Movies

10 Yellowstone Moments That Make NO SENSE

BBG News

Although it’s widely admired, the series occasionally requires viewers to overlook certain narrative techniques, storylines, and factual accuracy. The show, along with its offshoots, 1883 and 1923 , are undeniably engaging. Nevertheless, all three of Taylor Sheridan’s TV productions have a tendency to be quite theatrical, exaggerated, and permissive when it comes to historical facts and legal matters.

It’s understandable that some viewers might find it confusing when a show features intense monologues, violence, and betrayal, especially since creator Taylor Sheridan emphasizes realism in these series. However, fans are left feeling let down because although the settings, animals, and costumes are incredibly detailed, certain elements of the Yellowstone universe seem illogical or inconsistent.

The Dutton family typically disposes of their bodies in a place they call “The Train Station”

The Train Station is generally secluded, as noted by Donald Whitfield in 1923, which might have allowed for illegal activities such as dumping the Yellowstone ranch’s illicit findings. However, it’s important to note that such a scenario seems implausible in current times (2018) due to stricter laws and regulations against crimes.

In even the most secluded, sparsely populated regions – like the infamous Zone of Death in Idaho – any crime could be tracked back to another state if there was evidence linking the victims to a crime committed in Montana. The investigation would then take place in Montana. If a county doesn’t have its own jury, it might borrow jurors from neighboring counties, or the case could escalate to federal court jurisdiction. However, such a loophole does not exist in this era, and portraying John Dutton as an omnipotent deity through this cheap trick is unjustified.

1923 Sees Alex Taking a Road Trip with Two Rich Friends in a Snow Storm

The second installment of 1923 presents a series of unlikely events, intended to depict the extraordinary journeys taken by people during that era. However, the fatal road journey that ultimately leads to Alex’s demise raises eyebrows among viewers. Given that she had already surmounted multiple challenges, such as encounters with migration officials, it seemed implausible for her to jeopardize her life on a snowy road trip when she was so close to reuniting with her husband. Additionally, it was surprising that her affluent friends would venture through the wilderness in their car, doing so even after train routes had been canceled.

In a time when everyone was aware of the perils of snow, these individuals were not just wealthy but also well-educated. Despite being forewarned about the lack of nearby gas stations, they unfortunately ran out, leading to the death of Alex’s friends in the cold. Somehow, Alex managed to endure, while tragically she herself did not survive. A few days later, coincidentally, her husband was traveling on the same train route. Sadly, Alex did not make it, but miraculously, their baby survived, born premature at just six months of gestation, without any modern medical assistance. His mother had gone for days, if not months, without proper nutrition.

Even if the Caravan Purposely Avoided the Popular Route, They Were Likely Close

In the fictional realm of Yellowstone, the narrative often amplifies the perils of cowboy existence, with Taylor Sheridan taking this concept to its extreme in 1883. During an era when death could come from numerous sources, it was simple to depict the risks associated with walking across the Wild West. Initially, the caravan consisted of around 22 wagons, suggesting a group of roughly 100 individuals. However, by journey’s end, only a few survivors were left, and it seems that only one German, Josef, managed to survive, although not unscathed.

Indeed, it was an adventurous yet precarious era, and though only about 15% of the traveling populace (numbering in the thousands, not all simultaneously) undertook this journey, the portrayal in 1883 may lead one to question the sanity of these travelers. Contrary to Sam Elliott’s claim that there were no stops from Doan’s Crossing to Montana, numerous cities with considerable populations already existed along the way. Native American attacks were infrequent, making accidents and perhaps a single unfortunate encounter the greater risks. The series seems to depict it as a trek to hell, which might explain why people still dared to make the journey despite its challenges.

Sarah Atwood, Jamie’s Girlfriend, Hires a Professional Hit to Kill Montana’s Governor

It was revealed that Sarah allegedly planned and paid for the staged suicide of a prominent political figure, with the cost being only $50 million. This organization thought that making it appear as if John Dutton took his own life would be too obvious, so they devised an alternative plan. However, it’s worth noting that John had no prior history suggesting he suffered from depression or any mental health problems.

They gave him an injection in his toe, probably causing some bruises on his body. A skilled detective (and in this scenario, possibly a federal investigator) would have noticed these signs and concluded that suicide was unlikely. Many people were content to believe Montana’s Governor had taken his own life, but if it weren’t for Kayce’s exceptional abilities, nobody would have ever suspected foul play, it seems. John’s death in the last season is consistent, but the writers might have chosen a more realistic cause of death (such as a gunshot).

Tragedy after Tragedy Meets the Dutton Family and Anyone Who Comes into Contact with Them

Pete Plenty Clouds, Runs His Horse, Jack, John, Emma, and Alex are among them. Characters like Jacob, Elisabeth, Spencer, and Alex come close to death on numerous occasions, with Jacob being shot but managing to live, Elisabeth getting shot and attacked by a wolf, and Spencer and Alex narrowly escaping death in the wilderness.

