8 Hidden Gem Shows You Can Only Watch On Prime Video

Everyone talks about shows like The Boys, Fallout, and Reacher as Amazon Prime Video’s biggest successes, and they are! But Prime Video offers much more than just those popular titles. There’s a wealth of other, often overlooked, series that are equally worth watching. Prime Video really shines because of its variety, offering both big hits and fantastic hidden gems.

If you’ve already seen the popular shows and are looking for something a little different, Amazon Prime Video has a lot of hidden gems. You’ll find everything from realistic dramas to strange science fiction and suspenseful thrillers – proving that Prime Video offers a surprisingly wide range of quality series.

These hidden gems on Prime Video all offer something special – from captivating stories and well-developed characters to beautiful visuals. If you’re looking for shows beyond the usual recommendations, these are definitely worth checking out.

Homecoming (2018-2020)

Homecoming’s Tense Mystery And Surreal Direction Make It One Of Prime Video’s Best-Kept Secrets

Homecoming is a gripping and suspenseful psychological thriller featuring Julia Roberts as Heidi Bergman, a social worker who helps soldiers adjust to life after service. The series, directed by Sam Esmail (known for Mr. Robot), masterfully turns everyday office routines into something strangely disturbing and captivating.

Every scene is carefully designed, creating a feeling of mystery through stark offices, quiet moments, and a non-linear timeline. Julia Roberts gives a standout performance, portraying Heidi’s journey to uncover the secrets of the Homecoming Initiative with both vulnerability and suspicion. The second season, featuring Janelle Monáe, broadens the scope of the story while maintaining its suspenseful and personal atmosphere.

If you enjoyed mind-bending shows like Severance and The Leftovers, you’ll likely love Homecoming. It’s a captivating series that combines a puzzling mystery with genuine emotional resonance. The show excels at creating a sense of unease, making even peaceful scenes feel tense and unsettling.

Tales From The Loop (2020)

Tales From The Loop Turns Sci-Fi Into A Haunting Meditation On Humanity

Inspired by the beautiful, vintage-futuristic art of Simon Stålenhag, Tales From The Loop is set in a quiet Midwestern town centered around a mysterious machine that can change reality. Each episode tells a separate, poignant story about feelings of isolation, the power of love, and how time passes, all wrapped in a thoughtful and slightly sad science fiction setting.

The show unfolds at a measured pace, giving the audience time to appreciate its stunning visuals and heartfelt stories. Rebecca Hall delivers a powerful performance as Loretta Willard, a physicist whose personal struggles with loss and a sense of awe make the show’s more fantastical elements feel real and relatable.

If you enjoyed the thoughtful, quieter episodes of Black Mirror or the atmospheric feel of Station Eleven, you’ll likely love Tales From The Loop. This show, available on Amazon Prime, is a hidden gem that beautifully combines science fiction with heartfelt storytelling, leaving a lasting impression.

Patriot (2015-2018)

Patriot’s Dark Humor And Deadpan Style Make Espionage Strangely Relatable

Patriot is a unique spy thriller. Michael Dorman plays John Tavner, an intelligence officer whose secret assignments are constantly messed up by office politics and his own personal struggles. The show blends intense espionage with the humor of a quirky workplace comedy, and the combination is surprisingly effective.

Steven Conrad brings a unique blend of humor and sadness to every scene in Patriot. The show makes the world of spying feel surprisingly personal, showing the funny and heartbreaking sides of John’s life, whether he’s writing songs about his secret work or dealing with a frustrating everyday job.

Patriot is a uniquely charming and strangely emotional show – if Barry and Fargo had a family member, it would be this one. It’s one of Prime Video’s best kept secrets, blending oddball humor with surprisingly heartfelt moments.

Dead Ringers (2023)

Dead Ringers Redefines Psychological Horror Through A Feminist Lens

This new take on the 1988 film Dead Ringers features Rachel Weisz in a captivating role, playing both Beverly and Elliot Mantle, twin gynecologists. The series delves into disturbing physical transformations and a deeply unhealthy emotional connection between the two, offering a daring and disturbing look at who we are, what’s right and wrong, and the power of obsession.

The series is striking, blending a sterile, almost surgical aesthetic with vivid, symbolic imagery. The actors deliver powerful performances, creating a connection between the twins that is both frightening and deeply moving. It’s a bold show that tackles difficult and rarely discussed topics surrounding women’s health, motherhood, and personal drive.

