Movies

Disappointed Horror Fans: Watch This Underrated Slasher with 85% Rotten Tomatoes

BBG News

As a cinephile, I’ve been eagerly anticipating the Netflix release of the 2025 high-school movie, a delightful throwback to the genre films of the ’70s and ’80s. Known for its campy charm, this flick is an adaptation of R.L. Stine’s 1992 novel.

Regrettably, it seems my latest effort hasn’t resonated as I’d hoped, garnering similar dissent from both critics and viewers. Currently, the ratings stand at a disheartening 27% and 25% on Rotten Tomatoes.

If you’re missing a fresh take on modern horror after watching “Fear Street: Prom Queen”, I’d recommend checking out the distinctly different “Tragedy Girls”.

Tragedy Girls Puts Twists on Common Tropes

Similar to Fear Street: Prom Queen, Tragedy Girls draws upon nostalgic elements of classic slasher movies. Yet, it distinguishes itself through its exaggerated self-awareness and dark wit. This film follows two teenage true crime enthusiasts, Sadie and McKayla, as they delve into the mystery of a serial killer in their town. However, the lure of social media fame proves irresistible, causing the girls to unwittingly become accomplices in murderous activities. The audience gets the anticipated jump scares and gore, while remaining on edge due to the early revelation of the culprits, leaving them wondering when the other shoe will drop.

This film shares similarities with the iconic dark comedy “Heathers”. Unlike traditional portrayals where women are often victims, this movie switches roles and presents women as perpetrators, even challenging the concept of the ‘final girl’. However, it offers a flexible perspective, allowing viewers to delve into a deeper discussion about gender stereotypes in antagonists if they wish, or simply enjoy the film without engaging in such analysis.

Instead of building suspense effectively, Fear Street: Prom Queen makes its plot twists too obvious, leaving little room for surprise even for casual viewers. Critics have pointed out that the film doesn’t bring anything new or groundbreaking, not even within the Fear Street series. Although it can provide some light entertainment, the movie struggles to establish a strong presence, which ultimately hinders its ability to make an impact or leave a lasting impression.

The Cast Is Stacked with Familiar Faces

2017’s alternative version boasts a noteworthy ensemble, with Brianna Hildebrand, famed for her role as Negasonic Teenage Warhead in Deadpool, and Alexandra Shipp, recognized from the X-Men series, Barbie, tick, tick… BOOM!, among others, headlining as Sadie and McKayla.

It’s evident that Hildebrand and Shipp are creating characters who seem mentally unstable. Yet, their raw energy is so captivating that it becomes challenging not to cheer for them, despite their involvement in various illicit actions. With the help of the supporting cast, they successfully infuse humor into the film, even during its most grim scenes.

In comparison, the cast members of “Prom Queen” might not be as well-known as those in “Tragedy Girls”. Furthermore, many of the performers find it challenging to make their characters endearing, even under difficult circumstances.

Director Tyler MacIntyre Could Easily Make a Sequel

For years now, enthusiasts on the internet have been clamoring for a follow-up to the movie “Tragedy Girls”. Considering the ending of MacIntyre’s film, a sequel could potentially expand upon the narrative without damaging its reputation. Horror productions have garnered success in 2025, implying that a skillfully promoted “Tragedy Girls” sequel could be exactly what viewers are yearning for.

The untapped potential seen in “Prom Queen” is unfortunate. Instead of delivering another chilling horror experience as fans anticipated following the successful release of the “Fear Street” trilogy in 2021, this film unfortunately falls short and marks a disappointing continuation. It’s now evident that the franchise must evolve to steer away from its current path.

Essentially, “Tragedy Girls” offers a lively twist on the subgenre compared to “Fear Street: Prom Queen.” This cleverly self-aware slasher film delves into its frequently absurd and over-the-top plotline with an enthusiasm that deserves recognition.

Watch the movie “Tragedy Girls” for free on platforms such as Tubi, Plex, and Pluto TV. You can also access it through Prime Video, AMC+, Disney+, and Hulu, but these last options require a subscription.

Read More

2025-06-03 03:07

Previous post Who knew they were friends? Aussie singer Dannii Minogue catches up with Married At First Sight’s Mel Schilling in London
Next post VALORANT Pride Month 2025: New buddy, title, and more