Movies

The Haunting of Hill House: Netflix’s Chilling Adaptation of the Classic Horror Novel

BBG News

In 1959, Shirley Jackson published a novel that many consider among the best horror novels ever written. Critics hailed “The Haunting of Hill House” as the ultimate haunted house tale. This chilling and mysterious psychological Gothic horror story is often ranked one of the scariest books of the 20th century. Renowned horror author Stephen King even declared it one of only two outstanding supernatural novels from the past hundred years.

In different adaptations, The Haunting of Hill House stands out, but Netflix’s 10-hour series by Mike Flanagan takes the cake as the scariest interpretation. Unlike the 1963 film that stayed true to the book, some viewers felt it moved too slowly and the plot became muddled, with Shirley Jackson herself admitting she almost dozed off during her watch. Despite deviating from the original source material, Netflix’s adaptation is considered the superior and most authentic portrayal of the influential novel.

The Haunting of Hill House Is the Best Haunted House Story Ever Written

It’s One of the Most Influential Novels in the Horror Genre

Without a doubt, her most renowned work is “The Haunting of Hill House“, which was published in 1959. Acclaimed as one of the finest horror novels ever crafted and recognized as the quintessential haunted house tale, “The Haunting of Hill House” follows the experiences of four individuals who are gathered to spend a summer living in a supposedly haunted mansion. Under the guidance of Dr. Montague, he invites three other individuals with a penchant for the supernatural to collaborate with him in seeking empirical evidence of ghostly phenomena.

The chilling psychological horror narrative significantly impacted the horror genre, inspiring numerous writers such as Neil Gaiman, Stephen King, Joan Harris, and Richard Matheson. Upon its release, it was met with widespread critical acclaim, with the original New York Times review praising Shirley Jackson for her unparalleled skill in crafting eerie, haunting tales. Even today, decades later, this novel remains highly regarded for its chilling portrayal of Eleanor’s descent into madness as she struggles to maintain a grip on reality.

One intriguing element of the book lies in its mysterious and vague nature. Characters like Nell and others dwell within Hill House, where they encounter peculiar, unexplained incidents. Unlike traditional ghost stories, no spectral beings are directly observed; instead, these events take place in the shadows, remaining unseen. This ambiguity allows both characters within the story and readers to ponder and speculate about the haunting. Some suspect Nell possesses psychic powers, leading them to question if she was responsible for the eerie occurrences at Hill House. Others believe that Nell is the origin of the disturbances, debating whether the house is preying on her or vice versa, urging Nell to depart for her own well-being.

Despite the persistent and noticeable aura of dread enveloping Nell and her companions, she regarded Hill House as her residence. When Nell stubbornly refused to depart, she was forcefully removed from the house. They placed her in her vehicle, and Nell bid farewell to the others. Instead of leaving the property, Nell drove her car into a tree on the grounds. The novel’s conclusion is ambiguous, causing readers to ponder whether Nell crashed into the tree or if the haunted house was responsible. Whether or not Nell perished in the accident remains uncertain, adding to the chilling narrative that lingers in the minds of readers long after they’ve concluded the book.

There Are Two Film Adaptations of the Novel, Both Called The Haunting

The 1963 Film Was Directed by Robert Wise and the 1999 Film Was Directed by Jan De Bont

Ever since I first read that chilling novel, I’ve been captivated by its haunting tale. Two film adaptations have been made, with Robert Wise’s 1963 version being particularly noteworthy. Unlike the 1999 adaptation directed by Jan De Bont, which has received a mixed reception from both critics and audiences, this earlier film is widely regarded as a faithful adaptation that also stands as an essential horror movie.

While Wise’s film doesn’t show any ghostly apparitions like in the book, it retains the ambiguity that makes Hill House so terrifying. For instance, instead of attributing Nell’s car accident to mere human error, the film suggests that Hill House itself was responsible. This focus on the psychological horror resonates with many, including industry heavyweights like Steven Spielberg and Martin Scorsese, who consider it one of the scariest horror films ever made.

TitleYearDirectorTomatometer Critics Score
The Haunting1963Robert Wise87% – Fresh
The Haunting1999Jon De Bont17% – Rotten

When Mike Flanagan was initially offered the task of transforming the renowned Gothic horror novel into a ten-hour series, he doubted it was feasible. One reason for his skepticism was that Flanagan “felt there was no advantage in attempting to outdo Robert Wise’s adaptation.” Critics criticized the movie for its slow tempo and deviation from the novel’s plot. Although many praised the 1963 film, Shirley Jackson herself wasn’t impressed. In a letter to her parents, Jackson described The Haunting as “a rather poor movie; the narrative of the book was significantly altered, and there was far too much dialogue.” It might have been better for her if she hadn’t seen the 1999 film, which discards everything that makes Jackson’s novel unique.

