‘1923’ actor Jeremy Gauna on taking over Cole Brings Plenty’s role after his death: ‘It’s my purpose’
“1923,” the “Yellowstone” prequel, is back for its second and final season.
In the second season, the character of Pete Plenty Clouds was re-interpreted after the passing of Cole Brings Plenty, who portrayed a shepherd in the first season. Now, Jeremy Gauna steps into the role, carrying forward the narrative of Pete Plenty Clouds.
Last April, Brings Plenty, a 27-year-old actor, tragically passed away in Kansas City. His family had reported him missing following an alleged domestic violence incident, and his body was discovered a week later. The authorities have yet to disclose the cause of death, but they’ve confirmed that there were no signs suggesting any form of suspicious activity.
In November, the late actor’s father, Joe Brings Plenty Sr., expressed his desire to uncover the truth about his son’s circumstances. He stated, “We seek a thorough and impartial investigation, one that will shed light on what transpired with Cole,” during the Red Nation Film Festival in Los Angeles.
In July, when filming resumed, showrunner Taylor Sheridan opted to replace the character of Pete. Gauna was chosen for this role, having previously appeared as Tall Shadow in “American Primeval” on Netflix, along with minor roles in “The Last Son,” “The Harbinger,” and another “Yellowstone” spin-off titled “1883.
The actor spoke with The Times regarding honoring Brings Plenty, whom he regarded as a dear friend, and taking on the fresh character – a role he referred to as his “mission.
This interview has been edited for clarity.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9f5d3/9f5d3fa3e12ed02ddd337422b43c45d559bf2e42" alt=""
Television
As a passionate movie enthusiast, I’m saddened to share that there’s no indication of any untoward incidents leading to the demise of the talented actor, Cole Brings Plenty, who brought Pete Plenty Clouds to life in Taylor Sheridan’s ‘Yellowstone’ offshoot, ‘1923.’
In other words, you’ve made an appearance before within the “Yellowstone” world, as you were a significant character in “1883.” Can you share how you felt when asked to return for another role?
Yeah, I was the Native that shot and killed Elsa in “1883,” which is a pivotal part of the show.
To begin with, it’s important to mention that this opportunity has come at the cost of Cole Brings Plenty in reality. It was a challenging call to receive, but it was also a mix of sadness and joy. I lost a dear friend, someone who was deeply rooted in our community. However, I was also able to pay tribute to my beloved friend and his family.
I didn’t realize you and Cole knew each other. How did you guys become acquainted?
Our friendship blossomed through online platforms, and I had the added advantage of knowing his uncle, Mo Brings Plenty from “Yellowstone,” which led me to connect with him. We grew quite fond of each other and would frequently communicate daily. He would share his life’s ups and downs with me, expressing excitement about his upcoming role in “1923.” His enthusiasm for this part was palpable, as he couldn’t believe he’d be featured in every episode. It’s hard to accept the current situation.
To achieve that role, I realized it was something much greater than myself. I’m not seeking recognition or rewards. Instead, my goal is to ensure everyone acknowledges and respects him, as I believe this is my mission. While some people may not fully comprehend this, I have wholeheartedly understood it, and Cole has been by my side every step of the way during this journey.
After you got the call to step in as Pete, how did you begin to approach or prepare for this role?
To put it simply, I reached out to Cole through prayer and rituals. I was figuring out the best way for Pete to proceed and how to handle the space previously occupied, all the while infusing a bit of my personal touch into him.
In a show of respect, both to my ancestors and to Cole, I pledged, “I’m committed to contributing by learning the language, preserving the tribe’s heritage, and acknowledging your prior work on Season 1. At the same time, I aim to serve as a strong, unyielding support for everyone navigating the emotional journey.” This was my way of expressing gratitude for their efforts and showing dedication to the task ahead.
Television
The family of Cole Brings Plenty states that they are yet to receive any clarification regarding the cause of the ‘1923’ actor’s demise, despite police investigations concluding that no foul play was involved several months ago.
What was the atmosphere like on set? Were there any moments where you could feel Cole guiding you?
