Revisiting the worst article about the most overrated bands ever

by

One fantastic aspect of music lies in its personal nature – what resonates deeply with you might not strike a chord with your closest companion. For instance, while country tunes could stir emotions within you, they may evoke indifference or even dislike in your friend. This discrepancy can stem from an individual bond that each of you forms with the lyrics and harmonies specific to the genre, which your acquaintance might not share.

When compiling a list of top or bottom performances in music history, it’s crucial to establish some boundaries. Expressing your personal views is acceptable, but remember to provide strong justification for your perspective. Readers are entitled to their own opinions and may not always agree with yours.

It strikes me that over the years, I’ve penned articles which some folks dislike (including Phishheads, Sammy Hagar fans, and others). However, it’s important to remember that everyone has the freedom to have their own opinions. There might be one article from a decade back that most of us would agree was less than stellar, or even downright poor quality.

A list of the 10 most overrated rock performers goes badly awry

Back in 2016, I penned down an article for the CU Independent, listing what I perceived as the ten most overrated rock artists of all time. Now, I’m not here to start a fight or silence anyone’s love for these musicians, but rather to spark a conversation and share my perspective. However, some of the reasons I presented may have been questionable.

The fact that this topic is still being discussed after almost a decade might be due to the fact that the original article continues to circulate online, perhaps because of how absurd it appears.

In Exhibit A of Witt’s error, you find point number 9 where he places the Eagles. Sure, one might debate their level of talent, but what truly counts is the logic behind the argument. Witt stated that “the Eagles are a band with little to no musical talent.” However, it’s important to note that the Eagles didn’t actually write their most well-known song, ‘Take It Easy.’ This fact, in itself, doesn’t necessarily prove a lack of talent within the band.

It’s important to note that Witt strongly dislikes a group known for covering various songs. Interestingly, contrary to popular belief, the Eagles’ most iconic tune isn’t “Take It Easy” but “Hotel California,” and there’s quite a difference between the two. Facts are crucial in understanding correctly.

AC/DC ranks fifth, as Witt put it, “Their music isn’t melodious or refined, but rather consists mainly of Brian Johnson’s gravelly singing over a chaotic heavy metal rhythm. In the ’80s, they were an unstoppable force on the charts…

Initially, it’s highly unlikely that Angus and Malcolm Young began their musical journey with the intention of creating beautiful rock songs. In fact, the essence of their band lies in exactly the opposite idea. Furthermore, it appears Witt may have overlooked some crucial details, such as the band’s origin in the 1970s and its massive success during Bon Scott’s tenure as the lead vocalist.

Brace yourselves because Will Witt gets worse.

In simpler terms, the author places Jimi Hendrix at number 2 but expresses a perspective that despite his greatness, not being able to write his own lyrics well affects their view of him. They question whether “All Along the Watchtower,” a popular song often considered original to Hendrix, was truly representative of his talent since it’s actually a Bob Dylan cover. The author also wonders if Hendrix might have faded from fame had he lived longer.

Here’s another way of expressing the given text: Witt dislikes cover versions, and he appears to have gotten Hendrix’s best-known song, “Purple Haze,” wrong. It was Hendrix’s skill as a lyricist that was commendable, but it was his exceptional guitar work that truly defined him and contributed to his enduring success – something Witt seems to have overlooked.

Witt ended his list by ranking Nirvana No. 1 in the most confusing way.

The author clearly has a strong dislike for Dave Grohl, while expressing that about the band he states, “The most frustrating aspect is that Dave Grohl, the unremarkable and interchangeable drummer who contributed no compositions or melodies, enjoys all the perks. Even Grant Hart of Husker Du nicknames him ‘Dave Goul’, profiting off someone else’s demise. Kurt Cobain was the essence of Nirvana, and in no way overrated; however, without him, Nirvana becomes the most overrated band ever produced.

Just like Kurt Cobain was essential to the success of Nirvana, if Nirvana existed without him, they might have been overrated as a band.

Will Witt’s attempt at writing should serve as a reminder for us all: If you’re going to criticize, make sure your information is accurate. Otherwise, it becomes a waste of time and effort.

Read More

2025-08-02 15:00