10 Supernatural Episodes You Must Rewatch for the Ultimate Monster Thrill!

Over 15 seasons on The CW, Sam and Dean Winchester navigated the battle against darkness, riding their iconic ’67 Chevy Impala. Along for the ride were fans, experiencing the highs and lows of the hunting lifestyle. During its initial run, the show was filled with numerous villains, particularly in its early years when it had a more episodic feel. As the series matured, it shifted towards serialized storylines, sometimes losing some of the allure it once held while providing thrilling Monster-of-the-Week episodes.

Delving into the deeper meanings of Supernatural, it’s often when the Winchester brothers shine brightest – that is, while they’re fulfilling their duty, which involves vanquishing supernatural beings. Ranging from well-known creatures like werewolves and vampires to lesser-known mythical beasts of local folklore, Sam and Dean have tackled them all. Here are some episodes you might want to revisit as they hit the road again.

Season 1, Episode 2, “Wendigo”

In the first hunt of the premiere season of Supernatural, Sam and Dean face a challenging creature based on Native American folklore. Following the death of Sam’s girlfriend Jessica, the brothers set off to Colorado, guided by cryptic coordinates found in their father’s hunting log. Upon reaching Black Water Ridge, they discover that several hikers have vanished in the area. Local rangers share details about the disappearance of Haley Collins’ brother, which piques the interest of Sam and Dean.

Upon realizing that these disappearances seem to align with the coordinates their father provided, my brothers and I choose to seek out Haley for further information about her brother. With hesitation, we consent to allow Haley to join us on our journey into the ominous depths of Black Water Ridge, where we hope to find Ben and our missing father. Upon examining John Winchester’s journal, my brother Sam and I determine that we are dealing with a Wendigo – a once-human creature that has been transformed into a monstrous being after consuming human flesh. The early episodes of Supernatural possess an eerie atmosphere, and the towering, swift Wendigo fits seamlessly within this unsettling narrative.

Season 1, Episode 5, “Bloody Mary”

The tale of Bloody Mary is commonly heard among groups of teens looking to frighten each other during sleepovers, and this isn’t any different in the world of Supernatural. In this particular episode, a group of friends persuade another friend to say the chilling phrase “Bloody Mary” three times in front of a mirror, leading to tragic consequences. At the funeral of the deceased boy, the brothers meet two friends who witnessed the Bloody Mary ritual. They investigate the crime related to the occult and subsequently examine the deaths of women named Mary.

In the fictional world of Supernatural, burning the leftovers of a ghost or spirit is usually how they defeat a ghoul. When Sam and Dean find out that Mary’s remains have been burned, they decide the best strategy to overcome her is by summoning her spirit in a mirror. This method, as previously discussed, tends to give the series a more horror-oriented atmosphere. The well-known urban legend of Bloody Mary, which shares similarities with this practice, can greatly enhance the fear factor for viewers who may have experienced such sleepover rituals in their past.

Season 1, Episode 7, “Hook Man”

Just like the chilling story of Bloody Mary, the tale of the Hook Man is resurrected. Sam and Dean are summoned again to delve into a series of gruesome murders that have been haunting a college town. The Hook Man’s initial murder echoes his legend: a young woman is left alone while her companion steps out of the car to explore an unusual sound, only to be discovered dead and hanging above the vehicle when she decides to investigate herself.

Sam and Dean reach the location following a hint they gathered from a nearby café regarding some unusual events happening. Upon uncovering tales about a murderer possessing a hook for a hand, the Winchester siblings delve into local records and stumble upon accounts of a 19th-century preacher who had killed 13 women in 1862, using a hook as a replacement for his severed hand. Although no bones of the preacher were found, they continue their search for the hook itself with the intention of eliminating the town’s terror. This scenario represents another example of capitalizing on public anxiety with a chilling, timeless narrative.

