John Ford’s Classic 100% RT Western Is Still 1 of Henry Fonda’s Best Performances

by

John Ford is one of the most celebrated directors in Western film history, largely thanks to his collaborations with John Wayne. His career spanned over four decades, from the early days of silent movies to the mid-1960s, and produced iconic films like Stagecoach, The Searchers, and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. These movies were incredibly influential, defining how audiences viewed the American West with their memorable characters – brave heroes, dangerous villains, and captivating women – and stunning landscapes.

While Ford is known for Westerns starring John Wayne, Henry Fonda held a special place in the director’s heart. Fonda featured prominently in four of Ford’s grand Western films, the most celebrated of which is arguably 1946’s My Darling Clementine. This film cast Fonda as the legendary lawman Wyatt Earp and portrayed the events leading up to the famous gunfight at the OK Corral. Unusually for the genre, My Darling Clementine prioritized Earp’s love story with Clementine Carter over the violence, and this approach won over many viewers.

John Ford Abandoned Historical Accuracy in My Darling Clementine

Several elements came together to make My Darling Clementine so successful. Henry Fonda’s performance is particularly strong, bringing a relatable human side to a legendary figure. John Ford’s confident direction also helps, presenting the story in a classic and solid way. However, Ford wasn’t overly concerned with historical accuracy. While My Darling Clementine is considered one of the greatest Westerns, it’s also known for being loosely based on the real events at the OK Corral, despite Ford’s claim that he heard the story directly from those involved.

Throughout his career, Ford wasn’t overly concerned with sticking to the facts, both in his movies – which frequently bent historical accuracy – and in his personal life. So, when he told director Peter Bogdanovich in 1967 that he’d met Wild Bill Hickok, it was likely meant as a tall tale. Still, despite how unbelievable it sounds, the timing actually works. Earp died in 1929, by which time Ford was already making movies, and Earp was known to be in Hollywood at the time, trying to interest people in his life story. This means Ford’s claim, however improbable, could have been true.

I was just a prop assistant back then, and my job was to get John Ford a chair and coffee. He once told me the story of the gunfight at the O.K. Corral, and when we filmed My Darling Clementine, we recreated it exactly as he described it.

Even though director John Ford received a firsthand account of the gunfight, his version in the film My Darling Clementine contains several inaccuracies. For instance, the movie portrays Old Man Clanton as killing one of the Earp brothers and then dying at the O.K. Corral, but historians believe Clanton never even met the Earps. The film also gets details wrong about the Earp brothers themselves; it names the youngest brother James and shows him as the first to die, when in reality, he was the oldest and lived until 1926. Perhaps most significantly, the movie places the gunfight in 1882, while historical records confirm it happened in 1881. However, Ford wasn’t concerned with strict historical accuracy. His priority was creating an exciting and emotionally engaging film, even if it meant taking liberties with the truth.

Jane Russell’s Clementine Was a Composite Character

A highlight of My Darling Clementine is the developing romance between Wyatt Earp and Clementine Carter, who was previously involved with Earp’s rival, Doc Holliday. Clementine initially seeks out Doc, but quickly finds herself falling for Earp. Their connection slowly grows, and Henry Fonda brilliantly portrays Earp as surprisingly vulnerable and lovestruck, a departure from the usual stoic Western hero. He shows his affection through small gestures, like standing when she enters and daydreaming about her. Director John Ford emphasizes that meeting Clementine is the most important thing that happens to Earp, contributing to the film’s reputation as one of the most charming Westerns ever made.

Surprisingly, the character of Carter was largely a creation of Hollywood. In reality, Wyatt Earp lived with Josephine Marcus for 47 years, starting in 1881. Historians suggest Carter combines traits of Josephine and ‘Big Nose Kate,’ Doc Holliday’s common-law wife. Director John Ford named the character ‘Clementine’ because he was fond of the folk song ‘Oh My Darling, Clementine,’ which also inspired the film’s title. Despite being somewhat randomly conceived, Jane Russell powerfully portrayed Carter, creating a strong on-screen connection with Henry Fonda. Their romance continues to resonate with audiences even today, and remains a

Henry Fonda Helped Establish the Western Lawman Trope

Ultimately, My Darling Clementine shows how Hollywood can improve a story by changing historical facts. While altering history isn’t always ideal, it truly benefited this film. It allowed Henry Fonda to create a memorable Wyatt Earp, a tough lawman who was also surprisingly sensitive and compassionate – a new type of Western hero. This role wouldn’t have suited John Wayne, but it was perfect for Fonda, who was known for playing relatable, ordinary people in films like The Grapes of Wrath and 12 Angry Men. Fonda could easily portray Earp’s human side, especially in his touching scenes with Russell, while also convincingly handling the film’s action and violence, captivating audiences with both sides of the character.

Henry Fonda’s portrayal of Wyatt Earp is still considered one of the best, largely because it continues to stand out even compared to countless other film versions of the famous gunslinger. While the real Earp may not have been the perfect lawman legend the media created, Fonda’s performance in My Darling Clementine was so memorable that every actor who has played Earp since has been influenced by it, whether they realize it or not.

Henry Fonda’s portrayal of Wyatt Earp has clearly inspired many actors who’ve taken on the role, even in less successful films like Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp. Burt Lancaster and James Garner both drew from Fonda’s performance in their Earp depictions in Gunfight at the OK Corral and Hour of the Gun, respectively. In fact, Fonda’s impact can be seen in nearly every actor who plays an honest, principled lawman with a romantic side – all the way up to Timothy Olyphant’s Raylan Givens in Justified. That’s how significant his performance was.

Read More

2025-11-16 17:08