman uses humor to highlight the harshness of the violence, making it even more impactful. The humor doesn’t lessen the brutality; it actually emphasizes it. This combination of lightheartedness and cruelty results in a more realistic and emotionally engaging dark fantasy story.

Alchemised by SenLinYu

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Alchemised is a haunting and personal dark fantasy novel exploring themes of obsession, the loss of morality, and what people will do to survive. SenLinYu tells a story where true power comes from within, fueled by past trauma and personal sacrifice, rather than through traditional means like armies or royal titles. Magic in this world is a dangerous force used for control, change, and ultimately, can lead to one’s own downfall.

While Game of Thrones focused on a vast, sprawling world, Alchemised takes a more intimate approach. The story delves into how people justify terrible actions when faced with impossible situations. Its raw emotional power and focus on the characters’ minds feel more truthful than complex political maneuvering, demonstrating that a dark fantasy story doesn’t need to be epic in scope to be deeply impactful.

Night Angel Trilogy by Brent Weeks

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Brent Weeks’ Night Angel trilogy is a gritty fantasy series set in a city riddled with corruption. It follows the stories of people struggling to survive and gain power, but they soon learn that achieving influence comes at a terrible cost. The books are known for their brutal and often senseless violence.

While Game of Thrones often celebrates those who strive for power, Night Angel takes a much more cautious approach. The story shows that every achievement comes at a significant cost, and characters constantly struggle with difficult moral choices. Author Weeks focuses on the realistic consequences of actions, making the story’s darkness feel genuine and not simply used for shock value.

The Broken Empire Trilogy by Mark Lawrence

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Mark Lawrence’s Broken Empire trilogy features Jorg Ancrath, a truly notorious fantasy character. Jorg isn’t designed to be sympathetic; he’s violent, clever, and completely ruthless. The world he inhabits is just as harsh, combining elements of a medieval setting with the ruins of a fallen civilization.

As much as I loved Game of Thrones, The Broken Empire takes things to a whole other level. Where Game of Thrones kind of dances around difficult questions, this series dives headfirst into really bleak territory. Lawrence doesn’t shy away from making you think – and feel uncomfortable – about things like whether empathy is even possible, if we truly have control over our choices, and if anyone can actually be redeemed. It’s a tough read, but it proves dark fantasy can be genuinely thought-provoking, not just about shocking moments or cool visuals.

The First Law Trilogy by Joe Abercrombie

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Joe Abercrombie’s First Law trilogy is often considered the best example of modern grimdark fantasy, and it’s easy to see why. The characters are realistically flawed, frequently understand their own shortcomings, and don’t often find success even when they try to improve. The books show that violence doesn’t solve problems, political systems stay stuck, and history tends to repeat its mistakes in a harsh and unforgiving way.

Unlike Game of Thrones, Joe Abercrombie’s stories feel more realistic in how they portray people. His characters don’t experience satisfying victories or clear growth – instead, they face repeated setbacks and have to make difficult compromises. This, combined with his dark humor and well-developed characters, makes the grimness feel meaningful, highlighting the pointlessness often hidden within typical fantasy stories.

The Poppy War Trilogy by R.F. Kuang

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

I was completely blown away by R.F. Kuang’s Poppy War trilogy. What really struck me was how much it’s based on real events, especially the Sino-Japanese wars – it makes the fantasy feel so much more impactful because it’s rooted in actual historical horrors. It starts off seeming like a typical story about school and learning, but quickly descends into really dark territory with genocide, addiction, and characters facing impossible moral choices. It’s a tough read, but it really drives home the idea that power and trauma are completely intertwined.

While Game of Thrones presented violence as something happening far away, The Poppy War shows it up close and personal. R.F. Kuang doesn’t shy away from the harsh realities of war and colonialism, forcing readers to grapple with difficult truths. This makes the story’s darkness feel impactful and genuine, rather than just for shock value.

Malazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson

Custom Image by Hannah Diffey

Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen is a sprawling and often brutal series that deeply examines the themes of war, history, and human suffering. The story features powerful gods who frequently intervene, empires that shift and change without being fully shown, and soldiers who struggle with the consequences of decisions made by those in power. This immense scope is intentional, creating a truly overwhelming experience for the reader.

While Game of Thrones makes its political storylines easier to follow for dramatic effect, Malazan dives into intricate details. Erikson believes readers can understand the story through emotional connection instead of lengthy explanations. This constant emphasis on kindness even during difficult times gives the series a thoughtful quality, making the world of Game of Thrones seem less profound in comparison.

Read More

2026-02-08 23:11