Season 2, Episode 20, “What Is and What Should Never Be”

In the TV show Supernatural, it’s important to think twice before making any desires known. According to Islamic tales, Djinn inhabit forgotten ruins, which is where Dean falls prey to the malevolent power of a mischievous genie at the beginning of an episode. Teasing Sam about the Djinn’s wish-granting abilities, Dean searches for a remote location that he believes would be suitable for a genie. However, his jest soon turns into a reality as he gets ambushed and finds himself in a world that feels strangely unfamiliar.

In a different rendition: Dean experiences a vision of a reshaped past in which he’s back at his boyhood home in Lawrence, Kansas. Perplexed because he barely remembers the altercation with the Djinn, Dean is welcomed by his mother, Mary Winchester. The scenes that follow depict an imagined scenario where Mary didn’t perish and the brothers were spared from hunting. This heart-wrenching and unsettling episode of Supernatural Season 2, Episode 20, forces Dean to confront this alternate reality, only to lose his family once more.

Season 4, Episode 4, “Metamorphosis”

In the TV series ‘Supernatural’, there might be a reference to the Cajun or French legend of the rougarou/loup-garou, where a man turns into a beast with an appetite for human flesh. The rougarou in this context is similar to the Wendigo rather than the traditional werewolf. Characters Sam and Dean are summoned to examine the mysterious actions of Jack Montgomery.

As I sat there, mesmerized by the latest horror flick, I found myself struck by an unsettling truth about the rougarou: this shape-shifting beast is completely oblivious to its own transformation until much later in life. It’s a chilling thought, one that sends shivers down your spine as you watch Jack succumb to his primal urges and give into the savage instinct to kill and devour his fellow man. The moment he takes that first life, the process of metamorphosis is set into motion – the line between man and monster forever blurred.

Despite their close bond and shared history, Jack’s family are no strangers to the hunt. They are experienced hunters, skilled in tracking down and slaying beasts that most would run from in terror. But as they stand there, facing off against Jack – now a ravenous rougarou – they can’t help but feel a pang of sorrow for the man they once knew. In the end, it falls to them to bring an end to this twisted cycle, to put down the monster that was once their friend and family member. It’s a grim reminder that sometimes, even those we love most can become monstrous in the face of uncontrollable urges.

Season 3, Episode 8 “A Very Supernatural Christmas”

In the realm of Supernatural, Christmas isn’t always about warmth, family, and cheer. Instead, it becomes a time for investigating chilling mysteries, like the spate of murders where victims seemingly ascended chimneys. This year, Sam and Dean found themselves drawn into an intriguing holiday puzzle. As they delved deeper, an elderly couple caught their attention – they were none other than pagan deities with a unique vulnerability: stakes forged from evergreen wood could bring their reign to an end.

The show takes us through memories of Sam and Dean’s past Christmases during their childhood. As the younger Sam finds his father’s diary, it becomes clear to him that monsters exist. Meanwhile, the siblings are dealing with pagan gods in the present. However, what resonates deeply is the loss of Sam’s innocence and joy related to Christmas, which serves as a crucial aspect in portraying the life of a hunter.

Season 4, Episode 5 “Monster Movie”

During Oktoberfest, Sam and Dean come across a victim with neck bite marks, leading them to suspect the perpetrator is a vampire. However, this assumption gets complicated when the following victim exhibits signs of a werewolf attack. After some investigating and verifying that two eyewitnesses reported seeing a vampire and a werewolf attacking separate victims, the brothers conclude that the creature involved must be a shape-shifter.

The narrative unfolds with a vintage Universal monster movie feel, in stark black-and-white splendor. To keep up with the theme of classic monsters, a mummy awakens from its museum tomb and assaults a security officer. It turns out that the Winchester brothers were right when they claimed this was the doing of a chameleon-like creature with a fondness for horror flicks. On the TV show Supernatural, shape-shifters are creatures capable of assuming any person or beast’s appearance. This episode is particularly memorable and embodies the Monster-of-the-Week structure by incorporating various elements of old-school cinematic scares.