In Yellowstone, fewer main characters meet their end compared to other shows, yet a significant number of individuals (like Jamie, John, Lee, Monica’s brother, Monica’s baby, etc.) still perish. It’s astonishing how many deaths occur given that the average lifespan in 1883 was approximately 40 years. This count doesn’t include all the turmoil: abortions, murders, illnesses, attempted murders, kidnappings, and cowboy accidents. If reality mirrored the world of Yellowstone, there would barely be a hundred people left alive. Even The Last of Us doesn’t kill characters at such a rapid pace.

Alex and Spencer Are Separated after Alex’s Ex-Fiance’s Family Provoke Him and Remove Him from the Boat

To enhance the suspense of the 1923 production, Alex and Spencer should have been separated for an extended period and endured significant hardships before their reunion. Yet, it’s challenging to accept such a string of unfortunate events happening to these characters. Watching an entire season focused on people struggling through the worst luck imaginable isn’t enjoyable.

In my perspective as a fan, it seems reasonable that Alex and Spencer parted ways following their disagreement on the boat. Instead of arranging a meet-up in some European city, they didn’t. Perhaps, under the stress, the idea never crossed their minds. Interestingly, I learned that Alex had Cara Dutton’s address, an address she never used to reach out for help, not even when she was in England or America. Subsequently, both Alex and Spencer ended up taking months to arrive in America, which ordinarily should have been a 10-day journey. It seems like everything that can possibly happen to Alex does indeed happen, and this excessive drama is more than just entertaining.

They Leave the Death Bandit’s Bodies Untouched as if They Have Infinite Resources

One point that left some viewers frustrated about 1883 was the absence of survival skills shown by certain characters. For instance, when they defeated opponents, they failed to search their belongings for useful items like money, ammunition, weapons, or valuables, and they didn’t even take care of their horses. Given their scarce resources, it seems illogical that they didn’t loot the enemies’ possessions or keep the horses to help transport the wagons or other people in the caravans.

These honorable cowboys might follow a certain set of rules, but it’s doubtful. They were struggling on a perilous trail and any aid was highly valued. The TV series ‘1883’ aimed to keep a dramatic atmosphere after the fights, avoiding lightening the tension with regular robbery, but this approach ultimately left viewers feeling annoyed.

The High-Profile Crimes in Yellowstone Would Certainly Invite a Federal Agency Eventually

In the TV show “Yellowstone,” numerous crimes take place, with some being perpetrated by the Dutton family and others by intriguing characters. The Yellowstone ranch, one of Montana’s largest expanses, is often the battleground for lethal conflicts between the Dutton family, powerful corporations, wealthy individuals, and the reservation. It’s puzzling why no federal agency has looked into these matters more closely, given incidents like Dan Jenkins’ apparent demise and deals worth millions of dollars.

In the early 19th century, it might seem like two small ranches in Yellowstone were battling over livestock. However, this region was home to influential figures vying for control of vast tracts of land, potentially for future development into an airport. It’s important to note that John Dutton’s wealth wouldn’t be enough to sway federal agencies, especially considering their financial difficulties and lack of recent profits.

Every Member of the Dutton Family Should Have Been in Jail

As a passionate film aficionado, I find it striking how the Duttons seem to operate beyond the conventional boundaries of law and order. In an unusual turn of events, Jamie, a member of this enigmatic family, allegedly took the life of a New York journalist. Yet, despite clear evidence of foul play on her person, Jamie managed to evade any meaningful consequences. It’s as if John could have hanged Dan Jenkins, and there were no repercussions whatsoever.

The sequence continues. Kacey was responsible for Monica’s brother’s death, yet no one seemed to mind. They could discard remains at the “Train Station” without raising suspicion. Similarly, Beth took Jamie’s life, but no inquiries were made. In the settings of both 1883 and 1923, anyone could kill anyone, with Sheriffs serving more as ornaments than law enforcers. In the universe of Yellowstone, police probes are seldom conducted. Despite the Duttons having enough wealth to potentially manipulate every law enforcement officer and juror in the state, there should at least be a conversation about it.

Big Character Deaths, Like Lee Dutton, Were Practically Ignored in the Rest of the Series

In the world of Yellowstone, key figures are still being written off, yet the remaining characters press on, displaying a striking lack of emotional response towards their kin. The premiere episode of Yellowstone saw the demise of John Dutton’s eldest son and Monica’s brother. However, Monica seems unfazed by her brother’s passing, as well as her deceased sister-in-law and all of her nephews and nieces. The same goes for Lee; he’s rarely mentioned, as though he had never lived at all.

As a film enthusiast, I’ve noticed a recurring issue in both the original series and its spin-offs: the lack of emotional resonance when significant characters meet untimely ends. For instance, when Mary passes away in the storyline, and Claire is left to contemplate suicide, it seems as if the world around them remains unaffected. Yet, Claire was James’ sister, and Mary was his young daughter. In the new series, 1923, we witness the demise of half the family, but there appears to be minimal reaction to this tragedy. Perhaps it’s difficult for shows to depict such profound grief, considering characters meet their ends almost daily.

Read More

2025-07-05 04:12

Previous post Noel Edmonds, 76, and wife Liz, 55, prepare to wed for a FIFTH time as he pops the question in a hot tub at their home in New Zealand
Next post G2 BrokenBlade: “We were always on the back foot. Today was a disaster.”