The Haunting of Hill House Is A Brilliant Reworking of the Novel

Adapted and Directed by Mike Flanagan

Netflix’s show “The Haunting of Hill House” is based on Shirley Jackson’s novel, but needed expansion to become a 10-episode series. Flanagan explained this process by saying, “Rather than sticking strictly to the book, I found it more intriguing to dissect the novel, extract its characters, themes, and significant moments, and reorganize them.

Flanagan emphasizes the psychological elements in his horror tale, delving further into it and using mental illness as a significant motif throughout the series. Moreover, he infuses the narrative with a profound emotional dimension, focusing on the theme of grief. Each Crain child serves as an exceptional representation of a distinct stage in the grieving process.

Steven, who doesn’t accept ghostly existence, can be seen as “Skepticism.” Shirley, named after the author, symbolizes “Frustration”; she harbors anger towards Steven for his book, resentment towards their father for his secrets, and animosity towards Nell for taking her own life. Theodora embodies “Negotiation,” using her ability to swap emotions as she pleases, such as trading one emotion for another. Luke, the drug abuser, represents “Despair,” turning to drugs to escape the traumas he experienced at Hill House. The final stage of grief is “Acceptance,” which Nell symbolizes most clearly in the last episode when she embraces her destiny.

By using simpler and more straightforward language, the meaning remains consistent while making it easier for readers to understand.

In a discussion at SXSW, Flanagan shared insights about his work on “The Haunting of Hill House”, explaining that it serves as an outlet for him to grapple with grief and loss. He continues to struggle with these emotions throughout his life, but finds solace in the creative process and hopes it provides comfort to others facing similar circumstances. The theme of pain is universal, which makes Flanagan’s adaptation deeply touching and impactful for viewers. Although the story includes real ghosts and jump scares, the most terrifying aspects lie within the psychological torment portrayed by Olivia, played by Carla Gugino, as she succumbs to the house and her mental health declines.

The Haunting of Hill House Is the Best Adaptation of Shirley Jackson’s Novel

Stephen King Called it “Close to a Work of Genius”

In simpler terms, “The Haunting of Hill House” TV series is a creative take on Shirley Jackson’s novel, but it’s widely acclaimed as the most effective portrayal of the story. The eerie elements from the book are all present in the series, but they’ve been reimagined and reshaped. Key themes like the battle between psychology and supernatural, fear, and loneliness are still evident. Critics have highly appreciated Mike Flanagan’s adaptation, giving it a 93% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. One reviewer even went as far as to call it “one of the greatest horror series ever made.” Stephen King also praised the series, labeling it as “almost genius.

In a fresh take on the narrative, Flanagan elevates the story’s focus to revolve around a family. The misfortune that befallen the Crains was the curse of Hill House; even after relocating far away, the house continued to hold onto them. It’s not merely a haunted dwelling, but a place where they must confront both literal and symbolic specters from their past. Most of the Crain children were too young to fully comprehend the events surrounding their mother’s death, leading them to flee Hill House in the dead of night. As time passed, another calamity lured them back, compelling them to revisit and tackle what had transpired to them.

I affirm that Mike Flanagan successfully captures the chilling and intense sequences from the novel in his series. For instance, one of the most unsettling scenes in the book features Nell and Theo trapped in their connected rooms, with an unseen force violently shaking the doors. The sound is a terrifying mix of deafening banging and a “nauseating, demoralizing chill.” In the series, these ominous thumps echo through Shirley’s bedroom, making her suspect Theo as the culprit, but even when Theo enters the room, the banging persists. Today, as Hill House reaches out once more to Shirley, she encounters the banging yet again at her mortuary, signaling its persistent call to her home.

The Haunting of Hill House” stands out as an exceptional interpretation, breathing life into the chilling apprehension and gloom of Hill House in a way no other adaptation has, solidifying it as the quintessential representation of Shirley Jackson’s acclaimed horror novel.

Read More

2025-07-05 01:24

Previous post Noah Kahan sends fans wild as he brings out surprise guest Lewis Capaldi at his BST Hyde Park headline show – after Scottish singer’s emotional Glastonbury comeback
Next post 10 Free Vampire Movies & Shows to Sink Your Fangs Into on Tubi