Season 6, Episode 9, “Clap Your Hands If You Believe”

In Elwood, Indiana, Sam and Dean are probing into recent vanishings, as the TV series ‘Supernatural’ delves into the possibility of extraterrestrial life. It subtly interweaves folklore about fairies and leprechauns to create an intriguing connection. As Dean exhibits typical symptoms of alien abduction, Sam’s investigations guide them towards the enigmatic beings from Irish legends. Initially bewildered by this discovery, the narrative gradually unveils the bizarre occurrences hidden beneath Elwood’s surface.

As a devoted cinephile, I stumbled upon an intriguing tale about a fellow town resident, Mr. Brennan, who allegedly conjured a leprechaun in an attempt to revive his struggling enterprise. My siblings and I were tipped off by a woman named Marion about the fairies causing all the chaos. She shared with us that these magical beings have a peculiar fondness for cream and are meticulous counters of every speck of salt, so beware if any grains accidentally spill! This episode is filled with such whimsical, over-the-top antics that it’s hard to believe this isn’t straight out of a fantasy movie. Although past episodes might have had a more eerie vibe, this one is downright entertaining and full of zany twists!

Season 7, Episode 18, “Party On, Garth”

In Sam and Dean’s realm, the Shojo represents vengeful spirits from Japanese folklore. This is something Garth has encountered in his latest hunting case. He’s reached out to the Winchester brothers for assistance, as he believes he may be dealing with either a ghost or a vengeful spirit, though the assaults seem more like those of a beastly creature.

The story opens in a forest where a gang of adolescents are present. One among them jumps at a noise and spots an apparition-like figure that others can’t perceive. Frightened, he runs deeper into the woods, where his friends later find him lifeless after hearing his terrified cries. In due course, the trio discovers that this specter, called Shojo, appears only when one is under the influence of alcohol. This spectral entity is summoned through a cursed flask of sake, which was once owned by the local brewery’s proprietor. Similar to the previous case, this episode turns out to be quite engaging as Sam, Dean, and Garth have to keep themselves inebriated to catch a glimpse of the Shojo.

Season 8, Episode 4, “Bitten”

As a devoted fan, I’d say that for me, Supernatural shines brightest when it delves into the realms of traditional monsters. One chilling instance involves Sam and Dean being summoned to a college town due to a string of mysterious deaths that initially appear as wild animal attacks. However, upon further inspection, these incidents prove to be something far more sinister. A group of students were filming a project in the woods when they stumbled upon a heated argument between a couple. Upon seeing them, the students decided to retreat, only for one of them to be brutally attacked off-screen. The viewers are left to witness this horrifying event through the lens of the camcorder being used.

As a cinephile, I found myself in an unusual situation when, after the attack, I visited the doctor and was given the all-clear to return to our dorm. In the ensuing days, I experienced powers beyond my wildest dreams, leading my friends to speculate if I’d become some kind of superhero. This sparked a brilliant idea – why not film this incredible transformation and create a documentary? Little did we know that my encounter was with a werewolf, and I was gradually transforming into one myself. In time, our entire group fell under the curse. What sets this episode apart is its innovative cinematography, immersing the viewer in a first-hand, found footage documentary experience.

Read More

• The Last of Us season 2 confirms spring 2025 release on HBO

• Cookie Run: Kingdom Boss Rush Season 2-2 Guide and Tips

• Clash Royale Best Boss Bandit Champion decks

• Terrifying Sally Hawkins horror Bring Her Back finally confirms UK release date

• ‘Bring Her Back’ Release Date SHOCK! You Won’t Believe When It Streams!

• Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Ending—Maelle or Verso? All Endings and Twist Explained

• Everything We Know About ‘Ginny & Georgia’ Season 3: Plot, Cast, and Release Date Revealed!

• Bring Her Back, one of 2025’s must-see horrors, called a “stressful nightmare” that will leave you “squirming”

• ReMemento – White Shadow, the Korean turn-based RPG is launching globally this May 2025

• Pokémon TCG Pocket drops trailer for a new themed booster pack, Extradimensional Crisis

2025-05-26 19:39