Billy Bob Thornton Stole the Show in Yellowstone’s 1883

by

Billy Bob Thornton has consistently delivered strong performances throughout his career, leading many to consider him an underappreciated actor. While he’s been a reliable presence on screen for decades, he’s only recently started receiving wider recognition, largely thanks to his roles in Taylor Sheridan’s shows, including Landman.

Viewers have recently enjoyed seeing Michael Thornton in Landman, but he actually started working with Taylor Sheridan on another project beforehand. He previously teamed up with Sam Elliott, his co-star from Tombstone, in the Western drama 1883. However, five years later, many are beginning to forget Thornton’s part in that Yellowstone prequel, likely because his role wasn’t very extensive.

1883 Is Still Arguably the Best Taylor Sheridan Series

For the past eight years, Taylor Sheridan has created compelling television shows, particularly in the Western, crime, and action genres, known for their cinematic quality. These shows have expanded into a broader universe, and while they aren’t always directly connected, they all share Sheridan’s distinctive style, focusing on strong themes and memorable characters. Though fans debate his best work, Yellowstone is widely considered his most impactful achievement.

The ending of Yellowstone left some viewers wanting more, which is likely why the story is continuing with several spin-off shows. Since Landman came out, many people believe the newer series is even better than Yellowstone. However, some fans – particularly those who enjoy traditional Westerns – still prefer the spin-offs because they offer the kind of Western storytelling that’s become rare to find.

The show 1923 enjoyed greater success partly because it spanned two seasons and portrayed a rarely seen time in the American West, blending the modern feel of the 1920s with the traditional Western way of life. This similarity to Yellowstone also contributed to its appeal. However, 1883 is considered even stronger, showcasing Taylor Sheridan’s unique vision and heartfelt connection to the Western genre. The captivating historical drama continues to be praised by fans as one of the best Westerns created in recent years.

Billy Bob Thornton Stole the Show for Five Straight Minutes In 1883

Billy Bob Thornton is currently receiving a lot of praise thanks to the success of his show, Landman. But he’s always been well-suited for Westerns, going all the way back to his role in Tombstone. With his distinctive look and voice, he naturally fits the classic Western mold, and Taylor Sheridan clearly recognized that. When they began collaborating more, Sheridan specifically asked Thornton to appear in a key, though small, part in an episode of his popular series 1883.

The historical drama set in 2021 remains a standout Western, largely because it showcases the Dutton family’s crucial expansion westward. This mirrors the real history of America’s westward movement in the late 19th century. The show distinguishes itself by emphasizing the struggle to survive, though it still touches on themes of honor and ambition. A particularly memorable part of the series involves the character of Marshal Jim Courtright, played by Billy Bob Thornton.

Before heading west, James Dutton and his family need to take care of a few things back home. He’s asked to help the local marshal deal with a dangerous group of bandits, and is temporarily made a deputy to give his actions legal standing. The lawmen track the bandits to a saloon, where a standout performance by Thornton quickly grabs your attention. Courtright is particularly impressive, skillfully taking down several bandits and delivering a memorable line: “There’s only one killer in Fort Worth, and that’s me.”

Marshal Jim Courtright Was a Character Sheridan Needed Thornton to Play

Billy Bob Thornton’s brief appearance in 1883 is a standout Western moment in the series, and it needed a truly skilled actor to deliver it. Creator Taylor Sheridan initially considered using a less-known actor for the part of Courtright, but rereading the scene made him realize he needed someone special. He then approached Thornton, a seasoned actor with Western experience, who turned out to be the perfect fit. Thornton’s portrayal was so impactful that it was almost disappointing he wasn’t featured in more episodes.

As a huge fan of Westerns, the scene with Courtright in 1883 really set the stage for everything the show would become. It had this incredibly gritty, authentic feel – it reminded me of classic Westerns, but also felt like something completely new. Honestly, 1883 is one of the most realistic and brutal Westerns I’ve ever seen on TV, and Courtright was such a unique character, perfectly suited to the world Taylor Sheridan created. That scene still pops into my head whenever I think about the show, and I’m not alone – a lot of us are hoping Michael Thornton gets to reprise the role in a spin-off! He absolutely nailed it, and I truly can’t imagine anyone else playing Courtright; he completely exceeded my expectations.

Read More

2026-02-08 06:43