Why Chris Evans’ Return in Avengers: Doomsday Could Ruin Sam Wilson’s Captain America

by

It can be argued that Steve Rogers’ return in May might cause more trouble than benefit for Sam Wilson as Captain America. Steve Rogers is a key figure with significant impact within the Marvel universe. As the original Avenger, he played a crucial role in forming the team and steered them during critical times when the world was in peril. He led his team effectively, ensuring they provided optimal protection to civilians while neutralizing threats.

In the movie “Avengers: Endgame”, Steve Rogers’ story concluded. Following their victory over Thanos, restoring half the universe’s population, and experiencing the loss of close companion Tony Stark, Steve felt it was appropriate to retire. During his journey returning the Infinity Stones to their original places in time, Steve chose to return to Peggy Carter and enjoy a life he could have lived if not frozen. Moreover, Steve selected Sam Wilson as his successor and bestowed upon him his shield, allowing his friend to continue the Captain America legacy.

Brave New World Once Again Uses Steve Rogers To Challenge Sam Wilson’s Captain America

Sam Wilson Has Proven Himself Repeatedly In The MCU

Although Captain America himself has given his approval, many find it challenging to relate to Sam Wilson as the latest Captain America. This issue was significantly explored in “Captain America: Brave New World”, where characters like Thaddeus Ross expressed their doubts by saying “you’re not Steve Rogers.” Similarly, this theme of questioning Sam’s worthiness or the insurmountable nature of replacing Steve Rogers was a central focus in “The Falcon and the Winter Soldier”. Given that fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe who haven’t kept up with the shows may need a reminder, reiterating this point helps progress Sam’s narrative.

Instead of overemphasizing the point, Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) should strike a balance. Sam Wilson has convincingly taken up the mantle of Captain America, demonstrating his competence beyond doubt. Although he’s not Steve Rogers and lacks the super soldier serum, their differences in time and unique life experiences make his tenure as Captain America promising, impactful, and heroic. A seasoned soldier with years of fighting alongside superheroes, Sam has the heart to be the world’s new Captain America. He is poised to guide a fresh team of Avengers to become Earth’s Mightiest Heroes, even amidst their rivalry with The New Avengers.

Chris Evans’ Captain America Return Risks Undermining Sam Wilson

Having Competing Captain America’s Is A Recipe For Disaster

Sam Wilson is striving to legitimize his title as Captain America and lead The Avengers, but another group also wants that name. It wouldn’t be beneficial for his narrative if he were diminished further. Although it would be thrilling to have Chris Evans reprise his role as Steve Rogers in the MCU, it doesn’t align with Sam’s evolving storyline. If Rogers appears and reinforces his endorsement of Sam, having them both together could make Sam seem like a secondary character once more.

Doomsday” could negatively impact Sam Wilson’s role as the new leader of the Avengers within the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This is because it might create confusion and undermine the progress made to establish Sam Wilson as the new Captain America. While bringing back Evans might generate some nostalgia, it would not be beneficial for the overall quality or consistency of the storyline.

Chris Evans’ MCU Return Still Seems Likely In Some Way

Chris Evans Could Appear Again Before The Multiverse Saga Ends

It seems quite plausible that Marvel Studios may reprise Chris Evans for either “Avengers: Doomsday” or “Avengers: Secret Wars.” Given the conclusion of the Multiverse Saga, this could offer an opportunity for such appearances to fit seamlessly into the narrative. Notably, Evans has already made a comeback in “Deadpool & Wolverine,” reprising his role as Johnny Storm from the 2005 “Fantastic Four.” Given Evans’ significant role in shaping the MCU over the past 18 years, and with the universe currently undergoing major changes, bringing him back could serve as a fitting farewell.

Additionally, the fact that Robert Downey Jr., who played Tony Stark in the MCU before, is returning as Doctor Doom raises many possibilities. Although it’s uncertain how his character will be portrayed given that comic book Doom usually keeps his mask on, there’s a chance they might keep Downey’s face concealed throughout. However, reuniting Downey and Evans on screen once more could be hard to resist for the Russo Brothers, who are directing, or studio executives who feel the nostalgic appeal is worth any complications that may arise.

How Chris Evans Can Return Without Hurting Sam Wilson’s Captain America

There Is Another Version Of Captain America Who Could Appear

If the Marvel Cinematic Universe decides to incorporate Chris Evans in either “Doomsday” or “Secret Wars,” there are several methods they might use without compromising Sam Wilson’s status as Captain America. The character Evans portrays significantly impacts how seamlessly he can reappear. For instance, playing Johnny Storm would be less problematic as his character deviates greatly from Steve Rogers, exhibiting more relaxed morals and a carefree demeanor. However, there is another way Evans could portray Steve Rogers without causing inconsistencies.

Recently, Steve Rogers underwent a significant transformation in the comics, moving away from his traditional all-American, heroic self. The twist was that he turned out to be a sleeper agent for HYDRA, shocking other heroes who saw their friend morph into a dangerous villain. Introducing HYDRA Rogers could serve as a means to solidify Sam Wilson as the new Captain America, effectively defeating Steve Rogers and claiming the title. However, if this storyline appears in Avengers: Doomsday, it should respect Steve’s legacy.

Read More

2025-06-01 14:58