If you enjoyed shows like Hannibal or the intense psychological thriller Sharp Objects, you’ll likely be captivated by Dead Ringers. It’s a beautifully unsettling horror series that doesn’t shy away from dark themes, and it’s one of the most daring original shows on Prime Video.

Undone (2019-2022)

Undone Blends Rotoscope Animation With Mind-Bending Storytelling

Prime Video’s show, Undone, is strikingly creative in its visuals. It uses a unique animation technique called rotoscope to tell the story of Alma Winograd-Diaz (Rosa Salazar), who gains the power to control time after a serious accident. The show starts as a puzzling mystery but quickly becomes a deep and moving story about loss, family, and how we see the world.

Bob Odenkirk plays Alma’s late father, and appears to be helping her uncover what really happened to him – though it’s unclear if he’s a real presence or a figment of her imagination. The show uses hazy, dreamlike imagery to create a sense of being inside Alma’s confused and fragmented thoughts.

If you connected with the emotional depth of BoJack Horseman or the mind-bending time travel of Russian Doll, Undone delivers a similar experience, but with a completely unique approach. It’s a deeply personal, thought-provoking, and visually beautiful show – a true hidden gem that more people should discover.

The Tick (2016-2019)

The Tick’s Absurdist Heroism Brings Heart And Humor To The Superhero Genre

Before shows like The Boys popularized gritty, realistic superheroes, The Tick stood out as a delightfully strange option. Peter Serafinowicz stars as the incredibly optimistic and seemingly indestructible Tick, who partners with Arthur, a normal accountant played by Griffin Newman, to fight crime in a city full of mysterious bad guys.

This show on Amazon Prime Video is a delightful mix of spoof and tribute, blending silly humor with a surprisingly heartfelt superhero story. Its unique and charming style makes it stand out from the often-grim trend of deconstructing the superhero genre.

If you like the humor of shows like Harley Quinn or Peacemaker, you’ll probably love The Tick. It’s a unique and surprisingly touching show with a lot of creative ideas, and it’s no surprise it’s become a fan favorite – especially with a 95% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Prime Video really gave this show the space it needed to thrive.

The Devil’s Hour (2022-Present)

The Devil’s Hour Mixes Crime, Horror, And Time-Bending Mystery Into One Gripping Thriller

The Devil’s Hour follows Lucy Chambers (Jessica Raine), a social worker who is plagued by frightening visions and consistently wakes up at 3:33 a.m. Her strange experiences become connected to a series of murders, leading her to an encounter with a mysterious and unsettling criminal (played by Peter Capaldi, known for his role in Doctor Who).

This British thriller expertly mixes spooky, supernatural elements with a classic police procedural, creating a complex story that reveals itself gradually through flashbacks and fragmented memories. Peter Capaldi gives a particularly strong performance, playing a character who is both frightening and captivating, and Raine provides a powerful emotional core to the often chaotic events.

If you’re a fan of suspenseful shows like Mindhunter or Dark, you’ll likely be hooked by this hidden gem on Amazon. The Devil’s Hour demonstrates that Prime Video can deliver the same unsettling and sophisticated thrills as high-quality shows from other networks.

The English (2022)

The English Is A Visually Stunning, Emotionally Charged Western Unlike Any Other

Westerns on television have become increasingly popular recently, and Amazon joined the trend in 2022 with the series The English. The show features Emily Blunt as Cornelia Locke, a woman from England determined to get revenge in the harsh American West. She teams up with Eli Whipp (Chaske Spencer), a former Pawnee scout, and together they journey through a dangerous and morally complex landscape.

Considered one of the finest Westerns of recent years, The English is beautifully directed and filmed, bringing to mind the visual styles of The Revenant and Westworld. However, beyond its stunning landscapes, the series tells a moving and intimate story about healing from trauma, the search for justice, and the foundational stories of the United States.

If you enjoy shows like Deadwood or Yellowstone, you’ll likely love The English. This TV western on Amazon Prime Video isn’t just a great find—it’s a surprisingly overlooked gem. It’s a beautifully written, stark, and haunting modern classic that truly stands out from everything else available.

2025-10-26 02:02