Movies

A “muppet” episode would kill Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ good will

BBG News

A "muppet" episode would kill Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' good will

As a gamer with over three decades of Star Trek fandom under my belt, I must say that the latest iterations of the franchise have left me feeling rather conflicted. On one hand, Strange New Worlds has delivered some truly captivating episodes that harken back to the golden age of Star Trek. Yet, on the other, there are moments where it feels like they’re trying a bit too hard to be quirky or unique, often at the expense of the show’s integrity.

One challenge faced by the Nu Trek era shows is the frequent inconsistencies that arise due to Alex Kurtzman’s leadership, as it appears he aims to explore various aspects within the franchise while still struggling to create a genuinely captivating Star Trek series. Often, these productions either lean too heavily on darkness, veer off course from the intended themes of the series, or simply fail to embody the spirit of Star Trek.

It appears he has successfully tackled Star Trek’s Prodigy and Strange New Worlds, yet neither show is without flaws. To be precise, Strange New Worlds often contains quirky elements that the creators add which can distract fans from the core experience. While these offbeat episodes may attract some fans, many Star Trek enthusiasts prefer a more traditional approach and dislike such gimmicky instalments.

Initially, during the first and subsequent seasons of the series, the producers and scriptwriters introduced an unfinished “fantasy” episode where each character was portrayed as a fantastical version of themselves. Later on in the second season, viewers were asked to tolerate a musical episode featuring dancing Klingons. This episode seemed to be enjoyed by some fans.

The vast majority of the show’s episodes aren’t particularly well-liked, as “Subspace Rhapsody” from the second season and “The Elysian Kingdom” from the first season rank near the bottom on IMDB, with ratings of 6.8 and 6.2 respectively. Most other episodes score an 8.0 or higher, indicating that these specific episodes aren’t as well-received compared to the rest of the series.

Despite facing numerous challenges, the program has managed to persevere primarily because of the exceptional quality of each season’s episodes. In essence, the show has been nothing short of extraordinary, amassing a considerable amount of goodwill in the process. The series is resilient enough to handle occasional setbacks. However, even the most devoted fans have their breaking points.

It appears that certain enthusiasts within the Star Trek community are advocating for the show Strange New Worlds to feature a “muppet-themed” episode. During a recent Star Trek convention in New Jersey, one spectator posed a question to the series’ lead actor Anson Mount (Captain Christopher Pike) about the possibility of such an episode, using the term ‘muppets’. In response, Mount seemed puzzled but did not rule out the idea. This information was reported by TrekMovie.com.

Twice already someone has asked me, “Where is this located?”… Well, let me clarify first, we’re not given any information by default. It would be fascinating to hear the discussion that led to this concept being approved for a network. However, I suppose, theoretically speaking, anything could happen in science fiction.

Frankly, such changes could ruin the essence of the series. While Star Trek occasionally exhibited a playful side, it never degraded to self-mockery. There was an endearing quality about its seriousness, which was mostly maintained. However, the contemporary team behind the show doesn’t seem to share the same reverence or appreciation for Star Trek as their predecessors did. They continue to propose and approve ideas that seem to contradict the original spirit of the series.

The show, Strange New Worlds, occasionally strays from being a moral tale. Fans didn’t seem to enjoy the fantasy episode or the musical episode, but we keep getting more of these unpopular formats. If they introduce a puppet episode in season three, it would be hard to justify such a choice. The show isn’t supposed to be Muppets Tonight, and no one is asking for Star Trek to become that kind of program. Honestly, I don’t think many people genuinely feel this way.

What’s the point of making it seem as if it belongs there when Star Trek can be a bit goofy on occasion, but in an unintentional way? Even though it may appear so at times, it’s not really trying to be funny. Why would anyone want to strip Star Trek of its unique charm and transform it into a shallow franchise like the MCU or any other current series, copying their formula?

Instead of saying that, it isn’t what it currently is, and it shouldn’t be permitted to transform into that, if they produce an episode featuring puppets, I have concerns about how the fanbase might react, and it may not be as favorable as we all anticipate.

Read More

2024-11-24 05:23

Previous post Cate Blanchett cuts a quirky figure in a monochrome jumpsuit as she attends the Camerimage closing ceremony in Poland
Next post Sylvester Stallone sells original painting for nearly $500K at charity auction