This Wild Lord of the Rings Theory Ties Sauron to Faramir’s Greatest Enemy

The ongoing speculations about the storyline persistently spark intriguing fan theories, suggesting that Sauron might have been more directly linked to Faramir’s greatest adversary than initially perceived by viewers. Faramir, a character renowned for his heroism in J.R.R. Tolkien’s trilogy, always fought for Middle-earth’s wellbeing and never sought personal acclaim from victories on the battlefield. As with everyone who aimed to bring an end to Sauron’s dominion, Faramir encountered many villains from Mordor’s ranks. Yet, a particularly challenging conflict stood out as one of the most discouraging battles he had ever faced.

In the trilogy, Faramir plays a crucial part, embodying the power of those who can withstand the One Ring’s influence. He remained steadfast and faithful to the Free Folk, never showing any signs of betrayal towards his allies. His character mirrors his nobility and bravery. Despite finding contentment, Faramir faced the challenge of his father’s unjust treatment. Regardless of his accomplishments, he was unable to meet his father’s expectations, unlike Boromir. A Reddit discussion delves into a compelling theory about Denethor’s feelings, hinting at Sauron’s influence as an explanation.

A Redditor Suggests That Sauron Influenced Denethor’s Mind

To make it clear that Sauron manipulated Denethor’s perception, let me rephrase: So, viewers understand that Sauron used the Palantir to distort a vision from Aragorn’s fleet reaching Gondor, causing Denethor to think it was Sauron’s army instead. This false belief left Denethor with no will to resist further, leading him almost to surrender hope. In essence, Sauron was able to influence the sequence of events that unfolded thereafter.

One might ponder whether Sauron held a stronger influence over Denethor’s thoughts than has been previously examined. In seeking an explanation for his open contempt towards his son, Faramir, it is suggested that “Sauron understands Boromir poses no genuine threat. The Ring would easily subdue him. Therefore, Sauron taints Denethor’s feelings against the son who could wield the Ring long enough to momentarily overpower (while the Ring remains) Sauron.

This theory provides an interesting perspective, especially since it often sparks some debate. Firstly, it appears to align with the story: Faramir emerged as a morally upstanding character in contrast to the antagonist, whereas Boromir succumbed to the influence of the One Ring’s power. Despite Boromir initially joining the Fellowship of the Ring, it managed to tap into his desire for authority and dominion.

Instead of clinging to Faramir due to shared traits, the Ring found fewer hooks in him. This suggests that Sauron might have been wiser to devise an alternative strategy to destabilize Faramir. A Redditor noted that Gandalf acknowledged the strong Númenórean blood in both Denethor and Faramir. By influencing Denethor’s judgment against his own son, Sauron could not only corrupt his perception but also distort reality for him. This would further erode Denethor’s mental fortitude.

It’s true that the One Ring has the power to corrupt anyone’s mind eventually, and Aragorn would not be an exception. However, it might take longer for someone like Faramir to fall fully under its influence. This theory suggests that Sauron could eliminate Faramir as a threat much earlier if he targeted him sooner rather than waiting for a scenario similar to Boromir’s fate to unfold.

Sauron didn’t have a personal fear of Faramir, but he was mindful of Faramir’s strengths and talents. To deal effectively with his adversaries, he often chose finesse over direct conflict. Manipulating Denethor against Faramir involved a mental battle, which would intensify the struggle within Gondor, allowing Sauron to focus on other aspects of the War of the Ring.

It’s important to consider the harmful influence Saruman exerted on King Théoden through Gríma Wormtongue, which indirectly shows just how potent the darkness in Middle-earth could be. This reinforces the belief that Sauron might have had a sinister hold over Denethor as well, underscoring the extent of his power.

There Were Reasons that Denethor Preferred Boromir

It’s challenging to confirm fan theories about Tolkien’s stories as absolute truths because Tolkien wrote his tales meticulously, leaving very few plot holes. This complexity in the narrative may explain Denethor’s unbalanced perspective on Faramir. The Lord of Gondor experienced significant emotional trauma early in life when his wife passed away shortly after their youngest son, Faramir, was born. This tragedy might have led him to associate Faramir with his deceased wife’s death or even blame the young boy for it.

