2025 Horror Movie With 92% on RT Becomes a Streaming Hit

by

The horror movie Eye for an Eye, which was released in theaters in 2025 and received great reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, is now a huge success on streaming platforms. It’s become the most-watched film on HBO Max and has reached the top spot on streaming charts thanks to strong viewership.

Eye for an Eye (2025) tops all streaming movies on HBO Max

As of February 16, 2026, “Eye for an Eye” is the most popular movie on HBO Max worldwide. It’s currently ahead of all other films in the top 10, which includes “Valentine’s Day” at #2, “M3GAN 2.0” at #3, “Land of the Lost” at #4, “28 Years Later” at #5, “28 Days Later” at #6, “Friday the 13th” at #7, “28 Weeks Later” at #8, “Woman of the Hour” at #9, and “Eddington” at #10 (according to FlixPatrol).

The story of Eye for an Eye centers around Anna, a teenager who moves to Florida to live with her grandmother after the death of her parents. She makes new friends and falls in with a group, but soon finds herself in a difficult situation and is deeply affected after seeing something violent.

Colin Tilley made his first feature film as director, and Elisa Victoria and Michael Tully collaborated on writing the screenplay.

Whitney Peak stars as Anna in the series. The cast also features Laken Giles, Finn Bennett, Golda Rosheuvel, S. Epatha Merkerson, Carson Minniear, and other talented actors.

Critics on Rotten Tomatoes gave the film a very positive score of 92%, while audiences rated it at 71%.

I’ve been reading the early reviews, and things are looking really good for this film! Luna Guthrie at Collider said it grabs you right from the start. She admitted the story isn’t groundbreaking, but it executes that simple idea with a really strong, clear vision, making you care about what happens almost immediately.

Mark Dujsik from Mark Reviews Movies noted that while the movie’s idea wasn’t original, it was still quite effective.

Karina Adelgaard from Heaven of Horror praised the film’s impressive worldbuilding, but noted that a bit more character development or backstory could have improved it. She also felt the movie was a little too long, with some scenes slowing down the pace. Despite these minor issues, she highlighted the film’s strong production quality and effective use of practical effects.

Originally reported by Abdul Azim Naushad on ComingSoon.

Read More

2026-02-17 19:49