There were several instances when Cole seemed to make astute, subtle remarks, such as “I wouldn’t have done that” or “I’m not sure that was a good idea.” I could sense his disapproval. However, the moment I emerged from the trailer for the first time, playing Pete, proved to be particularly challenging, especially for Aminah [Nieves, who portrayed Teonna Rainwater, Pete’s love interest].
Upon entering the dressing room, an air of solemnity filled the space, as it was evident something had changed. After getting dressed and posing for photos, I was preparing to depart when my team suggested I glance at the mirror before going. I hesitated but they insisted “for your own sake.” As soon as I did, a wave of emotion swept through everyone, causing tears to stream down their faces. I exited to find Amina, and what followed was a heartwarming encounter where she expressed her feelings. In that moment, I simply had the chance to comfort her, assure her of my presence throughout the journey, and share a tender hug.
In that critical situation, it was clear that my role was to provide comfort and reassurance, letting them understand that despite the process, Cole’s spirit remains with us.
From the standpoint of Cole’s relatives, there remain unresolved queries about his demise. I wonder how your characterization of Pete might strike a chord with those who are grieving him.
In a heartfelt manner, his family welcomed me deeply into their lives, sharing with me their realms of sorrow and anguish, as well as their feelings of relief, happiness, and the captivating essence of life. It nurtured me when I transformed into Pete. It provided me the liberty to act as if Cole was by my side, instructing me. As an artist, I felt like Cole was directing my actions and bringing forth abilities within me. It wasn’t solely myself; it was a higher force flowing through me, enabling me to perform at my peak capacity. When I revisit footage, I can sense that it isn’t merely me. Instead, it’s Cole propelling me forward, and the ancestors leading me to deliver the performance that was essential.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/95f76/95f76653ba0b25c3a034cdf18e66305312f14365" alt=""
Awards
At her residence in Lake Tahoe, the actress engages in activities such as kayaking, swimming, and hiking. Additionally, she takes on various adventures in the vast western landscapes when appearing on television. However, it’s not accurate to label her as “sporty.
Were there any moments where you were doubtful or felt like you couldn’t take on Pete’s character?
As a cinephile, I never wavered in my conviction throughout this journey. There wasn’t a single moment of apprehension or doubt that crossed my mind. I wholeheartedly entrusted the task to Cole, with respect to our ancestral lineage. I was clear about what needed to be done to complete the mission, which is why I dedicated myself entirely to preparation and hard work.
Occasionally, the year “1923” can be quite graphic, particularly when it comes to depicting Native American characters. What makes such portrayals striking within the narrative?
Why does it seem that the depiction of certain events in 1923, especially those involving Indigenous people, stand out more prominently within the story?
This material is so far beyond comprehension, I struggle to grasp it. Among the multitude of stories – some factual, others fictional – this particular one has been toned down, as there are accounts even more harrowing than what you’re seeing now. Although it may be difficult to endure, it’s essential that people watch it because they might not have been aware of its existence before. What makes it challenging to watch is that parts of it are based on truth.
If these tales aren’t shared, history may reoccur, which is something we should avoid at all costs. Instead, we need advancement, growth, and improvement – not just for humanity as a whole, but for each individual. I believe that everyone has their unique story, and until we all get the chance to listen to one another’s stories, it will be challenging for everyone to grasp the lessons if they don’t make an effort to learn them.
“1923” streams Sundays on Paramount+.
Read More
- Cookie Run: Kingdom Pure Vanilla Cookie (Compassionate) Guide: How to unlock, Best Toppings, and more
- Reverse 1999 Willow Build Guide: Best Team, Psychubes, and more
- Cookie Run: Kingdom Black Sapphire Cookie Guide: How to unlock, Best Toppings, and more
- MAFS Star’s Secret Split
- Classic ’80s movie is finally getting sequel – and fans will be delighted
- The Handmaid’s Tale star to reprise role in spin-off series
- Monster Hunter Wilds director thinks the weapon balance is much closer this time: “They’re all hopefully nearly as viable as each other,” but he’s “confident, not cocky”
- Half-Life 2 and Dishonored Artist Viktor Antonov Has Passed Away
- Yellowstone and It Ends With Us star Brandon Sklenar lands next movie role
- Shocking Double Elimination Leaves Fans Reeling on I’m A Celebrity Australia!
2025-02-26 01:31