As they matured, the contrasting personalities of the brothers became more apparent, and Denethor found himself appreciating Boromir, despite seeing traits in him that were reminiscent of both siblings. Boromir embodied typical male qualities, confident in his combat skills and unafraid to charge into battle. Denethor admired his boldness and warrior spirit.

Despite being an accomplished warrior, Faramir didn’t derive satisfaction from battle itself; instead, he was deeply invested in the causes he was fighting for. His words, “I don’t admire the sharp sword, nor the swift arrow, nor the brave warrior for their glory. I love only what they protect,” perfectly encapsulate his character: steadfast and with a broader perspective on warfare, as contrasted to Boromir.

Denethor also felt envious towards the connection between Faramir and Gandalf, especially since their beliefs were very similar. He grew suspicious of Gandalf’s intentions, despite considering the Wizard’s moral compass as insufficient, much like he did with Faramir’s gentle demeanor. On a simple level, it was painful for him to witness his son admiring someone else, which affected his self-esteem.

Indeed, it’s worth noting that Boromir held the line of succession as future Steward of Gondor. Given this circumstance, Denethor might have placed great emphasis on Boromir’s high status, potentially overlooking his younger son in the process. Managing Gondor seemed to be a primary concern for him, which appeared to overshadow the affection he displayed towards others.

These instances offer sufficient clarity regarding Denethor’s partiality, yet it doesn’t negate the value of exploring the fan theory further, given its alignment with the storyline’s potential developments. Denethor is a multifaceted character, encompassing various aspects in his storyline. Besides contributing to the larger conflict, he also had personal struggles, such as his relationship with his sons, to confront.

Boromir Supported His Brother Over His Father

One particularly touching aspect of Denethor’s family relationships is how tightly knit Boromir and Faramir were. The films make it evident that Boromir was not swayed by their father to disregard his brother. In fact, he defied Denethor, a scene shown in the movie when he says, “He may not get your approval, Father, but he is trying to fulfill your wishes. He loves you, Father.

Through Boromir’s decision to love his brother without any sense of superiority, viewers gained insight into the richness of his character. Despite his occasional sternness, his reaction to the temptation of the One Ring revealed a complex and nuanced individual. Such scenes provided audiences with a comprehensive understanding of his true nature.

Furthermore, he demonstrated that it was possible to embody both the role of a warrior and the capacity for love without contradiction. He managed to be a caring brother towards Faramir, accepting and valuing his unique qualities, while still maintaining his strong leadership. Denethor didn’t have to opt for one role over the other; he could respect his children equally and appreciate their individual strengths.

In Tolkien’s work, and later in Peter Jackson’s adaptation, there is so much more than just a fantasy setting filled with battles. At the heart of the story lie themes such as loyalty, love, friendship, and courage. The intricate subplot involving Denethor, Faramir, and Boromir serves to highlight the depth and richness present in “The Lord of the Rings.” Such character-driven scenarios make the story appealing to a broader range of readers, including those who may not be as captivated by the intellectual nuances found within the finer details.

The intricate complexity of the story encourages fans to delve deeper in search of hidden meanings and develop theories, enhancing the richness of the trilogy and showcasing the artistic elegance. Indeed, when it comes to Tolkien’s work, it’s rare to find any unresolved plot points. However, conversations focused on Middle-earth and its potential mysteries are always captivating.

Read More

• Clash Royale Best Boss Bandit Champion decks

• Vampire’s Fall 2 redeem codes and how to use them (June 2025)

• The MongolZ leave s1mple in their dust at the BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025

• Spirit battle MOUZ in Austin for a chance to keep their CS2 Major crown

• NAVI oppose Vitality at BLAST Austin Major to stop their phenomenal win-streak

• JOOPITER’s sacai x SEVENTEEN Auction Sets Record for Highest-Selling LABUBU

• Honor of Kings KPL Growth League (KGL) Summer 2025 kicks off across three Chinese venues

• TH vs WOL. The first goodbyes at VALORANT Masters Toronto

• Wolves and Gen.G face off in a fierce VALORANT Masters Toronto showdown

• Simply powerful! FaZe are about to crash their way to Stage 3 of CS2 BLAST Austin Major 2025

2025-06-07 05:38