Mikey and Nicky Is an Underrated ’70s Crime Masterpiece

by

As a film lover, I’ve always been struck by how powerfully certain directors can tell stories within a genre. It’s a constant throughout cinema history, with the masters consistently delivering. But for me, the 1970s New Hollywood period felt special. Filmmakers seemed to push boundaries, creating dramas – and films across all genres, really – that were incredibly realistic, complex, and just… unforgettable. They really knew how to connect with audiences on a deeper level.

I’ve always been fascinated by Elaine May – she’s a truly underappreciated filmmaker from the 70s. What makes her even more remarkable is that she was one of the very few women directing films at the time, and she wasn’t just a director; she also acted in some incredible movies and wrote so many others! People often mention A New Leaf or The Heartbreak Kid when talking about her work, but for me, her most powerful film is Mikey and Nicky. It’s a brilliant crime drama, though it sadly got lost in the shadow of those bigger, more famous gangster films.

Mikey and Nicky Is One of the Most Heartbreaking Street Tragedies in Cinema History

What sets truly great films apart isn’t just entertainment value, and Elaine May’s Mikey and Nicky perfectly exemplifies this. It’s a powerfully realistic and intimate drama that avoids relying on flashy spectacle. However, the 1976 film is also genuinely enjoyable and delivers the kind of experience audiences appreciate.

While Mikey and Nicky uses familiar elements of its genre, it’s truly defined by the complex relationship between its two main characters. It’s much more than just a typical genre film.

Critics have analyzed the complexities of Mikey and Nicky, pointing to its exploration of masculinity, subtle suggestions of same-sex attraction, and underlying violence. Ultimately, though, the film is a powerfully written and acted tragedy that realistically depicts the world of crime and the connections between those who live within it.

While stories about everyday life and tough situations aren’t new, Elaine May’s film Mikey and Nicky captures this feeling exceptionally well. Released decades ago, the movie feels deeply personal, reflecting May’s own life experiences.

I found this film subtly brilliant in how it portrays a specific time and place. It doesn’t tell you where it’s set, but as someone who knows Elaine May’s background, it’s clearly a loving, and realistic, depiction of the Philadelphia she knew growing up. The whole East Coast vibe is just undeniable, and the characters feel incredibly authentic – like people you really might have encountered.

May was raised in Philadelphia, where she witnessed hardship and understood how difficult circumstances could lead people to commit crimes, either to survive or escape their problems. This pattern isn’t unique to Philly – similar situations exist in other East Coast cities like New York, Newark, and Boston, and really, in any large city.

As a young woman, Elaine May drew inspiration for her characters Mikey and Nicky from two men she knew, carefully recreating the complexities of their connection on screen. While the film includes dramatic elements, May infused it with deeply personal experiences, making it stand out from most crime films. Mikey and Nicky is fundamentally a story about a broken friendship and the consequences for men involved in organized crime.

This shift transforms the movie into a deeply tragic story, a realistic portrayal of street life reminiscent of Philadelphia’s tough neighborhoods. By focusing on the central relationship, Mikey and Nicky reveals itself to be a poignant exploration of a lifelong friendship tragically falling apart.

The result is a deeply tragic story, considered one of the most moving in its genre. This impact is largely due to the writing by , but the powerful performances of Peter Falk and John Cassavetes are equally crucial.

Mikey and Nicky Is an Anti-Godfather Crime Drama That Audiences Rarely See Anymore

Modern entertainment is increasingly defined by strict genres and a demand for large-scale, visually impressive experiences. This isn’t solely the fault of movie studios; audiences now expect films to feature major stars, massive budgets, and a constantly engaging plot that justifies a longer running time.

Most moviegoers aren’t interested in films like this, and studios haven’t noticed, leading to fewer and fewer of these unique, personal stories being made. Mikey and Nicky is one of those films, and it was released during a period when many different types of movies were popular with audiences.

In the 1970s, any director making a gangster or crime film had to contend with the massive influence of The Godfather. While smaller, more intimate genre films were still possible, they succeeded by focusing on realistic and complex stories. Movies like Taxi Driver and Serpico connected with audiences not through grand scale, but through their relatable and detailed portrayals of life.

While these films, often considered alternatives to the typical mafia genre, didn’t achieve massive blockbuster success, they’ve had a surprisingly enduring influence. Interestingly, they were financially successful at the time, something similar movies struggle with today. A big reason for this change is the rise of streaming, which has reduced the number of people going to movie theaters.

Mikey and Nicky is a unique and stylish drama that stands out, especially by today’s standards. The film explores how living with connections to the criminal world shapes relationships and leads to a particular, often bleak, way of thinking.

Nicky is a reckless and troubled man who constantly finds himself in financial and personal difficulties. His friend, Mikey, is consistently left to help him out when things fall apart.

What makes this story compelling is its unexpected twists and the strong bond between the friends. Nicky has flaws, but truly values Mikey, who often feels overlooked. This leads to hurt feelings and envy, ultimately damaging their friendship.

Honestly, I think Nicky’s really pushed things too far this time, and it’s going to end badly for him. He usually has Mikey to lean on, but their relationship is falling apart, which is just heartbreaking to watch. The whole story really centers around these two guys, and I think the acting, especially from Cassavetes and Falk, is phenomenal – they deserve so much more recognition for it.

The film’s heartbreaking story is impossible to look away from, even as the plot unfolds. Viewers will find themselves invested in both main characters throughout the entire movie. The director skillfully emphasizes this connection, which is a key reason why the ending is so powerful. This isn’t a flashy gangster film filled with action and laughs; it’s an intimate story about two people that will stay with you long after the credits roll.

Mikey and Nicky Is a Perfect Mean Streets Replacement

Viewers will likely compare Mikey and Nicky to films from 1973. Just as Martin Scorsese drew inspiration from his childhood in New York’s Little Italy, Elaine May’s work reflects her experiences with the tough neighborhoods of Philadelphia.

Mikey and Charlie (played by Harvey Keitel) share a similar trait: they’re both responsible individuals constantly having to protect Nicky. Nicky, however, is much more erratic and can’t be counted on as a friend. Both movies feel authentic, dealing with relatable issues and situations that are deeply rooted in the cultures they portray.

Interestingly, a connection exists between the two films because John Cassavetes appears in a role reminiscent of those in many others. Cassavetes guided Scorsese early in his career, encouraging him to create more films similar to Mean Streets after seeing it. It’s notable that Cassavetes later starred in a film with a similar feel just a few years later.

John Cassavetes directed several films with a similar style, notably The Killing of a Chinese Bookie. He’s also appeared in many classic movies, including a standout performance in what is now considered Elaine May’s greatest work.

5 Questions
Unraveling Toxic Bonds: Test Your Knowledge of Mikey and Nicky
Your Top Score
—
Attempts
—
0
0
Report Error

Found an error? Send it so it can be corrected.

Read More

2026-02-02 02:15